Just back from @HodgesFiggis and the launch of @Richard_Fitz’s biography of one of the most compelling figures in football history. Was lucky enough to be its first reader. It’s a brilliant book. You will love it.
@nicwoollee@thedeadballarea@BryanHabana I think all really rugby people are feeling like that at the moment. I did like the score sheet that was released to try and explain Ryan's ban. I hope that trend keeps going to help fans (who can be balanced) understand and discuss rationally. Its an emotive topic.
@nicwoollee@thedeadballarea@BryanHabana 2 weeks after mitigation for anything around the eyes is pretty light, I see he got 50% reduction for clean track record. Im guessing he conceded or had to concede being careless to get such a small ban?
@nicwoollee@thedeadballarea@BryanHabana Which together with player (Murphy), player (Wessels) and citing commissioner testimony seemed to come down to "what else could he have been doing" with his arm/hands in such an abnormal position. To have a real opinion we'd need to have been at the hearing, harsh result.
@nicwoollee@thedeadballarea@BryanHabana The bottom line is that the ref and TMO deemed it a yellow. I think they decided that Doris caused a yellow level penalty and Ryan's act was independent / unlucky as without Doris' act it wasn't really a bad offence by itself
@nicwoollee@thedeadballarea@BryanHabana 1. Prove which of them caused the injury 2. Prove the injury wasn't caused in the 46 minutes before the incident.
Common sense is not proof, players play on for significant breaks / fractures all the time.
@nicwoollee@thedeadballarea@BryanHabana If you want my opinion, the injury was a bad one, and the croc roll is an uglyoffence. But the challenge, rugby is governed by laws, so if you want to throw the book at Doris or Ryan or BOTH Doris and Ryan then ....
@nicwoollee@thedeadballarea@BryanHabana He was yellow carded and sent for a bunker review by Referee Dickson (on urging from TMO Tempest). I don't believe the incident itself was cited for additional reviews by the independent citing commission.
@nicwoollee@thedeadballarea@BryanHabana Because he didnt injure Marx? Before you post a picture of his eyebrow after the match check his eyebrow when he takes a lineout at 20mins 38secs into the match. Post hoc ergo propter hoc.
@rugby_ap Completely correct. Marx needs to be forced out of rugby before he does long term damage to himself. Same eye, same cut, never heals.
Tell us now about how Ryan was in Dallas in 1963.
@BrentGraham You're told as a trainee ref (been there) to try and be correct, decisive and consistent, and any 2 out of these 3 will do. I think it still applies from mini to elite levels of the game as "all" the fans expect. Unfortunately rugby has a problem right now with consistency.
@BrentGraham I'm with you, but with a minor caveat. When Irish fans moan about the ref we "only" moan about the ref. When South African fans do it they add "and Dublin based World Rugby" ... so if you have any ref playing any opposition.... its somehow our fault 😂😂😂
@JacquesMaree73 As opposed to the whole world's favourite South African whinges:
1. Dublin based World Rugby are out to get us all the time (except apparently when playing Ireland)
2. Rassie
Both real, wide spread and documented.
Dry your eyes dears and move on.
Tramps like me were Born to Run, but a version of this song was #1 in Ireland. What a year it was for tunes. Thunderous roads, Troublesome Fame, and even Boho Rhapsodies. Enjoy.
https://t.co/KYPLIKuHPE