@nutanc If this is bad, the budget allocated for this over the years rapidly gets to 2.5+Billion $. The amount of R&D, hospitals and improvisation could have done with it 🙃
The European Commission is ordering Google to share the search data of all Europeans with other companies (AI chatbot makers, search engines, etc.), after a kind of "anonymisation". I tested it on the real Google data, hundreds of billions of search records. I broke it.
Findings. I singled out the people behind half a million searches, and that only for few countries over one month of August (record isolation). I joined the pieces of search history beyond the defined cap of 3, more than 200,000 sets just for Germany and only in August (linkage). I also confirm that it is possible to perform inference on the dataset, for example concerning health, religion or political opinions. This moves us beyond data protection, and in the national security direction.
My report: "Alone among a thousand". (link below)
We’re making a personalized cancer vaccine for Yash, a 34 year-old pancreatic cancer patient, in the open with his consent.
We want external experts to review our design and make their own contributions before we manufacture it at the RNA Foundry.
https://t.co/HBkhxMxD1p
Hello friends, now that there are no more scientific updates from Deepinder Goyal on his scammy Temple device, I am moving on to completing my research papers this week. But I will keep a look out for any new "science" they bring so that I can simplify it for you.
Long, but worth your time because you should know how science fraud blends beautifully into seemingly good science papers also.
That said, Deepinder has uploaded various research papers on the Temple website.
https://t.co/xGJN0H7vcG
They have performed 4 studies on Temple. Three are in 'so-called' peer review (the trials are not even registered) and one is an internal white paper document from the company. The rest are "foundational research" - other published papers which Deepinder has used (exaggeratingly) to legitimize his device (deceitfully). Because the Temple "minions" are always citing from this webpage, I would like to clear the air on what the studies were done for and what was truly shown. This is for posterity.
[1] Temple vs. Five Flagship Werables - Heart Rate Accuracy Study - This paper is an unreviewed, in-house white paper funded, run, and analyzed entirely by Temple Private Limited (with generative AI assisting in the analysis and drafting) rather than an independent clinical trial. The methodology was tilted in Temple's favor: the company compared its own 1-second internal app data stream against Apple Watch Series 12 and Oura Ring 5 data pulled from Apple Health exports that only logged once every 5 seconds, and it forced participants to wear four wrist devices at the same time - pushing half of them onto the lower wrist bone where motion errors are much worse (for example, WHOOP MG's error more than doubled from 2.00 bpm on the upper forearm to 4.58 bpm at the bottom wrist position) and then pooling those worse readings into the headline numbers. Deepinder also applied custom "in-house thresholds" to strip out "failure episodes" before calculating accuracy, tested only 43 young adults during a single indoor treadmill run while excluding darker skin tones and outdoor or non-running activities, and ultimately only showed that an optical sensor taped over a scalp artery can read pulse rate - which proves nothing about Temple's flagship claims of tracking brain blood flow, vascular aging, or metabolic "Entropy" - or even heart rate accurately. This was the study that Deepinder (in)famously told his team to promote as "success" in the Company Slack group.
[2] Evaluating Brain Flow Index from a Temple-Worn Wearable (Deepinder had mentioned he would explain the technology behind it - but I dont think he understands his own paper, so I'll do it for him). This non-peer-reviewed preprint was designed, funded, and conducted by Temple (authored by company employees, founder Deepinder Goyal, and paid company consultants/advisers) on 44 young men completely excluding women because hair interfered with the reference headset. Neither device in the study actually measured brain blood flow: near-infrared spectroscopy (NIRS) only estimates hemoglobin concentration changes, and the "brain layer" reference was a mathematical guesswork from Temple Science Team, assuming every participant had an identical 8 mm flat slab of scalp and skull and a fixed 1.5-to-1 brain-to-scalp absorption ratio. The authors threw out the third optical time-of-flight moment (variance) measure - the exact measurement that truly provides the deepest tissue selectivity, because it produced "implausibly inflated" numbers, and they placed the NIRS reference on the opposite side of the forehead rather than under the Temple sensor, making it impossible to rule out local temple skin blood flow. To get their correlations (manipulated) right, they shifted the data by up to ±30 seconds per session to cherry-pick the best alignment, then used one-sided statistical tests without correcting for multiple comparisons, failed to find a statistically significant difference between brain and scalp correlations when lying down and never measured blood pressure, carbon dioxide, or breathing - meaning whole-body blood pressure rushes during inversion-table tilts and deep squats simply pushed blood into the head and moved both sensors together. Nothing about brain flow or its measurement is proven here.
