@thomasmetcalf@Philip_Goff Yes, I do think that intuition alone is very weak, and that it should only be trusted when verified. But that doesn’t give infinite regress; we can indeed verify our models (e.g. predicting times of future solar eclipses and seeing if they come true).
@thomasmetcalf@Philip_Goff I’m not rejecting conceptual analysis. It’s fine where conceptual schemes (maths, logic) have been verified as being sufficiently good real-world models. Half of science is conceptual analysis (aka “theory”), which entwines with observations and experiment.
@thomasmetcalf@Philip_Goff On the second: we have good reason to consider that intuitions relating to survival are a sufficiently good model of reality (else they would not have evolved). We have no good reason to trust intuitions that don’t involve any survival penalty in everyday life. 2/2
@thomasmetcalf@Philip_Goff On the first: the set of real-world actualities is vastly smaller than the set of what can be conceived. Hence, conceptualised entities are very unlikely to be real, unless pointed to by empirical evidence. Hence Occam’s razor. 1/2
@thomasmetcalf@Philip_Goff It comes down to a choice between: (1) human intuition on this point is wrong, or (2) throwing out physicalism and invoking a whole new ontological category, just to please human intuition. Given the known fallibility of intuition, isn’t (1) by far the more reasonable?
@thomasmetcalf@Philip_Goff The intuition over consciousness is similar to intuition over life. “Mere patterns of matter cannot be alive; needs something more, a life spark => vitalism”. But no, (non-consciousness) life, e.g. ants, can simply be patterns of matter.
Intuitions are evolved, so good wrt survival in everyday life. But otherwise poor.
E.g. Einstein’s relativity (very counter-intuitive); quantum mechanics (ditto); Darwinian evolution (very counterintuitive that it works); Cartesian dualism (intuitive but wrong); morality being objective is intuitive but wrong; lots of others. Science is a long saga of replacing intuitive notions with evidence-based explanations.
@thomasmetcalf@Philip_Goff It’s not about supporting with extra premises, it’s about evidence/argument that (2) is real-world true. I do think that human intuition is hugely fallible and thus a weak argument (science has shown “common sense intuition” to be wrong in many areas).
@thomasmetcalf@Philip_Goff It’s a mere assertion, asserting purely on intuition a claim that needs to be argued (the straightforward and ontologically simplest explanation of the world is that it is wrong, intuition notwithstanding).
@drmichaellevin@Philip_Goff A quick counter: mathematics is not even meaningful except as a model of physical reality (ditto logic & reason). Once you have, say, counting numbers, one can then reason to other truths, but you never escape the fact that the edifice models physical reality.
@jonatanpallesen@joelwatsonfish@Noahpinion To explain it to such people, distinguish between individual *people* being replaced (which is *not* happening), and *populations* being replaced (which is indeed happening, as one demographic gradually reduces in number, and another demographic increases).
@aljhlester Then go ahead, please point to this evidence. You'd be doing the world a big favour! Seriously, a proper, evidence-based "this is why Cofnas is wrong" rebuttal would be a useful thing to point to.
Akbari etal 2026 (from David Reich's world- leading genetics lab) reported in Nature: "in the past ten millennia, we find that many hundreds of alleles have been affected by strong directional selection. We also document one-standard-deviation changes on the scale of modern variation in combinations of alleles that today predict complex traits. This includes ... increases in measures of cognitive performance". (Link: https://t.co/ml7Qzl6KDJ )
So cutting-edge genetics finds genetic changes amounting to one-standard-deviation differences in cognitive performance on a timescale of 10,000 years. Thus genetics is telling us that, where populations have been largely separated on that timescale, we would expect of order ~ 1-SD differences in IQ.
It is no longer tenable to simply dismiss this possibility, however much it conflicts with how you would like things to be.
@aljhlester Alan, this is an empirical matter, not a moral one. The suggestion that there might be one-standard-deviation differences between populations in the means of some traits cannot just be dismissed as ideologically unwelcome; that’s not science.
@aljhlester First, Atlantic slavery did not create racism, most societies have always been “racist” (with a strong in-group over out-group preference). And it’s not true that typical white families pass on wealth from many generations ago, so this isn’t a major factor in inequalities.
@aljhlester The default is that harm is not passed on. I’ve suffered no harm from travails of my great-grandparents before I was born. Why would I? Kids are born anew each generation. (And hardly anyone gets inheritances from three generations ago or more.)
@Johnmcternan@FT Your article is effectively asking us to accept that long-past slavery is a major cause of inequalities today (and hence remedies are appropriate). That is a highly dubious and contentious claim.