I don’t see anything weird about it. In a sense, people’s view of the world back then was actually more cosmopolitan, because there wasn’t the kind of contact between nations that we have today. Most Indians had never met Germans, and most Germans had never seen an Indian. Racism in the modern world largely grows out of everyday contact.
Back then, a lot of right-wing Germans could genuinely believe that Indians were Aryans just like them, and that over there everyone lived in the “right” order, with castes and hierarchy. So for those Germans, there was nothing especially negative about it.
Honestly, it's kind of funny watching all these far-right parades, because Cyprus has basically turned into Sodom and Gomorrah lately. I went to Greek Cyprus as a tourist from Russia, and to be honest, it's just a service zone for Western tourists.
Drugs and prostitution right away, and the local Greeks are basically just the staff. So maybe the far right should do something about the state Cyprus is in. Then again, who knows, because Cyprus can't really do anything except serve tourists.
What I like most about Gorky is how he breaks with other Russian writers on ordinary people. For Tolstoy, Turgenev, Dostoevsky, Nekrasov, Grigorovich, and going all the way back to Karamzin, the peasant is a saint: simple, humble, long-suffering, the salt of the earth. But they were nobles who never actually lived among the people they idealized.
Gorky didn’t come from the peasantry himself, but from the lower middle class of the Volga region, and that put him much closer to ordinary people than any noble writer could get. He lost his father early and was raised by his grandparents, where beatings were a normal part of life. As a teenager he worked whatever jobs he could find: dishwasher on a Volga steamer, errand boy, baker’s apprentice. He saw that world from the inside.
And in his books, it’s a harsh world. Ordinary people are often cruel to each other, envious of any small success, and quick to take their frustration out on the weak. Endless poverty doesn’t make them noble. It wears them down until they become dull, bitter, and sometimes just brutal. Gorky shows all this without the sentimentality of the noble writers, and that’s the point. He doesn’t hate these people, but he refuses to pretend their life is something it isn’t.
Because he saw this world without illusions, Gorky thought much more seriously than the nobles about what kind of system could actually improve people’s lives. Their ideas about reshaping society look naive next to his.
And let’s not forget that Marx was a journalist first and foremost. For a journalist, the main thing is to write something that makes a splash. Economics, at least if you read or watch anything about it today, is a pretty dry science. It’s really hard to prove anything statistically, everything is built on probabilities, and you’re studying hundreds of thousands of boring details. With Marx, everything is exciting and flows, total 19th-century journalist vibes.
Russian here. Quick question: I keep seeing “Bukharinism” come up among leftists as its own tendency. I’ve spent some time studying Soviet history, specifically the 1920s, before Stalin consolidated power. What I don’t get is why Bukharinism is treated as a separate ideology, because in my view Bukharin had basically no real political weight. As far as I remember, he was on the Politburo, but unlike Zinoviev, who controlled the entire Leningrad party apparatus, or Trotsky, who had huge influence over the OGPU and the Red Army because he was so widely respected, Bukharin didn’t really have a power base. So where does Bukharinism even come from? He basically just sat at his newspaper. He didn’t even head any government agency, and in the Soviet Union, agencies were pretty much the main force that could back any faction.
@n30n5223434 China is in many ways a more interesting country than Japan. Japan is just a mirror state that copies whoever it sees as successful: Han culture, then Europe after Meiji, and the US after '45.
It's a very boring experience, and I don't get how people find it authentic.
I think all these parameters are going to change many more times. When I was young, back in the 2000s, everyone was talking about overpopulation, and how it would be great if everyone just had one kid and gave them the best life possible. That's the trend that got set back then. I think we'll flip it again soon.
#2 Maxim Gorky "The autobiographical trilogy: My Childhood, In the World, and My Universities"
Maxim Gorky is a fascinating writer, and his story starts with an unusual fact: he was a literary superstar who came from the bottom. When his first stories came out in the late 1890s, he became hugely popular almost overnight, and his play The Lower Depths was a sensation. He also became one of the best-paid writers in the country. Part of the reason, I think, is that he showed readers a world they had never really seen from the inside.
Most Russian writers of the Empire were nobles, the children of officials or of other writers. Chekhov, the grandson of a serf, was a rare exception, and so was Gorky. He grew up in a lower-middle-class family in Nizhny Novgorod. After his father died, he was raised by his grandparents, and later he worked odd jobs up and down the Volga.
That’s what his autobiographical trilogy is about, and it’s what makes it so different. Noble-born writers loved to romanticize the common people. Gorky had no such illusions, because he lived among them. He shows that this world had its good sides and its bad sides, and that it was, above all, incredibly brutal. In My Childhood, his grandfather flogs him so badly that he falls ill, and the only warmth in the house comes from his grandmother. That contrast says more about this life than any lecture could.
Gorky was a man of the left. He supported the Revolution of 1905, emigrated after the Bolsheviks came to power, and later returned to become the official classic of Soviet literature under Stalin. Today he’s much less read, both in Russia and in the West. But for me, his greatest contribution is that he could describe the cruelty and ignorance of ordinary people honestly, without embellishment.
His style is simple and plain, so it survives translation well. If you want to start with Gorky, read this trilogy
#1 Vladimir Nabokov "Lectures on Russian Literature"
Nabokov, a prominent Russian-American writer, was deeply interested in Russian literature and wanted to introduce it to Western audiences. Unfortunately, he wasn’t the most balanced guide to it.
I think the best sign of good criticism is when readers can retell the argument after finishing the book. With the writers he praised, like Chekhov and Leo Tolstoy, Nabokov had that ability. You can lay out every reason why these writers are actually good at what they do. But when it comes to the writers he disliked, all his arguments turn to mush. Take Dostoevsky: Nabokov dismisses him as sentimental and melodramatic, but beyond the insults, it’s hard to find a real argument you could repeat to someone else.
Nabokov was also a harsh critic of early Soviet literature and of the “lefty” writers of the Russian Empire. To him, the Soviet idea that literature should always teach something or deal with social problems was boring and dumb. He would have gotten along great with Harold Bloom, the literary critic who believed that literature should exist for its own sake, without any specific purpose.
Still, I can’t recommend this book to Western readers. These lectures are written for someone who already knows a lot about Russian literature and has read quite a bit of it. Instead of explaining things, Nabokov often just inserts long excerpts from the books, and it feels pretty chaotic. I don’t think he manages to draw the reader in with such huge chunks of text.
In these lectures, he reminds me of a tired old professor who genuinely loves his subject but no longer expects to engage anyone or inspire them to read something. He’s lecturing, he enjoys it, but making the material interesting isn’t really his goal. Ironically, he set out to introduce Russian literature to the West, but ended up lecturing to people who already knew it.
So the only people who will really enjoy this book are, first, those who are already into Nabokov himself and curious about his views on writers, and second, those who already know Russian literature well and understand what he’s talking about.
Japan is a truly unique country. It managed to come out of the global colonial race as a fairly independent nation.
Compare that with other Asian countries that weren't so lucky, where many people moved to the West for a better life (the Korean War, the Vietnam War, waves of refugees, etc.).
They got to experience firsthand what discrimination is like, being treated as outsiders in another country. The Japanese didn't.
I'd love to see how Japanese immigrants would react if I walked around their neighborhood calling them "slant-eyes" and "yellow scum" and spitting in their faces. Would they just roll over and take it?