NewJeans collectively decided to terminate their exclusive contracts with ADOR. This was their decision, made by all five members, based on their own experiences and their own reasons. It wasn't a decision someone else made for them, nor should their agency and personal convictions be dismissed simply because you want to point your finger to someone else.
Let's not forget that the members themselves publicly addressed this.
On November 28, 2024, during their emergency press conference, they explicitly stated that the September YouTube livestream and the November 13 formal notice demanding corrective action were both discussed, prepared, and decided upon collectively by all five members.
Hanni also made it crystal clear: "That is why the five of us together have agreed to leave ADOR."
They explained their reasons repeatedly: mistreatment of the members and staff, deliberate miscommunication, manipulation, the company's failure to protect them, and ADOR and HYBE's refusal to address their concerns despite being given opportunities to do so.
On November 29, they reiterated in their official statement that their decision came after long and careful consideration. All five had signed the contract termination notice. They also explained that remaining with ADOR would only cause them further mental distress.
Wanting to continue working with someone they trusted and respected does not mean that person made their decision for them. Supporting MHJ's reinstatement and deciding to leave ADOR were positions the members themselves chose to take.
The distinction is important. Min Hee-jin may have been at the center of the conflict, but the members had their own grievances, their own lived experiences, and their own reasons for no longer wanting to remain with ADOR.
HYBE and ADOR need to be held accountable for their own actions and for the circumstances that led all five members to conclude that leaving was their only option. Stop taking away the girls' agency just to construct a narrative that shifts responsibility away from the companies.
aespa are damned no matter what they do. merely sitting and smiling at a camera gets them called plastic, attending a prestigious global event brings out the "is this inkigayo" remarks, opening up in their rawest form gets dismissed as corny and attention seeking, and wearing similar group makeup leads to "omg i'm so scared they all went to the same plastic surgeon i can't tell them apart" spewing this kind of rhetoric says nothing about them and everything about you, it loudly exposes just how racist, misogynistic, and downright ugly you are
Attention, Bunnies! ADOR used this tactic during the NJZ lawsuit. They filmed an unknown man standing outside the HYBE building, claiming that Bunnies wanted NewJeans to return to the company. They then submitted this footage as evidence in courtβΌοΈβΌοΈβΌοΈβΌοΈβΌοΈβΌοΈβΌοΈ