The World Bank's just released their latest benchmark of real GDPs: Comparing specific categories between US and China with physical indicators of consumption make it look like the size of the Chinese economy is indeed greatly underestimated, even in PPP terms.
Compare the following categories in billions of PPP dollars with physical indicators of consumption:
Food consumption:
US - 1,085.3
China - 1,146.5
So apparently, we are supposed to believe that Chinese per capita food consumption is 25% of American food consumption?
In terms of calories, Chinese mean daily food consumption is 3,406 calories, 88% of US consumption which is 3,911 calories. In terms of meat, Chinese consumption, at about 61 kg, is about half of American consumption of 125kg.
Overall, considering that US consumption of food is higher quality, one might think meat is a good proxy, making Chinese per capita food consumption ca. 50% of US. Thus, the World Bank overestimated US food consumption by 100% relative to China.
Purchase of vehicles:
US - 623.6
China - 319.2
Sales of motor vehicles:
US - 15,408,565
China - 26,314,263
In this case, the World Bank apparently overestimated US vehicle consumption by 200% relative to Chinese consumption.
Housing consumption:
US - 2,472
China - 3,370
Est. housing stock in billions of square meters:
US - 22,742
China - 51,538
In this case, it appears the World Bank overestimated US housing consumption relative to China by 65%.
Utilities (water, electricity, gas, and other fuels):
US - 397.3
China - 727.2
Chinese electricity production in 2022 was about 215% of the United States; however, since Chinese manufacturing consumes much more electricity, and in this case, electricity is an intermediate good and not a final good, then this relative level of consumption of utilities looks roughly accurate.
Actual education expenditures:
US - 1,369.7
China - 1,779.5
So, are American real education expenditures really worth 77% of Chinese expenditures?
In China there are 44.3 million college students in 2021, while in the US there were 16.2 million college students in 2022. Using this as a proxy for the value of education expenditures suggests that US education expenditures were overestimated relative to China by 110%.
Adding all these categories of expenditures and including the adjusted Chinese figures to US PPP dollars in proportion to their underestimation, we have:
US - 5,947
China - 7,342
China (adjusted) - 13,445
These categories combined match the World Bank's relative GDP level: a Chinese per capita GDP of 29% of the US's. However, adjusted by physical statistics would imply a Chinese per capita GDP of 53% of the US's, agreeing with my previous assessments of a severe underestimation of the size of the Chinese economy by the World Bank.
@Kanthan2030 China does not include services that are used by manufacturers such as legal, banking, consulting, etc. these are considered input cost and actually subtracted. There was a financial times article a few months back detailing this.
@CarlZha@mariocavolo Amazing story Carl! My step grandfather on my dads side was a member of the ๅ ซ่ทฏๅ. I still remember him showing me his scars from bayonet fighting Japanese !