[3] Concordance Between a Temple-Worn Optical Wearable and Transcranial Doppler During Exercise and Postural Transitions. This non-peer-reviewed preprint funded by Temple Pvt. Ltd. and co-authored by a paid company consultant, tested only 20 analyzable young adults per protocol after dropping participants for movement-degraded recordings, and its own limitations section admits that the Temple Brain Flow index is "an extracranial optical signal whose cerebral component... the present protocols cannot isolate." Because vigorous cycling and lying flat drive blood into both the inner brain and the outer scalp skin at the same time, a surface skin sensor naturally rises and falls alongside Transcranial Doppler (TCD) ultrasound without ever penetrating to the brain. Furthermore, because Temple's closed-source algorithm outputs a unitless number rather than actual flow velocity (cm/s) or volume, the authors mathematically manipulated the scores. Even then, the timing between the two devices was erratic. Temple led the ultrasound by a median of 19 seconds during cycling but lagged behind by 9 seconds during posture shifts - while the devices were worn on opposite sides of the head, room temperature (25–30°C) and time of day were left uncontrolled despite skin blood flow reacting strongly to heat, beat-to-beat blood pressure were unrecorded, and Temple hid its LED-to-detector spacing so independent scientists cannot verify how deep its light actually reaches.
[4] Temple PPG Morphology Demonstrates a Stronger Cardiovascular Age Signal Than Wrist Sites. Written entirely by three Temple employees and posted on pre-print without peer review, this study claims the temple is a better site than the wrist for detecting "cardiovascular age", but it never actually measured the temple and wrist on the same people. Instead, it committed a classic apples-to-oranges error by comparing an internal group of 126 mostly young men wearing a Temple sensor against a separate public dataset (Microsoft Aurora-BP) of 240 much older, gender-balanced people wearing a different wrist sensor, alongside an exploratory public fNIRS dataset of just 13 people where 88 of 89 features failed multiple-comparison correction. Worse still, the Temple sensor recorded pulse waves at a coarse 32 Hz while the wrist sensor recorded at 500 Hz, and both were artificially resampled to 75 Hz - even though resampling cannot recover high-frequency pulse details lost at 32 Hz, which heavily distorts the second- and third-derivative waveform ratios the paper relies on (and the raw Temple signal even came out upside-down, requiring manual sign inversion - again manipulation). Finally, the study excluded everyone over age 60, failed to show a statistically significant difference in overall feature "richness" between the temple and wrist (the confidence interval crossed zero), and never measured actual arterial stiffness or vascular health, merely correlating scalp pulse shapes with chronological birth age - andn othing more.
[5] Assessing the Accuracy of Photoplethysmography for Wearable Heart Rate Monitoring Based on Body Location and Body Motion in Uncontrolled Outdoor Environments. This short 2024 conference abstract (no even a proper study) by Zurich researchers had nothing to do with the Temple wearable, brain blood flow, or vascular aging - and it did not even test the temple region. Rather than proving that a head-mounted sensor is ultra-accurate, the study found that even the forehead sensor suffered a 7.1% median error in real-world outdoor conditions (which equals roughly 10 to 13 bpm of error during exercise heart rates of 140–180 bpm, nearly ten times worse than the 1.18 bpm error Temple claims from its indoor treadmill test). Most importantly, the authors concluded that irregular real-world body motion degraded signal quality across all body locations far more than sensor placement helped, directly undermining Temple's marketing claim that putting an optical sensor on the head solves real-world motion artifacts.
[6] Temporal Skin Temperature as an Indicator of Cardiorespiratory Fitness Assessed with Selected Methods. This 2022 Polish sports-science study in Biology did not use the Temple device or any wearable sensor at all; it used a stationary, non-contact infrared thermal camera from a distance in a 21°C lab to photograph the bare temple skin of 23 young men before and after a 3-minute cycling sprint. Using a remote thermal camera to justify a skin-taped wearable is physically flawed because sticking an adhesive plastic sensor onto the temple traps heat, blocks sweat evaporation, and ruins the natural radiative skin cooling and rewarming that the camera measured. Even more damaging to Temple's core premise, this paper explicitly explains that temple skin temperature rises after intense exercise because heat-dumping blood is shunted into the external carotid artery on the scalp while actual brain blood flow decreases to protect the brain from overheating - MEANING, this cited paper actually proves that blood flow and temperature at the surface of the temple move in the exact opposite direction of true brain blood flow during intense exercise. Everything opposite of what Deepinder claims.
Now that you know there is nothing more than these fraudulent, manipulated, methodologically weak, AI written papers and falsified scientific data on Temple device, do not let them cite these papers again as proof. These are garbage worthy.
