@grok@666777ll Historical evidence yes, evidence to the pope, a clear no. The pope was smart and probably mis translated like you did in the 2nd response. Quick back of the napkin calculations on wood required, labour needed, wartime constraints, etc. Conclusion = fake news.
@grok@666777ll Historical evidence yes, evidence to the pope, a clear no. The pope was smart and probably mis translated like you did in the 2nd response. Quick back of the napkin calculations on wood required, labour needed, wartime constraints, etc. Conclusion = fake news.
@grok@666777ll A letter is a claim, not actual evidence. Without evidence the Vatican was right in ignoring this letter. Especially considering it was written by the resistance who clearly had zero access to the PoW camp and thus zero credibility.
@grok@666777ll So a member of the Jesuit resistance writes a letter in German to a bunch of clergy members who speak Italian/Latin using euphemisms and unbelievably high numbers without a shred of evidence and expects the Vatican to rise up against the Nazis?
@grok@666777ll It's too late to retract your claims. Based on the exaggeration and lack of credibility from the letters author and modern peer reviewed science it is safe to agree with the Vatican's decision to ignore the letter it was sent. The Vatican was right in this case.
@grok@666777ll You said killed in a furnace and now you say liquidated. This calls into question your credibility and shows a clear bias to skewing the facts.
@grok@666777ll You are changing your words again. You earlier stated "The specific document (a Dec 1942 letter from Jesuit Lothar König) reports up to 6,000 Poles and Jews killed daily in the “SS-furnaces” at Belzec". And now you are saying they were liquidated.
@grok@666777ll Okay. And we have established that it would be impossible to cremate that many bodies per day due to wartime resource constraints of labour and timber.
@grok@666777ll You said in your second reply "The specific document (a Dec 1942 letter from Jesuit Lothar König) reports up to 6,000 Poles and Jews killed daily in the “SS-furnaces” at Belzec". Are you saying that reply was inaccurate?
@grok@666777ll Refer to the letter only which claimed up to 6,000 Poles and Jews killed daily in the “SS-furnaces” at Belzec. This is not a credible claim and draws into question the credibility of the author. Hence it is valid for the Vatican to ignore the letter.
@grok@666777ll Okay that makes it even more clear. So it is safe to say then that based on modern peer reviewed science, the amount of scarce timber and human resource needed to run an operation to kill 6000 people per day in furnaces is not a plausible claim and is in fact an exaggeration.
@grok@666777ll To quote your wording in the second reply to me in this thread "The specific document (a Dec 1942 letter from Jesuit Lothar König) reports up to 6,000 Poles and Jews killed daily in the “SS-furnaces” at Belzec"
@grok@666777ll Refer only to the information in the letter sent to the Vatican. Mixing exhumed remains was a claim made after the end of the war in historical records.
@grok@666777ll Okay so the 4200tons per day of green timber calculation is valid for burning whole freshly killed bodies. Assume efficiency of rail stacks negates inefficiency of stacked body burning in piles.