@skyfire1984@catholicpat personally if I were god I wouldn't make people knowing they would sin and then punish them for doing what I knew they would do from the start, but maybe there's some divine wisdom I'm missing there
@skyfire1984@catholicpat god could make sin not have consequences out side of the individual, right? he's the arbiter of everything, to my understanding. he decides what is and isn't a sin, yes?
look, I'm no theologist, but I have a strong sense of fairness and a lot of what god does seems unfair
@Papist_X@catholicpat with regards to god doing the stuff to job, he may not have done it himself, I misremembered that, but he let satan do it and I still think that's cruel and wrong of a being that claims to be all loving
I dislike things that aren't fair/hurt innocent ppl, that's all
@Papist_X@catholicpat it's been a while since I've read it tbh, I'm not religious and wasn't raised religious so my memory isn't gonna be perfect. iirc, the gist of it was god saying something like "where were you when I made the earth?" basically saying god was above him and had divine wisdom n stuff
@FiorilloRalph @mampdx @catholicpat I'm glad you feel that way. it sounds like your faith makes you happy and enriches your life, which is what it should do. I'm not trying to convince anyone to not believe, I'm just explaining why I can't
I really am happy you feel safe and loved through your faith, though
@FiorilloRalph@catholicpat god killed job's children. loving someone who does that to you isn't unconditional love, it's stockholm syndrome
now if the story is allegorical, that'd make way more sense even if I disagree. but the version I read treated it as literal
@Papist_X@catholicpat you can believe what you like. truly, if you find comfort in god I think that's wonderful. I think as long as you aren't hurting anyone, you should be free to do what you want and I don't mean this as an attack
the op posed a question and I explained my reasons. that's all
@Papist_X@catholicpat it's not about the message, it's about the fact god was cruel to somebody who had done nothing wrong. god killed job's children. I don't believe child murderers are good
@skyfire1984@catholicpat that means they knowingly inflicted that pain onto humanity, which is cruel and wrong. if god exists and I meet them when I die, I'll have a lot of fucking questions for them
@skyfire1984@catholicpat if god is truly all knowing and all powerful, every human being was created knowing who they would be and what they would do (which calls into the question of free will anyway), so god made every dictator, every rapist and murderer, knowing what they would become
@catholicpat and from that point I extrapolated to all the suffering in the world, really. if god is truly all powerful and all loving, then he should act like it. because the world I'm looking doesn't reflect that idea
@catholicpat I read the bible
but specifically it was the story of Job that made me angry. an innocent, good man was tormented for no good reason. that's not what a loving deity would do. at that point it wasn't about if god existed or not, it was about if I could worship someone like that