Chasing an extra 1-2% return through stock picking is the smallest lever a middle class Indian has while Growing active income is the biggest.
Income growth is hard work, which's fully in your control, and yet most of you will pick a stock instead, which is never in your control.
SEBI's recommendation of Tax-Free Switch on the Long Term MF Units can be a really good thing for RIAs helping their client:
> Move from Regular funds to Direct Funds
> Get Rid of Poor Quality Funds
> Consolidate MF portfolio to a handful of funds
all of these in a single shot!
Contrarily, investors who do not have a financial advisors will be prone to their own behaviour.
Very high chance of people playing around with their long term, switching and trading funds year on year to chase the recent top performing fund.
Professions built on the base of Trust and Relationship are going to prevail while the one's which are just 'Transactional' are/will be decimated simply because the cost of transaction is reduced and the efficiency and the quality of the output are enormously superior.
Wake up.
Every profession deemed white-collar, the middle class dream, is about to be decimated by AI, at a much faster pace than anticipated, with monstrous social consequences.
Last year I wrote about Kumar Awasthi, a retired Army officer whose bank sold him ₹1.36 crore of AT-1 bonds as a “Super FD for Senior Citizens.” That was most of his retirement savings.
Today the Supreme Court ruled that Yes Bank’s write-off of those bonds worth ₹8,415 crore was illegal.
The court also found that Yes Bank actively offered these bonds to individual investors, in violation of RBI’s own rules.
Which is exactly what "Mis-Sold" Documentary by @1FinanceHQ and @BahlKanan showed, through the people who lived it. (link in comments)
Awasthi's branch manager, a 13yr old friend of him, sold the riskiest paper a bank can issue and called it a fixed deposit, which is insane.
Six years later today, the supreme court has said the wipe-out should never have happened the way it did.
That is not the end of it. What bondholders actually get back is still a grey area and the incentive that put these bonds in a retired officer’s hands has not changed one bit.
@1FinanceHQ@JeetMarwadi@kevalb26
HDFC Bank just fired 3 senior executives over AT-1 bond mis-selling.
HDFC isn't the only bank.
A retired Army officer who fought in 1962 and 1971 lost ₹1.36 crores to the same scam. A friend, a Yes Bank branch manager, sold him AT-1 bonds as "Super FD for Senior Citizens."
This video is from The Mis-Sold Documentary by @1FinanceHQ@BahlKanan
The story of Kumar Awasthi, a retired Army personnel who served India at the borders, mis-sold AT-1 bonds at premium as "Super FD for Senior Citizens" worth Rs 1.36 crores. Written off when Yes Bank collapsed.
Around 1,300 individuals were pushed AT-1 bonds as "Super FDs." Across banks. Across cities.
Firing 3 executives makes a headline. But to understand why this keeps happening, you need to understand how a bank RM's world actually works.👇
Every quarter, revenue targets flow from the top down. HQ decides which products need to be pushed. Branch managers receive those allocations and pass them to RMs on the ground. The RM's job security, bonus, and career trajectory are all tied to meeting these numbers.
An AT-1 bond pays a significantly higher commission than a simple FD. When the incentive structure pays and forces you to mis-sell masking the riskiest product with the least informed customer, the outcome is a disaster.
The RM who sold Awasthi these bonds was his friend of 13 years. When confronted, he said: "I didn't know the product would do this. There was pressure from above."
That one sentence is worth sitting with...
This is how the chain works at every bank:
The customer walks in trusting the institution ➡️ The RM doesn't understand the product but has a target to meet ➡️ The branch manager doesn't question the product because the target came from above ➡️ The product team doesn't think about the customer because they never meet one.
Everyone is evaluated and PAID on how much did they sell.
@SEBI_India , @RBI , and @irdaindia can regulate what gets sold. When they should be actively regulating 'WHY?' it gets sold.
Regulators can police products but they can't policing the incentives. As long as an RM earns more selling you an high commission products because his pay is linked to it, the outcome wont change.
@nsitharamanoffc@FinMinIndia
So is another hike coming?
The median of 47 forecasters in the RBI’s September survey, taken before the hike, had the repo rate at 5.75% by March.
That is one more 25 bps hike from here...🪡
🧵RBI’s committee went from a unanimous “neutral” in Aug to a unanimous hike and “calibrated tightening” in Oct.
The whole committee changed its mind in eight weeks.
The Monetary Policy Report that came with the decision reads like a case for the next hike.
