If you polled everyone in Toronto on their favourite pastime 65% of them would say "gather 3 friends and walk as slow as possible in that tiny ass tunnel between the train and Yorkdale"
depressing to see how many native english speakers are saying these samples are unintelligible or that nobody writes like this. obv not great choices for an ESL exam but imo a native anglophone should be able to read something harder than "the very hungry caterpillar" actually
@polarroposite and anyway it's a whole other kettle of fish to talk about fundamental ESL pedagogy: all I'm really trying to complain about is low standards of literacy and low tolerance for adversity in reading among native English readers
@FaustianFF The answer to the first is 3 afaict. But also I'm not really talking about the design of questions from the excerpts (which I agree is poor). I'm talking about the comprehensibility of the excerpts themselves, which has been the subject of the discussion which I mean to discuss
@Alexg81008660 ideally of course the difficulty would be from complex but well-written excerpts, not badly-written ones, so I agree with you there. I just think a lot of people are really overblowing how difficult these excerpts actually are for a fluent English speaker
@Alexg81008660 to be clear I agree that these are bad questions, poor choices of excerpts, abstruse etc, but for the purposes of something like the CSAT I don't think it's necessarily a bad thing to make questions extremely or even 'unreasonably' difficult
@Youzieew@Kyarumie my assumption is that the exam board wants to deliberately give them excerpts that are "too hard," so as to differentiate the right end of the bell curve.
also, depending on the field of study, I don't think I agree that more contemporary readings are necessarily more relevant
@COGs_Anemyre the purpose of the exam afaik is 1) to test ability to study university material in English moreso than everyday conversationality; and 2) to be very hard so as to differentiate the right end of the bell curve. they're not great questions but also the excerpts aren't thaaat hard
@Youzieew@Kyarumie yeah but various humanities degrees require the ability to read old and/or abstruse texts, and in that sense I don't think these are exceptionally bad
@Alexg81008660 in principle for university admissions exams it's perfectly reasonable to have extremely difficult dense academic reading comprehension questions. Of course these are bad questions in other ways, but not really because of difficulty per se imo
@Kyarumie the readings definitely read like academic writing ime. clunky and inelegant, yes, but so is plenty of academic writing, and they're reasonably clear. I just think anglophones are overreacting to the difficulty of these excerpts because their own first-language skills are poor
@kissinguuuuu or i guess to be a bit more to the point, I'm not really trying to comment on the exam itself so much as I'm trying to comment on anglophones' reactions to the exam online
@kissinguuuuu yea true, bad design for an esl exam, wrong sort of difficulty, rewards gaming the exam rather than holistic language skill etc. but really what bugs me is these aren't crazy difficult for academic writing, but native speakers are freaking out over them for the wrong reasons