We’ve had 3 seasons and a whole spin off exploring how the loss of his culture deeply affected him (not to mention the whole movie).
I think it’s obvious.
wish they had kept that parade scene in the movie. i think displaying the culture & bending of the other 3 nations would've driven home how alone aang feels & explained why he was so desperate. then we wouldn't get takes referring to his struggles as "super special man pain"+
@aspuhm I commented on your analogy because it didn’t hold up. A professional or aspiring professional creative is generally expected to develop their craft; a fanfic author writing recreationally isn’t. That’s why I drew the distinction.
The analogy doesn’t hold up because fanfiction is not the same thing as commercial music. They’re more akin to those bands you form as a kid or teen and playing for your parents and friends.
@florabats Genuinely and I don’t get people taking offense because it applies to every form of art. Like ask a modern pop artist her inspirations and she’ll list all her favorite blues records, some books that inspired her lyrics etc. You just cant get good if you pigeonhole your inspo
@aspuhm Aspen, have a cookie. My original tweet was specifically about your analogy. You elaborated, I elaborated, you elaborated again, and I reasserted the original point because we’re drifting away from it.
@aspuhm Neither did I say that you did. All I said originally is that your analogy did not hold up. You can’t reasonably compare someone who writes fanfiction for the expected audience of fanfiction to a commercial musician.
@aspuhm Ok and the analogy still doesn’t hold up. Fanfiction is a lowbrow, amateurish medium and it’s always strange when you people get to up and arms about it being terrible. Of course it is. It’s meant to be 😭😭😭
Essentially yours and many others’ reactions are disproportionate.
Except Alicent escalated things by accusing Lucerys of aiming to murder Aemond.
Rhaenyra only brought up torture to goad Alicent into revealing that she is the one spreading the bastard Rumors “-must be sharply questioned so we might hear WHERE he heard such slanders from.”
@ragandboneshop But that’s not how she said it. Which is why people pushed back. Just because people in Classics’ circles enjoy being verbally castrated doesn’t mean the wider public will.
Review is harshly worded but in what world would a Homer scholar not offer a valuable critique of an adaptation of the Odyssey. And everyone watches movies!
You people act rude and dismissive and get shocked or offended when people react to that. I know you’re not an idiot so I’ll spell it out for you: While that may be normal within your tradition, talking like that outside of it will earn pushback.
Accept the consequences 🤗
You don’t really know an ancient language if you can’t translate into it, and you can’t translate well into Greek or Latin prose or verse unless you grasp how the ancients thought and articulated their thoughts.
It’s a skill that takes a lot of reading, learning, immersion in texts, and observation of style and idiom.
It takes years of hard work, but there’s deep joy in it and at the end of it.
Imagine five minutes before an exam, someone is told their entire family was shot dead Romanov-style. Do you think they will deliver their best effort in that kind of setting?
Another pseudo-philosopher who thinks every word that comes out of their mouth is profound likely.
You are right that people might not be brilliant as they think they are but academic performance can and often does suffer during a crisis.
@feydemie I could tell.
I still corrected because the politics is the point. Alicent undermines Rhaenyra in sneaky, underhanded ways because she can’t attack her directly. A direct attack is not her MO, hence why I said the scene in Driftmark where she attacks Rhaenyra is kind of dumb
No she would not have.
S1 Alicent is not an idiot. However she hates Rhaenyra, she is not going to lay a hand on Viserys’ daughter with no consequences. That’s why even the Driftmark scene everyone knows and loves is erroneous bc the mere idea Alicent would charge at Rhaenyra-
s1 alicent would have clawed rhaenyra's eye out and walked to the black cells with her head held high at the mere suggestion that she should go kill her own son i can tell you that much