Wow I had this crazy dream that after suffering historic losses by an electorate that ranked corruption as their top concern, the losing side declared that Congressional investigation of corruption is a crime. Oh wait…
@dccopley1951@MasonHickory@NEWSMAX There is nothing in The Federalist linking Vattel and the NBC clause. You're inventing your own history.
"Scalars?" 🤣🤣
It matters what the SCOTUS says, because no judge reading the case precedent will rule Rubio ineligible.
@dccopley1951@MasonHickory@NEWSMAX The SCOTUS (backed by much legal/historical precedent) states "natural-born citizen (like many other Constitutional terms), derives from the common law and follows the same 'jus soli' rule.
The "Vattel theory" is Obama-era pseudo-history.
@dccopley1951@MasonHickory@NEWSMAX There is no "citizen parent" requirement. All persons born in the U.S. were (are) considered n-bc (save for limited exceptions). The U.S. followed the English 'jus soli' principle which the Framers were well-familiar.
@dccopley1951@MasonHickory@NEWSMAX The Framers expressed concern that a Euro aristocrat or royal might come to the U.S., naturalize, and use their wealth or prestige to gain the CIC/executive office. By limiting that to persons who were born citizens and waited at least 35 years it impeded ambitious foreigners.
@PokerPolitics There was a Q-tard thread a week ago where one woman chimed in "It's exhausting living in 2 realities."
My thought was "You're SO close to getting it."
I'm kicking myself for not saving it, because it summed up so much.
@TalesTucson@AngryFleas I've found that if you put a few dozen freshly baked cinnamon rolls on top and cover everything over, security and other observers can be told you're bringing meals for election workers. It throws them off the scent, as it were. 😀
@bensonkc2601@dsmarquez424@kymonarch@hday1125 There are only 2 types of citizen: natural born and naturalized. The 14A refers to both.
SCOTUS in U.S. v Wong Kim Ark (1898), stated "natural-born citizen" includes most all children born in the U.S., even to alien parents (with limited exceptions).
Rubio is eligible.
@saulrosenberg77@PogueMoran@t_f_bow We've been denying and debunking Brunson-type claims since 2020. That case was an example of "Same Sh*t, New Day." And that case is now dead.
@RyanAFournier Trump will fight. He'll fight to make sure GOP candidates in 2028 are those who exhibit the greatest fealty towards him, bestowing primary endorsements to the most MAGA candidates out there. Which means 2028 should be another good year for Democrats
@PogueMoran@saulrosenberg77@t_f_bow Plus, the statute of limitations for causes of action pertaining to the 2020 election expired no later than January, 2026. No merit. Time-barred. [Edited and reposted to correct the year]
@gturner6ppc@ImAhappySparky@corujasabiaa@PatrickRuffini The lower courts will rule that way (or possibly avoid a merits ruling via justiciability (e.g., standing or ripeness). The appellate court will slow-walk it till primary elections are largely done. Then mootness can be invoked.
Courts don't want to affect elections directly.
@gturner6ppc@ImAhappySparky@corujasabiaa@PatrickRuffini A fair summary. Though I argue children born abroad who are citizens at birth have "de facto" eligibility, as no court is going to rule otherwise. Courts (the one unelected branch) REALLY don't want to alter elections in that way if they can avoid it.
@saulrosenberg77@t_f_bow The decision at the District Court was that Brunson's claims were barred due to sovereign immunity. That is a ruling on the merits. Both appellate courts let that stand.
The case is dead. That you purport to see flies buzzing around the corpse doesn't mean the corpse is alive.
@t_f_bow@saulrosenberg77 Is this person so daft he doesn't know the SCOTUS denied the Brunson petition? Or does he know and just wants to pretend otherwise?
@PokerPolitics "Leaves" -- more "Trump dies while in office." Trump's ego will never let him step down. He can't give up the spotlight, the grift. Thinking strategically about the future of the GOP isn't in his DNA.