Judge: Ma’am, before we proceed, is that a DOG you’re holding?!
Woman: Yes, Your Honor. This is Princess. She’s my emotional support animal.
Judge: And who gave you permission to bring Princess into my courtroom?
Woman: Your Honor, she helps with my anxiety. I can’t just leave her home!
Judge: Ma’am, I understand that. But you can’t simply walk into a courtroom with an animal without making arrangements!
Woman: Hugs the dog. Well, she’s already here, and she’s not bothering anybody!
Judge: Let’s hope she keeps it that way! Now, you’re disputing $2,400 in charges from your former landlord. Correct?
Woman: YES! He charged me for having Princess even though she’s an emotional support animal!
Judge: What exactly are these charges for?
Woman: A pet fee and supposed damage to the apartment!
Judge: Looks through the paperwork. Ma’am, according to these photographs, your dog scratched the bedroom door and damaged the carpet!
Woman: Your Honor, she’s a little dog! Look how tiny she is!
Judge: MA’AM, I’M LOOKING AT THE DAMAGE, NOT THE SIZE OF THE SUSPECT!
Woman: Looks offended. She’s not a suspect! She’s my BABY!
Judge: Well, apparently your baby had a disagreement with the bedroom door!
Woman: She gets anxious when I leave her alone!
Judge: So you knew she had separation anxiety?
Woman: Yes, Your Honor!
Judge: And what did you do to prevent her from damaging the apartment?
Woman: I bought her toys!
Judge: Raises his eyebrows. And did she play with them?
Woman: Apparently, she preferred the door!
Judge: WELL, THAT’S A VERY EXPENSIVE TOY, MA’AM!
Woman: But she’s an emotional support animal! I thought they weren’t allowed to charge me for having her!
Judge: There’s a difference between charging an improper pet fee for a qualifying assistance animal and charging for actual property damage!
Woman: So you’re saying emotional support animals don’t have rights?!
Judge: NO! I’m saying your rights don’t give Princess permission to redecorate somebody else’s apartment with her TEETH!
Woman: Shakes her head. This is ridiculous! She’s helped me through the worst moments of my life!
Judge: And I’m glad she has! But that doesn’t automatically excuse damage to someone else’s property.
Woman: So what am I supposed to do? Get rid of her?!
Judge: Nobody is telling you to get rid of your dog! I’m telling you to take responsibility for what she damages!
Woman: Looks down at Princess. See what you’ve gotten Mommy into?
Judge: MA’AM, PLEASE DON’T START ARGUING WITH THE DOG! I’VE ALREADY GOT ENOUGH PEOPLE TO DEAL WITH TODAY!
Woman: Tries not to laugh. Sorry, Your Honor.
Judge: Based on the evidence, I’m disallowing the $400 pet fee. But the documented $2,000 in property damage remains your responsibility!
Woman: TWO THOUSAND DOLLARS?! FOR A LITTLE DOG?!
Judge: MA’AM, THE DAMAGE DOESN’T GET A DISCOUNT BECAUSE THE DOG IS CUTE!
Woman: Hugs Princess tightly. Well, I guess we’re both going to be eating noodles for a while!
Judge: AND PLEASE MAKE SURE PRINCESS DOESN’T EAT THE FURNITURE WHILE YOU’RE AT IT! COURT IS ADJOURNED!