@Amelia37401857@keisha_3_ That's blood quantum and there's a complicated colonial way behind that thinking. Joseph and Emilia Clarke have great grandparents that are 1/8th Aboriginal and Indian. To the world, they are white
@just_confetti@faithsjustice Judging by how the season favors people who know the lore, I don't think they are. When they released the poster with Galadriel and a man I didn't know, like I was expected to know him, that wasn't for me
@just_confetti@chiaro_scuro_x@faithsjustice It's very lazy writing. This is the relationship Galadriel is in so I expected better. What I see is a sad lonely woman clinging to what's left for her to love. That's an interesting story but it's not the fairytale they're telling me
@chiaro_scuro_x@just_confetti@faithsjustice I don't know much help I am. The more immersed I get in Twitter fandom, I learn more without reading the books. I'll give my opinions though. I have felt alienated by the season
@chiaro_scuro_x@just_confetti@faithsjustice TROP said Galadriel saw imprisoned Celeborn in front of her and did not investigate any further. Galadriel has never been shown to have hallucinations until this season. She didn't have any metaphysical reason to believe he wasn't real then. She didn't have her ring then
@just_confetti@faithsjustice It's bad writing. I've been confused why the episodes show a different story than their interviews. TROP also tried to rewrite Finrod being Galadriel's motivation to hunt Sauron but it's a rewrite and an ineffective one since Finrod is part of Galadriel all S1. Celeborn isn't
@just_confetti@faithsjustice I don't remember the movies much and I haven't read the books. As a show viewer, I tried but when Galadriel says "the love we have left" on top of the pattern of her not prioritizing him, my takeaway is not what they're telling me
@hrrystylzluvbot Joseph is white like Emilia Clarke is white despite her Indian great grandmother. They are 1/8th Aboriginal and Indian respectively. They move through the world as white people
this is a really interesting read. i was rooting for des because i would have loved to see devi x des, but his character also represented a v real brown boy moment that while cliche, is rooted in some truth
@robertjosephval She was told that Sauron was dead and didn't accept it. She decided Celeborn was her imagination. She believed C was dead again without proof until Theo told her he was alive. It's a pattern. Book readers work backwards from canon. It prevents media comprehension #TROPSpoilers
@celedriell She didn't accept Sauron's death. She saw Celeborn and decided he was a figment of her imagination. She believed Celeborn was dead without proof until Theo told her he was alive. A pattern. Book readers work backwards from canon and don't follow what's on the show #TROPSpoilers