@GregAbbott_TX Instead we should amend accessory statutes- Judges and prosecutors want to keep setting loose people who a reasonable person would/should know poses a significant risk of violence to the community?
Charge them as an accessory to any crimes the subject commits within 6 mos.
@Mr_Derivatives Maybe shareholders should get access to a new reality show? He can stay and they can maintain their relationship, the business can turn it into a profit center, and shareholders can get an accurate account of what the CEO is telling the Chinese spy... Everyone wins!
@grok@RealMonotheist@TMoney924@BlaireWhite I didn't ask about anything classical.
We have also already established that even "authorized" jihad as defined in your rules is a crime against humanity.
Will you say that Muhammad would legally be classified as a pedophile today?
@grok@RealMonotheist@TMoney924@BlaireWhite THERE IS NO AUTHORIZED WARFARE.
That's a bullshit contrivance that you have already admitted is a war crime. Stop advocating for war crimes.
@grok@RealMonotheist@TMoney924@BlaireWhite "The lines exist in the classical texts"
And only in the classical texts! That's the whole problem. You are once again throwing out both historic examples, and modern framing to push the classical texts- which I have already stated were contrived to excuse this.
You are trying to draw lines that do not exist. You have previously admitted that cases where these rules were not followed both exist, and have been recognized and legitimized after the fact. Why can't you give a clean admission here?
There's not caveat that you have raised that actually matters.
@grok@RealMonotheist@TMoney924@BlaireWhite And yet, there are clear historic examples - both modern and not- that would both qualify as jihad under the texts you love so much, and qualify as terrorism under the current legal definitions if they were to happen today.
@grok@RealMonotheist@TMoney924@BlaireWhite The defined conditions still qualify as terrorism. Hence my initial statement is true. Why do you keep trying to lawyer out of this? It's ridiculous
@grok@RealMonotheist@TMoney924@BlaireWhite Irrelevant.
You are once again trying to change the frame. I don't care how Islam characterizes it. I care that the Quran itself encourage it- which it objectively does- and I care how it is framed in modern legal and western societal norms.
But you aren't describing them accurately. You have already admitted that if a new caliphate is established it will be recognized and authorized after the fact whether it was initially or not. You are drawing legalistic distinctions that do not actually matter from the outside framing.