@MomaBera@cremieuxrecueil Not sure why this is surprising. It isn't to me.
What I will point out is that this appears to be more about healthcare than about pensions, and that demographic shifts make this worse.
We are keeping more people alive longer, and this is expensive.
@TaliaGraceSable Indeed.
The math behind this is that donating 10% extends time to hit FI by~25-30% in many cases, which is a big deal.
Image-based work changes many FIRE assumptions too - being able to easily go back to work allows the portfolio to be a lot more risky.
@DaystarEld@tracewoodgrains "murder and jaywalking" refers to this argument:
A: murder and jaywalking is bad, ban it
B: jaywalking is fine, let's not ban murder and jaywalking
A: why are you against banning murder?
here the metaphor stretches, but "jaywalking" maps to "any monitor that humans build".
@DaystarEld@tracewoodgrains pretty sure the crux here is "absolute guarantee".
If we define the hypothetical with the monitoring being a magic genie, my model is many more people vote "yes".
If instead the monitoring is "the government promised", my model is many more people vote "no".
@DaystarEld@tracewoodgrains My counterpoint to the "I did not eat breakfast today" point (which is a good point) is from the other side it feels like the "we want to ban murder and jaywalking" argument.
@DaystarEld@tracewoodgrains My intuition pump for this is "if we build this in real life, and the people who build the monitor are 100% honest and committed to this, and they get it right, do the NSA/DoD/etc have a backdoor to technology this powerful"
plausibly yes, hence monitor trade is not worth it.
@DanRosenheck gutsy.
you get credit for be willing to go against the crowd.
this is good for people like me who want to combine expert models to get a blended forecast.
when the models herd, they're not independent. same with polls
alas, you're still gonna be wrong.
it's not a flip.
@oscredwin@CoughsOnWombats@patio11 So a specific point here is that at e.g. Vanguard specifically, you don't have FDIC insurance on investments (not a bank!), but you do have SDIC up to $500k.
But, I still think if Vanguard were hacked and someone lost a ~$1m 401k/retirement fund, they're made whole anyway.
@CoughsOnWombats@oscredwin my instinct says secure for the Vanguard/Fidelity class of institution, but I am also interested in opinions from either @oscredwin's inner patio11 or actual @patio11
@_NathanCalvin As much as I appreciated your coverage of Anthropic's poor draft AI bill, an S1 is different, especially for a company of the size of Anthropic.
"Anthropic may prioritise safety" is about the best I expected, the S1 is defensively written for good reason.
@So8res I roll to disbelieve.
Certain people at OpenAI, who wanted the three researchers removed, stood to gain from strengthening their internal position by pretending Greenblatt might have leaked.