Wrong. Anyone who has made financial progress starting with nothing has started with a budget and sacrifices. I can recall a time that my fun money was $5 a month- and that is what I spent. The amount of people willing to sacrifice and live within there means so they can climb out is less than it was previously. Today people feel like a certain standard of living is a human right- and it never was.
Should it not be at least somewhat eye opening that all people who agree with Kevin- came from all different backgrounds and have made something from what they were given? And everyone that disagrees hasn’t yet figured it out. Back in the day people used to want to learn from wealthy folks- not condemn them.
This is an uneducated take and oversimplifies decisionmaking to one round of action with no room for secondary and tertiary impacts. What happens to price when demand increases? What happens to supply when the price is not allowed to go over what the government is willing to pay? What happens when demand goes up and supply goes down? This naive take hasn’t considered any of these likely realities.
@0xdavecryps Ill take things that didn’t happen for $500. Funny how 4 days ago you didn’t have kids but today you have childcare expense. Maybe your lack of keeping track of your own children roll over to your budgeting skills.
@BillyGoatRuff69@0xdavecryps He doesn’t have kids - but has child care expense. I just saved him a ton of money by helping him realize this fact. Problem solved.
@4Gt2Hate@jackybh What is the definition of excess profit? Its an undefinable and silly concept that will ultimately unoptimoze the workforce after
You consider several rounds of this game playing out.
I mostly agree with your point of view but remember that there is nothing keeping workers from buying stock in the company with their wages. Many public companies make it even more enticing by the use of stock purchase plans where they match stock purchases -
Which can double the investment- or more.
You can apply talent in sports very similarly to talent in the business world and by doing so, you will see how unequal your view is. Do every player on a team deserve to be paid the same as Lebron James or Leo Messi? Of course they dont- it is an absurd premise. Now how about you or I getting paid the same as Leo Messi or Lebron James because we have made a few baskets or played in High School or whatever. You not understanding the value that some people can really provide society from a business sense is your blind spot.
I can’t speak for y’all but I can speak for me. I am not conditioned and grow weary of the online jump to conclusioning that you have done here. I make no judgements on you but O do make judgements on this line of thinking in this post. I have studied these matters extensively and have degress to prove it. In my spare time - I read books on economics and have studied each form of economic theory more than most. I seek truth in everything I do and take no ones word for it as everyone is serving somebody. The judegments I make are my own and am open to a real measured argument for what you are talking about.
In my view it does not pencil. There has never been a system in our world that you can give away money that is not earned at this scale and it not be detrimental in many ways to our monitary policy, our ability to trade with other nations, our national private and public work force and many other factors. As far as taxing the rich more, it is nice in theory but has many shortcomings that must be faced.
Look at our federal budget- add on how much health care for all will cost. Add on how much universal basic income will cost. Compare it to the entire wealth of the richest 1% and you will find they cannot pay for it- an honest assessment of the full supply and demand ramifications would push substantial increases far into the middle class. We are talking 40-50% taxes on your payroll + a national sales tax of up to 25% on most of your purchases.
The impact of this level of taxation will have impacts so far reaching they are hard to model and are not included in any study I have seen saying how cheap it will be to implement these ideas.
It is doubtful that you have made it this far as I am long winded. But I felt the need to - at the minimum- demonstrate that I have thought about this a great deal. Agree with you that it sounds nice- but at least would line to challenge your thought process on this topic to say that many who want to implement the above have not fully wrestled with the complications necessary for me to think it is a great idea.
@DJpolyD_@KennyTinTaiwan@scottsantens Yes it’s like magic! If we did 10k a month that much more would go into the economy and none of us would need a job at all. Its a win win win win.