Thank you @connolly_ahern for a enlightening session! I am so glad to have been part of the #JMCQTrainingProgram with this amazing group of scholars! This has been such a wonderful experience, all thanks to @Prof_Dimitrova and team! 🙏
Apparently @tonyromo needs a thesaurus. Maybe we can help. Here are some other words for “aggressive,” big guy: combative, hostile, contentious, threatening, intimidating, bellicose, invading. You get the idea #nfloncbs#sundayfootball#fromthebooth
R&R Tips
Q: What if I disagree with reviewer suggestions?
A: You can advocate in a professional manner. Address all reviewer comments, even critical ones. TIP: Provide context and reasons why you disagree with a reviewer in a separate letter to the editor. #JMCQdemystified
@AEJMC Q8: Find a good research mentor as you begin the journey. Don’t be afraid to reach out to a scholar you cite often – most people love to discuss their research! #JMCQdemystified#AejmcChats
@AEJMC A7: We all appreciate good reviewers! Think about what kind of review you would like to get. Substantive, fair, professional, & timely. Here are a few more tips from @COPE:
https://t.co/M22vLWSgKR
#JMCQdemystified#AejmcChats
@AEJMC A6: The last option is “reject.” Accepting a manuscript “as is” is rare, and “rejections” are rare as well. The AE makes a recommendation to the Editor-in-Chief with a comment that summarizes and synthesizes the reviewers’ comments. #JMCQdemystified#AejmcChats
4/4
@AEJMC A6: A “major revision” indicates that the manuscript needs significant revision for further consideration. Revise and resubmit (R&R) is a typical outcome of the review process. Don’t let it scare you off! #JMCQdemystified#AejmcChats
3/4
@AEJMC A6: An “accept” indicates that the manuscript will be accepted as is. For a “minor revision” the manuscript may go back to the reviewers, but the AE ensures the minor changes are addressed by the author(s). #JMCQdemystified#AejmcChats
2/4
@AEJMC A6: Once the reviews are in -- it’s decision time. The AE reads the piece and all reviewer comments closely and makes a recommendation: accept, reject, revise & resubmit, or minor revision. #JMCQdemystified#AejmcChats
1/4
Q: Why become @jmcquarterly reviewer?
A: Reviewing 1) ensures your theoretical and methodological perspectives are represented; 2) improves your own research and writing. Email the editorial office to join the team. Tips from @SAGE: https://t.co/0WfRHFEI8v
#JMCQdemystified