Honestly I find it quite funny how Umamusume Phalaenopsis has pink menko, when the late 90s filly that won the Oka Sho and wore a pink menko was the one who won it a year earlier
(Yes this is a thread exploring the similarites and differences of Kyoei March and Phalaenopsis)
@telewaifus@rdrisms I mean if it was a stallion itd be dancing brave if anything (juddmonte colors on hair + it'd still technically be a Kyoei March reference)
@sagespells My favorites from various genres
Desert Cruiser - Truckfighters
The Romantic Warrior - Return to Forever
Trackrunners - Asheru
Mars, Bringer of War - Gustav Holst
Intro - Alan Braxe
On one hand I can definitely acknowledge that Erdenali isn't a flash in a pan. Many euro connections have attempted the mile CS, ranging from Immortal Verse, Charyn, Docklands, Sahpresa, and so on
Heck it is definitely true that euro places a lot of respect on the mile
@fagnestachyon Would Ten Bob Tony or Gstaad have won the Mile Cs? Or Deterministic? Or Docklands if he came this year again?
Why is it now suddenly that Erdenali is just the average euro thoroughbred?
@fagnestachyon Yeah it's not like any sociopolitical factors made JP horses hesitate to go to the DSC/DT
But I suppose those aren't real g1s too and the fact that Reve/Sixpence/MaBo all sucked huge ass in the belly of the beast means that keiba hasn't progressed since the 80s
@sraurane Horse wins the marois as a 3yo and i'm supposed to pretend like he's an average 3yo miler?
I really do not mean to downplay his win because it is freakish + excellently won by Barza with style but like at the same time I just don't think JP miles are that weak
Why is erdenali winning a sign that JP racing in itself is weak and faltering? That the scene needs to "wake up or whatever?" Was French racing weak because Taiki Shuttle beat them at the Marois? Why can't we assume that Erdenali's just a freakish generational talent?
@BWADW_Real@fagnestachyon Yeah man I like a fucking bum ass division
How dare I enjoy my stupid fucking weak ass division
The best JP miler just retired and the good jp milers rn are still green cmon man
Obviously keiba is far from being saved by these. But I think it's a disservice to the game and a bit of an insult to those who enjoy it, to flatly say that the game has no positive effect on keiba at all (even if Royal Family could be said to be way more influential)
In my humble and totally unbiased opinion, the only thing one can say keiba is best at is promoting the horse itself as the product. Not betting upsides or the depth of the game but merch/100 yen throwaway bets/bloodlines/POG magazines
As well as private horse related entities such as Northern Horse Park likewise doing things like that CDawgVA vid with Hitomi Ueda at NHP or the mini doc where Cheval and Burapi's VAs take care of the horses there.