Seven signals👇
The RBI hasn't raised rates in 44 months. That streak is most likely ends tomorrow at 10 am.
Last month I argued a hike was due in the quoted post, but lenders are already betting 'it won't be the only hike', and the government's own borrowing costs show it.👇
Here's what the last four weeks added:
🔶 RBI drained more than half of the liquidity
In early September, banks were drowning in the liquidity that the overnight call rate fell to 4.97%, below the RBI's own 5.00% floor.
A hike then would have moved the headline and little else.
→ Reverse repo auctions: half worked. Banks parked cash overnight but wouldn't lock it away for weeks.
A 26-day auction on 11 September drew just 12% of what was on offer.
→ Bond sales: ₹1 lakh crore, its first net sale since 2017. That money is gone for good, but the sales push yields up.
→ Dollar sales and mid-September tax payments did the rest.
→ CRR stayed on the shelf, because using it would undercut the FCNR(B) scheme.
The surplus fell from ₹11.16 lakh crore to about ₹4.45 lakh crore, and the call rate climbed back above the repo. A hike now reaches your FD and your EMI.
🔶 Lenders expect three hikes by early 2027
→ On 23 September, the government paid 5.39% to borrow for three months and 6.09% to borrow for a year. That gap only makes sense if lenders expect rates to keep rising, and it works out to roughly three hikes by early next year.
→ The MPC's own minutes point the same way. Deputy Governor Poonam Gupta wrote that "a case for a hike may emerge during the course of the year."
🔶 Inflation hasn't peaked, and the RBI knows it
→ August CPI was 4.82%, and rural inflation was already at 5.23%.
→ The RBI's own forecast takes headline inflation to 5.9% this quarter, 5.5% in January to March, and 5.3% in April to June 2027.
A rate hike takes about three quarters, to start bringing inflation down. That estimate comes from the RBI committee that designed India's inflation-targeting framework. So tomorrow's hike will do its real work around mid-2027.
The RBI's own forecast puts inflation at 5.3% in that window, which is still above today's 5.25% repo rate. Even after a hike to 5.50%, the real rate (the repo minus inflation) would be only about 0.2%.
One hike barely lifts it above zero.
→ So clearly, one hike will not be enough.
The Taylor Rule, a rule of thumb for where a policy rate should sit, says no. Take the low end of the RBI's own neutral-rate estimate (1.4%), add August's core inflation (4.4%), then add half the gap between that inflation and the 4% target. You get a repo of about 6.0%.
Tomorrow only gets us to 5.50%.
Tomorrow most likely ends a 44-month wait.
Lenders, the MPC and the Taylor Rule all say it won't be the last hike!
Your Repo-Linked Home Loans are about to get Expensive!
7/ The real rate is still negative
➤ The repo rate is 5.50%, below the RBI’s inflation forecast for each of the next three quarters: 6.0%, 5.7% and 5.6%
➤ The real rate is minus 0.5%, minus 0.2% and minus 0.1%. To slow demand, borrowing has to cost something after inflation
The RBI hasn't raised rates in 44 months. That streak is most likely ends tomorrow at 10 am.
Last month I argued a hike was due in the quoted post, but lenders are already betting 'it won't be the only hike', and the government's own borrowing costs show it.👇
Here's what the last four weeks added:
🔶 RBI drained more than half of the liquidity
In early September, banks were drowning in the liquidity that the overnight call rate fell to 4.97%, below the RBI's own 5.00% floor.
A hike then would have moved the headline and little else.
→ Reverse repo auctions: half worked. Banks parked cash overnight but wouldn't lock it away for weeks.
A 26-day auction on 11 September drew just 12% of what was on offer.
→ Bond sales: ₹1 lakh crore, its first net sale since 2017. That money is gone for good, but the sales push yields up.
→ Dollar sales and mid-September tax payments did the rest.
→ CRR stayed on the shelf, because using it would undercut the FCNR(B) scheme.
The surplus fell from ₹11.16 lakh crore to about ₹4.45 lakh crore, and the call rate climbed back above the repo. A hike now reaches your FD and your EMI.
🔶 Lenders expect three hikes by early 2027
→ On 23 September, the government paid 5.39% to borrow for three months and 6.09% to borrow for a year. That gap only makes sense if lenders expect rates to keep rising, and it works out to roughly three hikes by early next year.
→ The MPC's own minutes point the same way. Deputy Governor Poonam Gupta wrote that "a case for a hike may emerge during the course of the year."
