@markjaquith Lol. They just hope people don't notice. Those bundles are a loss leader, or at least a lower margin—as a gateway drug into the Ryobi collection. Ask me how I know.
@lilyraynyc@rajanpatel Yikes — great find. The answer will undoubtedly be “these are two vastly different areas of Google,” but the timing of the events tells an obvious story.
Oof.. if you think the Helpful Content Update was bad for some travel sites... look at what happened before.
These 6 travel blogger sites (removed names for this chart) were wiped out by the April 2023 Reviews Update... then the HCU made it worse.
(More to come in next article)
@lilyraynyc I’m with you but let me play devils advocate for a moment. What if Google has enough data to prove the title customization is driving more engaged users with fewer bounces to sites? Surely they’re optimizing towards some sort of north star metric.
@RyanMcCready1 Yep, you're fine. We're all longing for 2019. If we knew about 2020/21 I'm sure we'd all have squeezed in a hell of a lot more adventures.
@RiaLolwut From what I’ve read, Google goes as far optimizing titles towards specific search queries. They’ve been doing it selectively for years but have clearly cranked it way up with this last update. Point being—I think there would too many to show us. Would be cool, though!
@dan_shure Solid point! Plus, that builds rank diversity keeping you a little safer from shakeups. Maybe a hybrid approach is best, though? Setting and aiming for a baseline goal but still pursuing higher goals with your whale posts/keywords. Balance feels logical here.
@bill_slawski I assume you shared this because of its relevance to the recent <title> SERP changes. Even though you published this 14 years ago it's as true as ever. I believe Google's optimizing titles to help users make quicker easier choices. There's no way they did this without enough data
@areej_abuali You’re not alone! I’m trying my best to trust Google’s optimization and see the good it may bring. Perhaps, in the form of cleaner SERPs, improved CTRs, and search-to-content alignment.
@IanLurie We've also seen proof across our sites. In some scenarios as extreme as only a mid-section of our H1. I believe Google's trying to optimize towards less noisy SERPs—and that they have enough data to output more effective titles than publishers. Time will tell.
@lilyraynyc I've put a lot of thought into this. My best guess is that Google's removing noisy titles and optimizing for a faster click to search results. If they succeed it'll shake up the SERPs but result in a better UX. I hate losing control but it makes sense.