The only way I see Temple device selling and succeeding is to remodel the device into the form of a leech and state that Ayurvedic principles of good and bad blood (ancient Jalauka Therapy - leech application) were applied as per Ayurveda texts and that the device measures primal energy imabalance as described in Ayurveda and Entropy is actually your Ayurvedic Doshas (without chutney). An example is shown below. Ayush Ministry will legalize, approve this and promote this (because those useless people are allergic to data and science) and 1% of the world and 99% of India will buy this scam-toy! I dont want royalties for this idea.
Until the next fraud paper drops, goodbye and goodluck.
Image courtesy: (at)drvarunacharya (Instagram)
@hakluke Will reinforce the disparity, accessibility even more across the board. Since AI scaled exponentially faster but the production and access still lags and export controls.
Goodmorning to you good people (not you Deepinder). Now that India has entered the commercial era of "scienceploitation", I would like to educate and inform the people on this topic, using one of Temple device's claims as an example.
This is long, but stay with me, you will really benefit.
But first, what is Scienceploitation?
It is a marketing and communication tactic where brands, influencers, or media outlets borrow or manipulate language from legitimate, emerging areas of science (such as stem cell research, the microbiome, or epigenetics) to promote unproven health, wellness, or beauty products and services.
The term was coined by @CaulfieldTim (I am honored to have known him and written an editorial with him in the BMJ), a professor of health law and policy at the University of Alberta.
Temple Device is your first boss battle against scienceploitation. Let me explain this using their own biggest claim - ENTROPY. Temple claims it measures Entropy.
What is entropy? In lay terms, entropy is a measure of how spread out, mixed up, or disorganized things naturally become over time. In human health, entropy can be a measure of disorder, wear and tear, and loss of organization in your body's cells, tissues, and organ systems.
Low Entropy = High Health (Order): A young, healthy body is in a state of low entropy. Your cells are communicating well, your DNA is intact, your proteins are folded properly, and your heartbeats have a smooth, adaptable rhythm.
High Entropy = Disease or Aging (Disorder): As entropy increases, biological "mess" builds up. Damaged DNA accumulates, proteins misfold, cells stop working right, and communication breaks down.
Aging is essentially a slow, natural rise in entropy. While conditions like cancer (uncontrolled, chaotic cell growth), neurodegeneration (like Alzheimer’s protein tangles), and metabolic dysfunction (like uncontrolled blood sugar) represent spikes of high entropy in specific parts of the body. Note that - aging is a normal anatomical and physiological process, it is not a disease.
Now you know how complex this term is?
Well, this is what Deepinder Goyal's Temple device claims to measure.
A device can produce a number without proving that the number means what its advertising says. That is the central problem with Temple’s “Entropy.”
“Entropy” has different scientific meanings. In physics, it concerns energy transformations. In heartbeat or brainwave analysis, it describes how irregular or unpredictable a signal is. Measuring one does not mean you have measured the other, or someone’s overall health.
Yes, wearable recordings can be used to calculate signal entropy. A Polar H10 chest strap, for example, records heartbeat intervals that suitable software can analyse. GE’s clinical Entropy monitor analyses electrical signals from the forehead to help assess anaesthesia. Neither tells you how much “disorder” your body contains or how long you will live.
Temple’s published research describes an optical sensor that shines light into skin and detects changes associated with blood flow. That can provide useful physiological information of flow and perfusion only there or at the heart level, but not the brain or other systems. And detecting blood-related signals does not automatically measure whole-body heat loss, metabolism or thermodynamic entropy. Those claims are wild. Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence.
Researchers have estimated human thermodynamic entropy production. The experiment cited by Temple used a whole-body calorimeter, measurements of breathing gases and mathematical modelling. It did not demonstrate that a small optical sensor at the temple could do the same job. Misrepresenting and misinterpreting genuine research and extrapolating that to a new device does not establish that Temple performs the measurement described in that research - this is classical Scienceploitation. It Is "sciencey" word salads. Non-medical people will fall for this sort of gimmicks.
Temple also claims that lower resting “Entropy” means better health. That is not an established universal rule. Even the theoretical paper it cites discusses the importance of maintaining adequate entropy production and increasing it when needed—not simply driving the resting value ever lower. A lower number needs a proven health meaning before it becomes a health goal. Deepinder's Science Team has to prove this first, before they let their "machine" measure it - if it really can.
A reading that changes with exercise, meals, stress or temperature may be responding to real physiology. But that does not prove it measures immune health, digestion, reproductive function or recovery. Responding to many things is not the same as understanding or measuring all those things.
