In a fully automated factory, you wouldn't have machinists, you would have application engineers. You wouldn't have maintenance, you would have service engineers. Every position there would be more technical than what is demanded to operate a factory. Fewer overall people, but the ones that are there have a deep skill set. Finding these people isn't impossible if you're willing to throw a lot of money at them. Making them from scratch is almost easier, but it takes time. With the way things are moving, we don't have time. Unfortunately, we only have deadlines.
No matter how much hands-on experience I have, I find myself asking a hundred dumb questions a month just so I can answer five complicated ones later. Five years ago I knew a lot about machines, programming, and process. Now I can help build and service an entire factory floor.
@tsunezo_works DMG needs an overhaul of their management and corporate operating procedures here in the states. They're losing service and application engineers left and right. These guys are top notch, love the product but are fed up with the current atmosphere.
@mariamusta33 I'm working for a distributor in Michigan. We sell CNCs and robotics cells for OEMs. I wasn't trying to discourage people from getting into robotics either. I was just pointing out the huge challenges that come with it.
@synerGy_FAB Spotting talent is just as important as creating it. Yes, there's a shortage but most managers have no clue how to gauge it, even if it's in front of them.
@RedBalloonWork I've been saying for years. I've learned everything from musical instruments to engineering from obsession. Sometimes it's a gift other times it feels like a curse. You have to stay focused and follow through or else you have a bunch of things you half learned how to do.
@_Faraz@AstroMechanica Being in over 100 factories a year, the answer isn't always the same. Troubleshooting the problem is where you earn your keep. You're either the hero or humbled.
I think they get the expertise they need to create a product. Then get stuck due to a lack of funding and are unable to take the next steps. Manufacturing experts, sales and service.
new rule: i ignore hard tech decks where the org chart has 6 PhDs and zero people whove run a production line.
thats not a company yet, its a science project with a logo.
Gantry arms are great for loading and unloading parts. They just lack the ability to do change overs. The absence of knowledge on how to program robots is also a challenge. Every shop has CNC programmers but many rely on application engineers from distributors to do the programming. Once they have a wall of robotic cells, then they actually hire a technician or engineer.
@10_X_eng I'm going to keep everything electrical to a minimum. Instead of running off of an encoder, it'll probably be cheaper to read proxy switches on each end of it.