@PGTorontoGuy @PMoehringer@NotMrTibbs Babe Ruth led the league in HRs at 23 & never stopped. A-Rod was a 40 HR guy at 22. Barry Bonds was an MVP at 25. They were good young and never stopped being good. David Ortiz was a scrub...until he joined known PED user Manny Ramirez and failed a test himself in '03.
@PGTorontoGuy @PMoehringer@NotMrTibbs IDK how you argue there isn't a case against Ortiz. There was no evidence at all against Jeff Bagwell and whispering was enough to delay his HOF induction. Ortiz has the survey, ties to a proven (and shameless) user and a rate of production relative to age w/o precedent.
@PGTorontoGuy @PMoehringer@NotMrTibbs The survey isn't the only thing. His production did skyrocket after becoming teammates with a known user. He did play at a very high level at an age not exactly consistent with the way bodies work.
For real, his production relative to his age has few, if any, precedents.
@PGTorontoGuy @PMoehringer@NotMrTibbs Now I'm agnostic about guys not caught post-testing program. I'd put Bonds in. I'd put Clemens in. I'd put Sheffield in. I'd probably even put Ortiz in. I just refuse to put a halo on his plaque or entertain anyone who would.
@PGTorontoGuy @PMoehringer@NotMrTibbs Again, you're acting like the survey is a total non-factor. It's not. Manny was caught in it. Sammy Sosa was caught in it. Jason Grimsley was caught in it. A-Rod was caught in it. Those are all either widely suspected or legit caught PED users.
@PGTorontoGuy @PMoehringer@NotMrTibbs David Ortiz was a replacement level player 6 years into his big league career. Then he joins Boston, with known, proven PED user Manny Ramirez, and immediately goes on a HOF track. His first year with Boston? 2003. When was the PED survey where he was caught? 2003.
@PGTorontoGuy @PMoehringer@NotMrTibbs So where's the proof against Bonds or Clemens? Neither has admitted use. Neither ever tested positive. Any connection between them and PEDs is still hearsay.
@PMoehringer@NotMrTibbs Has anyone as closely tied to PEDs as him received enough support to get in at all, let alone the first ballot? Bagwell & Piazza were talked about, but neither is known to have failed a test.