Temple lists (their own) preliminary studies of heart rate and brain-circulation-related signals. Those studies do not establish the advertised health meanings of “Resting Entropy,” “Entropy Max” or “Span.” These cannot be measured using currently available wearable tech, including Temple. Combining readings into a new score does not remove the need to validate that score, or if the score is really meaningful to start with. Pretty much like Homeopathy. So much stuff, no content or context.
Highly advanced wearable science is not impossible. The problem is presenting an unvalidated interpretation as an established fact about your body. Calling a product “wellness” does not make its scientific claims true. Temple device is the commercial, expensive example of consumer scienceploitation. The website needs to be updated with medical and health truths rather than magical thinking and delusions of so-called founder and his science team.
Deepinder's Temple device is very much like Baba Ramdev's Coronil. Only one difference. Former is scienceploitation, latter is pseudoscience and both are harmful in their own ways. Learn to identify a scam and fraud when you see one.
This is in very bad faith Yuvraj.
You are a good cricketer, you are a strong human, a cancer survivor. But you are an absolute health and science illiterate.
People like you and your business of bad science deeply damages science literacy and public health in our society. It is a pathetic.
You can be powerful allies for cancer patients and oncology societies and use your voice to educate people on evidence-based preventative care and direct cancer patients towards science-based care for improved survival outcomes.
But instead, you chose to team up with unethical businessmen - some with long degrees, lengthy certifications and in high positions without any functioning brain cell - and among them, one of the worst "health" influencers on the internet right now, the so-called cancer surgeon Arpit Bansal who is a pseudoscience sympathizer, an Ayurveda apologist and quite similar to Luke Coutinho, but with actual medical degrees wasted.
Know this first: Cancer patients who use alternative medicine die sooner, study finds - https://t.co/pvkpRmuyhC
Now coming to your product - P32
Among the 32 listed ingredients with 35+ distinct compounds in them, 13 carry documented risks of organ toxicity, mineral toxicity, capable of causing/promoting atherosclerosis inducing toxin generation, and with high rates of toxic environmental contamination.
Four ingredients - Ashwagandha, Bacopa, Curcumin and Boswellia are among the most frequently implicated botanicals in liver injury in LiverTox registries. When they come together, it is going to be disastrous.
https://t.co/Gya0Ycqdpc - The person who designed this complex formulation is really a clown.
Nearly all 30 active ingredients in this 32-ingredient supplement lack solid scientific proof for the health benefits promised on the label. First, the company's own chart admits that eight ingredients have no gold-standard human trials behind them - two are just inactive fillers, and six rely on weaker data or are added only for safety, yet are still marketed as multi-organ boosters.
At least 11 ingredients are "fairy-dusted," meaning the sachet contains only a tiny fraction of the daily dose actually proven to work in human studies.
High-level clinical and translational evidence demonstrates that several components in this sachet can actually increase cancer risk or accelerate tumor progression in healthy adults: Vitamin E (prostate cancer), combined folic acid+B12 (lung and colon cancer) and NAC, Vit E, Vit C, Astaxanthin (increase risk of cancer spread). See this paper:
Supplement Use and Increased Risks of Cancer: Unveiling the Other Side of the Coin - https://t.co/xqiDq6jL5c
Finally, the product stretches basic science by assuming that because a nutrient deficiency harms certain organs, taking extra amounts will supercharge those same organs in healthy adults who already get enough nutrients.
Your product is absolute BS just like the whole of herbal and dietary supplement industry is. Have some shame selling this nonsense to public and people with cancer.
I hope nobody accepts your stupid invite.
HELLO! I HAVE AN ANNOUNCEMENT THAT BENEFITS YOU! WE NEED YOUR SUPPORT.
We are back. And this time, we are taking on arguably the biggest wellness hack that people spend money on. The NEW Citizens Project will now look at a massive list of Probiotics for their quality claims.
People consume probiotics for a host of things. Gut health, protection against alcohol use, brain improvement, improving digestive symptoms, exercise recovery and even sleep!
Despite generating over $75 billion in annual sales (and heading toward $115 billion by 2030), most store-bought probiotics suffer from poor quality control because they are regulated as food supplements rather than medicines.
Independent lab tests regularly reveal that what is on the label is not inside the bottle: products frequently contain dead bacteria, far lower doses than advertised, missing bacterial types, or unlisted contaminants. Even when the microbes are alive on the shelf, poorly made capsules often fail to protect them, meaning stomach acid destroys the bacteria before they ever reach your gut.
These widespread failures show an urgent need for strict regulation and mandatory independent testing before products reach consumers. For a generally healthy person, over-the-counter probiotics rarely deliver real value for money or live up to their bold marketing promises.
