In 22/23, 14 of the 20 Premier League clubs had shareholder loans on their books. Many were funded by owners on terms that would never have been available commercially.
Interesting how 70% of PL clubs benefited from an intentional loophole that was later ruled unlawful, with many lecturing others while presenting themselves as models of financial virtue.🤔
A couple on minimum wage, both working 40 hours a week:
Gross: £52,874
Take-home: £45,108
Child Benefit: £1,407 (1 child)
30 funded childcare hours: ✅
A single earner on £100,001:
Gross: £100,001
Take-home: £68,558
Child Benefit: £0
30 funded childcare hours: ❌
Losing those hours costs £11,890 a year in nursery fees.
So the single earner ends up with £56,668.
The couple ends up with £46,515.
That's £10,153 more for the single earner.
Despite earning £47,127 more.
Now add a second child.
The couple's Child Benefit goes up to £2,337.
The single earner's nursery bill doubles to £23,780.
Couple: £47,446
Single earner: £44,777
The minimum wage couple are now £2,668 better off.
Is this a fair system?
Before anyone acts like Manchester City invented wrongdoing in English football, perhaps they should take a proper look at the history of the other big clubs.
Arsenal: Arsenal were voted into the First Division despite finishing sixth in the Second Division, pushing Tottenham aside. Their chairman, Henry Norris, bribed clubs to secure the votes that got Arsenal promoted.
Tottenham: Spurs were found guilty of 39 charges involving irregular payments to players.
Liverpool: Four Liverpool players were found guilty of participating in a match fixing scandal alongside Manchester United players. Liverpool supporters were also involved in the events surrounding the Heysel disaster, where 39 people lost their lives.
Manchester United: Three United players were found guilty in the same match fixing scandal.
Chelsea: Chelsea admitted to £47.5m in undisclosed payments to agents and third parties.
Manchester City are not the first offenders, neither are they the only major club with a controversial history. Yet some people behave as though football was perfectly clean until City started winning. The selective outrage is quite revealing.
#114charges #ManCity
Paul Dikov on the controversial ref decision regarding Brighton two handball
🗣️: “This is totally unacceptable, the club is being robbed by an incompetent ref in their own home.
Two clear handballs in the opposite box and it wasn't even checked. Terrible tackle on Gvardiol in their box, Haaland had to help him up and the ref just ignored it.
This isn't a fair game at all. They're basically doing everything to frustrate the club. I hope someone calls the ref to order.”
🚨Harry Harris (Football Journo)
🎙"This isn’t going to end up anything like these pundits with high platforms think. Winding people up. The lynch-mob mentality" 👀
"#PL are handling this appallingly. Full trial is where this could go unless #ManCity/PL reach an agreement" 🤔
🚨Micah Richards on Manchester city’s three denied penalty appeals vs Brighton: (Vušković and Dunk)
Honestly? I’m sat here and I cannot believe what I’ve just watched.
Phil Foden whips that cross in… and Vušković’s arm is stuck out away from his body. It’s not tucked in. It’s not natural. He’s made himself bigger, he’s blocked the delivery, and the ball hits him flush on the arm inside the box. How is that not a penalty? Explain it to me. Because from where I’m sitting, that is a clear handball. His body shape is unnatural, the arm is extended, and it directly stops City’s attack. That’s exactly what the law is there for.
Then you’ve got the Dunk one as well. Again, City get into a dangerous area, the ball comes in, and Dunk’s arm is in a position that City fans — and anyone being honest — are screaming at the screen about. Two clear appeals. Two of them waved away by Craig Pawson, and VAR doesn’t even seem interested. What are they looking at? What did they actually see in the footage that made them go, “Nah, play on”? Because it looked obvious to everyone in that stadium.
And this is the part that properly winds me up. The consistency is a joke. We’ve seen near-identical incidents given against other teams this season. Arm out, makes yourself bigger, ball hits it in the box… sometimes it’s a penalty, sometimes it’s not. Depends who you are, apparently.
Let me ask you this: if those exact two decisions had gone against Arsenal, or Liverpool, or Manchester United… do you honestly think the reaction would be the same? The pundits, the former players, the media — would they be this quiet? Or would we be getting wall-to-wall “scandal,” “robbery,” “VAR is a disgrace” for the next 48 hours? We all know the answer.
City are creating the chances, they’re getting into the right areas, and then potentially game-changing decisions just get dismissed without proper scrutiny. It’s frustrating. It feels like no matter what they do, they have to clear a higher bar than everyone else.
I just want one of those VAR officials to sit here and tell me, with a straight face, what they saw that justified saying “no penalty” on those two. Because from the outside, it looks like City are being held to a completely different standard.
Would Manchester City ever get the same treatment as the other big clubs in this league? Or do we just have to accept that some decisions only go one way when it’s them?
That’s the real question. And right now, it doesn’t feel like anyone wants to answer it.
Aston Villa agreed to sell a 90% stake in their women's team to parent holding company V Sports and a 10% stake to external investors for a total of £55 million to comply with Premier League Profit and Sustainability Rules (PSR).
However, the gullible public are led to believe by the likes of TNT (yesterday) that Villa have grown organically!
The Villa fans obviously don’t do irony !
🚨Joe Hart on the Matty Cash incident with Doku before Nicolas Jackson goal in Aston Villa’s win over Manchester City:
🗣️Joe Hart: “I’m not sitting here saying the whole league is deliberately out to get us. I’m saying what I saw. Matty Cash should’ve been sent off for stepping on Doku before Jackson scored again. The whole league is against us at this point.
That wasn’t a normal coming-together. His studs went into the back of Doku’s foot, right around the Achilles area. Whether he meant it or not, when you plant your studs like that on an opponent who’s not in a position to protect himself, that’s serious foul play in my book. That’s the kind of challenge that ends careers if it lands a fraction higher or catches the wrong part of the ankle. VAR should have been all over it. Instead, Peter Bankes gives a yellow and waves play on like it’s a minor trip.
And what happens five minutes later? Jackson scores again and Villa are back in front. You’re telling me that doesn’t change the game? Cash is still on the pitch, still able to influence things, and City are suddenly chasing again. If that had been looked at properly and he’d gone, it’s 11 v 10 with the momentum swinging our way. Instead we get a soft yellow and the referee moves on as if nothing happened.
Here’s the part that really gets to me. If that was one of our players — say Gvardiol or Dias does that to one of theirs — the pile-on would be instant. Rival fans, the pundits, the media, they’d all be screaming for a red card before the next phase of play even finished. ‘Endangering an opponent,’ ‘reckless,’ ‘should’ve been sent off.’ But because it’s against City, it gets brushed off as ‘a bit clumsy’ or ‘accidental.’ That’s the double standard. We win a lot, we dominate, so the bar for what gets punished against us seems higher and the bar for what gets punished for us seems lower.
I know some of the Villa fans will just shrug and say ‘it was only a yellow, get over it.’ Of course they will. It helped their team. If the roles were reversed and one of our lads had done that to their winger five minutes before we scored, half of them would be demanding a retrospective ban by half-time. Don’t pretend otherwise.
We’re judged differently because of what we’ve achieved. Success brings scrutiny, fine. But it also seems to bring a different set of rules. We have to beat the opposition on the pitch and then we have to overcome decisions that keep going against us as well. That’s the reality right now, and until someone in authority starts applying the same standards to challenges like that one on Doku, City are going to keep feeling like they’re fighting more than just the eleven men in front of them.”