im sorry, but I disagree so much π this is anti-art, I hate that she thinks like this. i want to not talk much about her but this is just a bad awful take yikes ππππ...
I feel like she's just talking about confessional lyricism here, there's music in songwriting too you know, not just lyrics... the emotion and the voice of the singer, the melody is also songwriting, and confessional can come from those things too.
THIS IS SO IRONIC BUT SINCE WE'RE TALKING ABOUT TAYLOR I LOWKEY HAVE TO BRING UP CHARLI XCX WITH SS26, like lyrically not sense, but the songwriting is incredibly confessional
@blehshcunt punk and metal music are really great examples of how skewed this perception of songwriting really is, THEY ARE ART! they refuse to be boxed into any definitions of songwriting.
@jovisosamu the two truths can be both true. Screaming shocking things happen a lot of times in punk music, in metal music, it exists outside this sphere. it's not just about how you do it, it's also about your intention and how you put meaning to it
@jovisosamu art & soul are intertwined concepts of life, creation is an expression. art is the concept of creating bc you are a living, feeling being. I know a fuckton about art bc I care about music and art. I wanna quote this song by CW cancer of the skull, songs r ugly babies I can't feed
@jovisosamu if art doesn't come out of wanting to express, writing because you feel like you have to, or just plain-old describing what you feel, then it's gonna come out really REAAALLY soulless. some artists don't even want to create art, they have to because it's their lifeline.
songwriting and lyricism are different things, she's an EXCELLENT lyricist, like you just know she is well-read on classical literature, songwriting-wise, tloasg is really horrible to her image as a songwriter...
I don't connect with this kind of perspective in her songwriting, probably the reason why I don't connect to anything off of showgirl and even iki,iky, but that's just me, I love how crazy she went with her songwriting in folkmore, doesn't feel calculated unlike showgirl
@stnkyfshykochie well I did say not talk MUCH so I do still want to talk about her cuz she's still one of my favorite artists ever but lately she feels like an old friend I don't understand anymore