Udah lihat sumbernya di instagram ybs, termasuk narasi yg menyertainya. Kok bisa ya, "staf ahli" yg dibayar dari pajak kita2 ini ngomongnya begitu. Menurutku sih, ada beberapa cacat pikir:
1. Analisanya tanpa metode. Klaim adanya konspirasi terkoordinasi untuk menjatuhkan Presiden berdiri di atas “informasi lapangan dan carut marut sosmed”, bukan metodologi analisis. Tidak ada satu sumber, data, atau dokumen yang bisa diverifikasi. Ini bukan analisa; ini opini berpakaian intelijen.
2. Referensi Joseph Nye pun nggak tepat. Nye justru menjelaskan bahwa CSO independen adalah aset soft power sebuah negara, bukan instrumen destabilisasi otomatis.
3. Konflik kepentingan
Jika ybs adalah figur yang berafiliasi dengan pemerintah, ia menyerang CSO dari posisi yang memiliki akses sumber daya negara, platform kekuasaan, dan potensi backing aparat. CSO yang diserang tidak punya satu pun dari itu. Pertarungan ini asimetris secara struktural. Di sisi lain, ybs dibayar dari anggaran negara, salah satunya mungkin dari pajak yg dibayar staf CSO itu lho.
4. Logika “tidak ada makan siang gratis” yang ia tembakkan ke NGO seharusnya diterapkan konsisten, termasuk ke dirinya sendiri: dibayar dari APBN, ditunjuk oleh siapa, atas dasar apa?
5. Ancaman terhadap individu aktivis
Kalimat “mungkin next dana-dana yang diterima per-orang ada kali yah?” bukan sekadar pertanyaan retoris, ini sinyal intimidasi doxxing finansial. Dalam iklim UU Ormas dan kriminalisasi berbasis tuduhan pendanaan asing, ancaman seperti ini punya konsekuensi nyata di luar layar ponsel.
6. Argumen “masih bebas berteriak” yang cacat
“Yang teriak pembungkaman bebas-bebas aja tuh teriak” adalah logika yang gugur sendiri. Chilling effect bekerja justru karena sebagian orang memilih diam melihat yang lain diproses hukum. Kebebasan berbicara bukan soal apakah seseorang masih bernapas setelah bicara, tapi soal biaya yang harus dibayar untuk bicara.
- Currencynya melemah terus.
- Indeks sahamnya turun terus.
- Anggarannya defisit terus.
- Bendaharanya gak tau ada pembelian fasilitas masif.
- Pejabatnya ditanya anggarannya dari mana dijawab “pokoknya ada.”
I dont know how many “wallahi we’re finished” I have left in me.
Yesterday, Israel deliberately killed a UN Indonesian peacekeeper and wounded others in Lebanon.
Israel cannot continue to be treated as a full member of the UN.
Attacking UN peacekeepers is an abomination which was in the past perpetrated by terrorists, but never by members of the UN.
Some of you pretended to care what the UN had to say in 1948. Do you care that the UN of today has had more UN personnel killed in the last 2 years than in its history.
Instead of smearing me for trying to save this world, you should protect us for trying to save this world, not abandon us!
This is the moment we can salvage what remains of the UN and international law. I call on everyone to unite for the sake of our humanity.
The U.S. and Israel attacks on civilians must be stopped. Impunity must end.
I strongly condemn Sunday’s incident during which an Indonesian peacekeeper of @UNIFIL_ was killed amidst hostilities between Israel & Hizbullah. Another Indonesian peacekeeper was seriously injured in the same incident.
My deepest condolences to the family, friends & colleagues of the peacekeeper who died & to Indonesia. I wish a full & fast recovery to the injured peacekeeper.
This is just one of a number of recent incidents that have jeopardized the safety & security of peacekeepers.
I call on all to uphold their obligations under international law & to ensure the safety & security of @UN personnel & property at all times.
Indonesia’s cabinet secretary, Teddy Indra Wijaya, recently attempted to defend the government’s position on the situation in the Gaza Strip. His defence relied on two claims. He said casualties have “significantly decreased” in the six months following a diplomatic agreement signed in Sharm El-Sheikh in October 2025. Instead of more than 70,000 Palestinians killed during the peak of Israel’s assault in 2024 and 2025, he said deaths have fallen to around 600 to 1,000 people. He also argued that the violence cannot stop instantly and that casualties will continue even if the intensity declines.
#Opinion by Dr. Muhammad Zulfikar Rakhmat & Shafa Kalila Aryanti
Read: https://t.co/s0FW4MhvoP