ce.

[ふーちゃん @fchan_aewin]

ニンニン楽しくなっちゃったのかなwwwめちゃかわいい🥹🥹🥹

[🌩️ @roxknnroll]

웃음터져서 babo됨

[ce. @cheesepalea]

lmao I'm dying

[KETCHUP AND LEMONADE @NING2Xningmeng]

Since when did Ningning's position in the group change?

[ce. @cheesepalea]

A Level 5 Karina fan posted this before Ningning even spoke out，and you're still trying to call them a Ningning fan? The evidence is right there. Now that your lie's been exposed, are you embarrassed yet?@ChinaKarinaBar

[CHINA NINGNING Bar @NingNing_Bar]

Beneath the post made by the hater whom Ningning responded to, someone used this image. If you have a conscience, don’t continue to question this.

[ce. @cheesepalea]

@rareriroru00 @NingNing_Bar Baby, maybe figure out the difference first. Fanwars are fanwars. Using edited photos of someone's family to repeatedly harass them crosses into criminal behavior. Don't argue until you understand that

[ce. @cheesepalea]

@NingNing_Bar Can @ChinaKarinaBar explain why you're bending over backwards to defend antis while smearing innocent ppl? Are you seriously working with them, or is this just how far you'll go to protect your own side?

[ce. @cheesepalea]

@NingNing_Bar @ChinaKarinaBar You made false accusations and spread baseless rumors to defame Ningning and her fans without a shred of evidence. Apologize.@ChinaKarinaBar

[ce. @cheesepalea]

Some Karina fanbases need to face what happened instead of rewriting the story. Just bc the ones responsible are ur akgae doesn’t give u a free pass.
Spreading lies to protect ur side is disgraceful. Stop covering for them. Stop being accomplices

[CHINA NINGNING Bar @NingNing_Bar]

Please stop fabricating lies and claiming that this is the behavior of Ningning’s fans. Please explain who the fans of the person Ningning responded to and those who left these hateful comments actually are.@ChinaKarinaBar

[ce. @cheesepalea]

@okaydokeyu @yizgal No matter how many times you move the goalposts, it won’t change the fact that ur twisting the narrative, spreading bullshit, and running defense for absolute scumbags. Embarrassing

[ce. @cheesepalea]

@okaydokeyu @yizgal Mate at least keep ur bullshit consistent. First you claimed ningning wasn’t even liked in China. Then after getting called out, you switched to ‘you don’t understand Chinese culture,’ and now ur crying ‘racism.’ Pick a fucking lane

[ce. @cheesepalea]

The comments are proving exactly what ningning has been dealing with all this time, relentless, baseless abuse. It's fucking disgusting. She should just send these ppl straight to jail instead of only warning. These scumbags and trash don’t deserve any forgiveness

[CHINA NINGNING Bar @NingNing_Bar]

We urge that the discussion not be steered toward fan conduct, interpersonal dynamics among members, or fandom rivalries, as such diversions would only serve as a further tacit endorsement of the harm inflicted upon her.

[ce. @cheesepalea]

Don't rewrite history. Those accounts got suspended for a reason, and your meltdown says it all. Funny how "stupid, nasty, and always starting shit" describes you way better than anyone else

[Sella @por_tirina]

@NingNing_Bar 死臭不要脸，宁艺卓应该告自家大吧呀，毕竟为了给队友泼脏水宁愿骂亲妈教女无方，这应该就是粉随正主又蠢又坏爱作妖吧

[ce. @cheesepalea]

@okaydokeyu @yizgal Nbdy asked where u live, that has nthn to do w anything. ur still talkin outta ur ass. learn the topic before making a fool of urself

[ce. @cheesepalea]

@okaydokeyu @yizgal You used a VPN to come on X and lecture me about learning Chinese? lmao the audacity. Go back to wherever the fuck you came from and keep posting your garbage, you English illiterate clown 💀

[CHINA NINGNING Bar @NingNing_Bar]

[Statement on the Defense of Rights]
A Solemn Statement Regarding NINGNING's Legitimate Rights Protection focusing on the Facts of Harm to Family Members:

[Pop EMPIRE @PopEmpirex]

Aepsa's Ningning won the ‘Top K-Artist (Female Solo)’ award on Billboard Korea, Billboard China, and the TME Chart.

[aespa @aespa_official]

aespa 에스파 'KISS N TELL' MV Teaser Image 2

https://t.co/PjsdyQKxH9

aespa 에스파 The 1st Japan Mini Album 〖KISS N TELL〗
➫ 2026.07.24 0AM (KST/JST)

💿Pre-order&save
https://t.co/79G5HWs2XB

#aespa #æspa #에스파 #エスパ
#NINGNING #닝닝
#KISSNTELL #aespaKISSNTELL

[ce. @cheesepalea]

Oh so now we’re talking about ‘protecting members’? When ningning was massively cyberbullied by jnetz, where was her leader and those unnies?
But now you want her to babysit your akgaes instead of her own mom? The hypocrisy is insane

[s. @aespalogist]

the way she's protecting her akgae more than her members like girl be serious 💀

[ce. @cheesepalea]

Stop gaslighting. Fan wars happen all the time, no one expects idols to babysit their fans. But the second someone drags ningning’s mom into it, she’s not allowed to defend her own mother?????
What kind of mom less freak gets mad at that? Touch some grass you absolute clown 💀

[Kkkkkkkkkkk @youx411]

You stayed silent while your fans spread disgusting rumors about Karina & her father. But when someone used your mother's photo as a pfp, you suddenly knew how it feels when family is targeted? Who started this? None of this would've happened if you'd kept your fans in check.

[ce. @cheesepalea]

@okaydokeyu @yizgal You're Chinese but simp for an idol who backs anti-China shit?? lmao shut the fuck up with your 'culture' bullshit you fake ass hypocrite 😂 Go cry in your task posts, loser