@Hebro_Steele 2. The reason collective guilt persists is that the antidote to guilt is forgiveness and in the case of collective guilt there is no party that can act for the harmed and offer forgiveness, so collective guilt can never be dissipated.
Interesting encapsulation of how guilt, a fundamentally interpersonal state, has been co-opted by group and hierarchical relations thinking to yield a new morality.
For the first time, almost half of our country’s 30-year-old women are childless. In 1976, it was just 18 percent.
A low birth rate is the number one threat to Western Civilization. Society doesn’t survive without babies.
https://t.co/KgWvOMPLdd
Really enjoyed this interview with Matt Galloway on #CBC. The Current with Matt Galloway - Feb. 23, 2026: Why you shouldn’t feel guilty about feeling guilty https://t.co/nn40EGnmQw
@NYPostOpinion The problem with white guilt and other forms of collective guilt is that there is no path to forgiveness and so the antidote to guilt is denied and it festers. #thepowerofguilt
Think of guilt as the "check engine" light for your relationships. It’s uncomfortable for a reason—it’s designed to prompt an apology, a change in behavior, or a meaningful conversation. 💡
That's what we see with collective guilt. Because collective guilt, like white or settler guilt, cannot be resolved through forgiveness, it can be the source of moral outrage on behalf of the 'victims.'
My conversation with Sheima Benembarek at The Conversation: Book Talk: Q&A with a psychologist who argues ‘guilt is a helpful emotion, not a harmful one’ https://t.co/QF2WmwLLbW via @ConversationCA
@DrGipps@JonathanShedler ultimately both I think. The latter is the downstream consequence of the former both developmentally and historically. Happy to continue the discussion offline (offX) if it would be easier
@DrGipps@JonathanShedler thanks Richard. I think this perfectly illustrates the difference between a philosophical (metaphysical) approach and a psychological one. For me, guilt originates in the psychological reaction to relationship harm.
@DrGipps@JonathanShedler Yes if ‘primary’ means original here. But these days ‘guilt’ is used for both a subjective state (the feeling of guilt) and an objective state (the fact of being guilty e.g., under the law or of having sinned).