🔶 Inflation hasn't peaked, and the RBI knows it
→ August CPI was 4.82%, and rural inflation was already at 5.23%.
→ The RBI's own forecast takes headline inflation to 5.9% this quarter, 5.5% in January to March, and 5.3% in April to June 2027.
A rate hike takes about three quarters, to start bringing inflation down. That estimate comes from the RBI committee that designed India's inflation-targeting framework. So tomorrow's hike will do its real work around mid-2027.
The RBI's own forecast puts inflation at 5.3% in that window, which is still above today's 5.25% repo rate. Even after a hike to 5.50%, the real rate (the repo minus inflation) would be only about 0.2%.
One hike barely lifts it above zero.
→ So clearly, one hike will not be enough.
The Taylor Rule, a rule of thumb for where a policy rate should sit, says no. Take the low end of the RBI's own neutral-rate estimate (1.4%), add August's core inflation (4.4%), then add half the gap between that inflation and the 4% target. You get a repo of about 6.0%.
Tomorrow only gets us to 5.50%.
Tomorrow most likely ends a 44-month wait.
Lenders, the MPC and the Taylor Rule all say it won't be the last hike!
Your Repo-Linked Home Loans are about to get Expensive!
US hiked 25 bps yesterday.
ECB hiked last week.
BoJ is at its highest rate since 1995.
Meanwhile India's repo hasn't moved, even with CPI above the RBI's 4% target for three months straight.
Everyone is tightening except us.
Here's why, and what the RBI has been doing instead👇
First, the world.
🔹The Fed's move yesterday was its first hike since 2023, a unanimous vote, and 16 of 18 officials pencilled in at least one more before the year ends.
🔹The ECB's hike last week was its second this year after eight straight cuts. The BoJ is at 1% with another hike priced as near certain this month.
🔹Even the BOE, which held at 3.75% today, had three of nine members voting to hike, and markets give an 80% chance the first one lands in November.
None of these economies has crisis level inflation.
→ US core is around 3.4%.
→ UK is at 3.1%.
→Europe around 3%.
→ Japan barely above 2%.
So why is everyone moving?
Because they all got burnt by the same mistake in 2021-22.
They called inflation transitory and waited for the data to confirm it, and then had to hit the brakes so hard it nearly broke their economies.
This time the trigger is common, oil being above $100 because of the West Asia conflict, and sort of a lesson.
"Move on where inflation is heading rather than where it has been."
Which brings us back to India, because the RBI spent the last three months fighting a completely different fire.
Rewind to May.
→ Rupee at a record low near 97
→ Oil above $100
→ Foreign money leaving
→ Reserves down from $728 billion to $682 billion.
Instead of hiking rates to defend the rupee, the RBI went another way:
🔸 Took on the entire hedging cost for banks raising 3-5 year FCNR(B) dollar deposits, which let banks offer NRIs 7%+ on dollars
🔸 Opened a concessional swap window for PSU overseas borrowing
🔸 The govt scrapped capital gains and interest tax for foreign investors in government bonds
The results:
→ $136 billion of foreign currency in by 31 August
→ Reserves at a record $729 billion, up $63 billion in eight weeks
→ Rupee stable in a 94.5-96 band
→ And when the RBI saw how much money was flooding in, it shut the window six weeks early on its own.
Credit where it is due. We have a cushion.
But now the reality!
→ Every one of those dollars entered the banking system as rupees.
→ The liquidity surplus is near ₹11 lakh crore, about 3% of GDP.
→ Last week the RBI offered banks a ₹5 lakh crore VRRR window to park cash overnight at 5.24%.
They only parked ₹60,449 crore (12%).
Banks did not find 5.24% attractive enough to lock up more than 12% of what was offered.
→ Meanwhile CPI is at 4.82% against a repo of 5.25%. Subtract where inflation is heading and the real return on your savings is roughly zero.
@TantriPrasanna has been calling out the same that, Act before the inflation print forces you to.
After this week it is harder to dismiss, because the Fed, the ECB and the BoJ are all doing exactly same!
Not funny how things have changed since the beginning of the year where we were expecting rate cuts, then things got ugly and then we expected a pause, and then now the tables have turned for a 50bps hike!
IRDAI's job is to protect the person paying the premium and not protecting the industry's margins
Mis-selling of Insurance is happening because of the commission-based-incentive by the insurance company, but everything apart from it is being addressed👇 https://t.co/GGLTPS7KLr