Dear Senator-Elect @AbdulElSayed
What you're suggesting is that Israel should abandon its Jewish identity to qualify as a state that respects equality, dignity, and freedom. But why should Jewish self-determination be incompatible with democracy when national identity and equal citizenship can coexist?
I'm speaking to you from a Muslim to a Muslim, let me remind you that Jewish sovereignty in the Land of Israel is not a modern invention. Its roots go back some 3,000 years, to the time of a prophet and king whom you and I recognize in Islam: Prophet David (Dawud), peace be upon him.
Now, here's my question: There are 57 member states of the Organization of Islamic Cooperation, many of which explicitly identify with Islam in their constitutions, laws, or national identities.
Why don't you demand that they abandon their religious and cultural identities? Why is the world's only Jewish state expected to surrender its Jewish character to earn your approval?
I'm not calling you a radical, Abdul. But your argument echoes a central demand of radicals who refuse to accept Jewish sovereignty under any circumstances.
For them, the problem isn't Israel's policies. It's the very existence of a sovereign Jewish state.
And history has heard this argument before...right after Alexander the Great.
More than 2,000 years ago, the Seleucid rulers tried to suppress Jewish religious life in Judea. But the Maccabees resisted, reclaimed Jerusalem, and rededicated the Temple. Their struggle eventually paved the way for renewed Jewish independence under the Hasmonean dynasty.
And do you know what Jews around the world still celebrate in remembrance of that victory? Hanukkah.
Even Jesus, whom YOU and I revere, was in Jerusalem during Hanukkah, as recorded in John 10:22–23. This is how deeply Jewish history and the struggle to preserve Jewish identity are rooted in the very traditions we respect.
Hannukah is all about a Jewish refusal to surrender their identity, faith, and freedom to foreign domination.
And here's what makes your argument particularly troubling: Israel's own Declaration of Independence explicitly promises equal social and political rights to all citizens, regardless of religion, race, or sex, while affirming Israel as the Jewish state.
We can and should demand that Israel honor that promise. We should also defend Palestinian dignity, rights, and self-determination. But none of that requires denying the Jewish people's right to national self-determination.
Equality for all citizens and Jewish sovereignty are not mutually exclusive.
History matters, Mr. Abdul. And I encourage the Jewish voters who supported you to revisit their own history and consider the implications of your words.
Peace cannot be built by asking one people to surrender the national identity we accept in so many others.
Best regards,
Loay Alshareef
So they’re making Michael randomly go after this woman he shown absolutely no interest in before while his friend is in jail I mean, don’t make Michael look like a sleaze or turn into Drew. It’s really gross. We don’t need a Michael and Jordan pairing. No one asked for this.#GH
@donwinslow@hakeemjeffries Even AOC supports him because she understands what the job entails. It can’t be a zealot. Has to be Switzerland. That’s how you get a consensus!
I remember when Hillary won the 2016 primary by FOUR MILLION VOTES and the shouty lefties all screamed for her to resign to make room for the loser Bernie! We do the work, we win, they shout for us to step down and let them "win!" How many times are y'all gonna fall for it?