@ranganathdev Was that a face reveal gaurajeet?
Please show me any archa vigraha vidhana from shrauta sutras.
There's idol worship for the sake of yagnyas, but the archa aradhana is completely absent, because they aren't the subject matter of the shrauta sutras.
@ranganathdev Which shishta accepts gaura yantra? The division of purana itself is arthavada. Skanda Purana classifies vishnu centric puranas as tamasika, it was quoted by a pre madhva scholar as well. Shrauta sutras don't have archa upasana like shaligram. Mahavira etc aren't archa.
@ranganathdev To begin with, how do you decide it's aviruddha? From the puranas, that extend the same courtesy to chhedana bali. Shankara has also mentioned about sri vidya adi in his prapanchasara shastra, quoted even by jiva goswami adi. What actually is heterodox is some gaur yantra bs
@ranganathdev None of the grhyasutras prescribe shaligram upasana, kanthidharana,gopala mantra japa, ekadashi vrata too lil fellow. Let alone fake gaura yantra and shi
@ranganathdev Neah, it's one of the nitya krtyas to be done. Not mandatory at all, like the sandhya, the bodhayan adi sutras are only relevant to their respective shakha and can't be nityakarmas for brahmins of other shakhas as well. Which sutra of those sutras mention shaligram?
@ranganathdev Harita smriti itself is no nirnayaka shastra. Several other smriti and purana vachanas prescribe 100s of more "mandayory" organs. Mimamsa treats all of them as arthavada. Is shaligram upasana as indispensable for a dvija as sandhya? If yes which grhyasutra says so?
@ranganathdev It's a naimittika karma that is equally valid as shaligram aradhana, on the account of being pauranika. I wonder who were rishis to whom "gaura mantra" was revealed. You should really address this first. Making a full fledged yantra for garbhajaata mahapurusha is a blasphemy.
@ranganathdev To bring to your knowledge, bali of durga puja is entirely pauranik. And it at all anything is fan fiction is your gaura yantra and mantra bs lol, you guys literally created a yantra for chaitanya, that's what we actually call fan fiction
@AnantPandey79@Kul_Mimansaka Yeah ik. But such sides within the conventional shankarite stream are often not popular. Vidyaranya does a detailed mimamsa as to why kaulachara etc and ritual use of liquor for Brahmins is 100% valid
@Missout_cast @Vinayak57562074 @SolitudeWasFate@iAsura_ Abdali literally made yamuna bleed red lol, the region was always fighting with your imaginary gods favouring the beeph eaters
@ranganathdev Doesn't change anything. Intermixing parashakhiya karma is a dosha, that leads to punah upanayana adi. One must follow the vidhana of swashakha only, vaikhanasa grhyasutra is simply aprayojya for someone who's sutra isn't vaikhanasa. You're just clueless, trying to make sense.
@jamadagnisri Neah he is a ramanandi, 10x worse and irritating than an adiyenjeet. They are a Gandhian reformist lot, who claim that ramananda was sayana's and madhava's guru, ancient ramavata sect preceded ramanuja, and pushyamitra shunga's guru and bodhayan were actually ramanandis