Good bacteria are not a one-size-fits-all cure; specific microbes only help specific illnesses, and in a healthy gut, supplement bacteria usually pass right through the body without sticking around. Unless a doctor recommends a clinically proven product for a specific medical issue, buying daily general probiotics is largely an expensive waste of money.
Are you wasting money of the hyper rated probiotic supplements? Are you really getting what you spend money for? The Citizens Probiotics Project will look at standards and quality of probiotics sold to you across the medical and wellness pharma spectrum and in great depth that is the highest standards in medical science and industry.
We have the list (>100 products) and the pricing is being finalized. But, it you would like to get onboard and help us with early logistics, such as purchases and travel then please think about supporting us here with the minimum of ₹500 https://t.co/pthJTx0rXq ...or wait for the full project to go live for specific levels of funding for the public, in a few weeks.
We hope we can provide you with the highest quality of citizens science you'll ever witness in this era. Thank you in advance!
- for Mission for Ethics and Science in Healthcare (MESH) https://t.co/ifs3PUzAw9
#Bangalore film folks, here's the https://t.co/BBW8wcTaO5 film calendar: https://t.co/cEM5FXOtxn
Tracks a lot of interesting screenings from various sources. What should I add?
My dear friends, please, I hope to demand your absolute attention to this matter:
In 2018, my junior from St. John’s Medical College, Bengaluru, Dr. Randall Sequeira (middle in the pic), trekked up a steep, bauxite-rich plateau in Odisha to hold a monsoon health camp in the indigenous Kutiya Kondh village of Kutrumali.
In a piece he wrote then titled "Kutrumali’s Demons," Randall described sleeping under a dripping school roof in freezing fog, borrowing utensils from a local health worker to cook khichdi, and waking up at 6 AM to a line of tribal mothers. He wrote with heartbreak about treating malnourished toddlers with protruding bellies and visible ribs, listening to stories of stillbirths and chronic fevers, while noticing the shiny new solar lights installed by a mining conglomerate eyeing the aluminium ore beneath the villagers' feet.
Comparing his small medical team to hobbits sheltering in the night, Randall worried about the outside forces coming for that fragile village.
Randall stayed with the tribal/ adivasi community to serve them. After St. John’s and an MD in Internal Medicine from SMS Jaipur, he gave up every comfort of urban medicine to live in Kalahandi, recognizing that clinical prescriptions are meaningless when indigenous communities are stripped of their forests, water, and dignity.
On the night of October 16, Odisha police picked up Dr. Randall Sequeira and Dalit activist Laxman Naik at 11 PM from his home in Bhawanipatna. A gentle physician who has spent years trekking up hills to save tribal children is now locked in Rayagada sub-jail under frivolous but draconian charges (attempt to murder, dacoity), simply for standing with Adivasis peaceful protesting the mining of their sacred hills in Sijimali and Kutrumali.
https://t.co/PsxZZCngyV
Odisha Govt. said it will cut down forests to connect tribal villages. But it was a way to bypass green laws and fast track London based Vedanta’s, and Adani's mining plans. Local organisations estimate that around 45 villages depend on these hills and would be affected.
https://t.co/0pATUIYADm
The state has answered with repression rather than dialogue. In the last three years, at least 43 police cases have been filed and over a hundred Adivasis and Dalits, both women and men, have been incarcerated in Odisha jails. For example, from In March and april 2026, 8, 2026, to April 8, 2026, within one month, 24 people were sent to jail, 217 were made accused, and the number of “others” total 1,140. An activist who was not named in the original FIRs, but has since been implicated in about 12 cases, so that bail in one case is followed by arrest in another. This pattern of capture and releases have been used to crush rational dissent.
Dr. Randall understood that being a good doctor means understanding that prescriptions cannot compensate for the denial of land rights, that surgery cannot undo displacement and that no medical can substitute for the basic infrastructure a government has failed to provide.
https://t.co/fOC9AU3jaR
To my fellow medical fraternity, and every citizen with a conscience: a kind physician who embodies the highest ethics of our profession is being criminalized to clear the way for bauxite mining. Please do not let his voice be buried in a sub-jail.
Amplify this, demand due process, and demand the immediate release. Please sign in this form to show solidarity: https://t.co/cgLIoEXExG
If anyone can help out in this situation please reach out to Medico Friend Circle - https://t.co/OT2D2E3DuW
@gauravsabnis We turn faith into chaos, ignore basic safety, then mourn the dead.
When preventable deaths keep repeating, it’s not a tragedy. It’s negligence with a body count.