Others have rebutted this screed on the immigration front (where it also fails), but allow me to destroy the points presented as financial and economic justification for being against skilled immigration.
Palmer Luckey seems to believe :
i) There are a fixed amount of jobs in the US. This is known as the 'Lump of Labor fallacy'. So if a startup grows and creates jobs, did that destroy jobs in existing firms?
ii) There are a fixed amount of dollars in the US. People leaving the US after a stay of a few years, and taking their own money with them, is bad because it 'takes money out of America'. Yet, Palmer elsewhere complains that the Federal Reserve printing $8 Trillion is also bad, since this 'adds too much to the money supply'. These two positions are contradictory.
Beyond that, it gets worse:
iii) I am sure someone of Palmer's wealth knows that foreigners are, in fact, able to purchase shares in US companies. Did he think that Apple, Google, NVidia, etc. are not available to foreign investors?
iv) VC firms often have foreign LPs. In addition to that, Sovereign Wealth Funds open VC firms on Sand Hill Road and invest in US startups. Again, Palmer knows this already, so his comment here is strange.
v) About 33% of Fortune500 revenue is from outside the US. So Palmer wants to halt skilled immigration, but somehow the revenue coming in from overseas is fine. One can no more oppose globalization than they can oppose gravity.
vi) He says that 20% of skilled immigrants return home in five years. So wait, that is bad? Does that means he wants every H1B to get a greencard and stay her permanently?
And someone who was here for a short time surely did not earn that much money and vested shares. Yet he cites this as some huge withdrawal from the US economy (which has a fixed amount of dollars, of course).
vii) Remittances : Imagine being against someone sending their OWN money to their mother. Anyway, India is only #75 in terms of foreign remittances as a percentage of recipient country's GDP. Bogus point.
viii) "I lean very libertarian" Not based on this, he doesn't. Yeah, and feminists only want equality.
ix) "did not think Americans should have to compete with the entire Third World".
Wait, so they are 'third world' (i.e. inferior), but in just five years, they earn so much money and vested shares that the departure of 20% of them back to their home countries is significant as a capital exodus?
x) "American law should, and does, advantage American citizens." I agree.
But surely Palmer has seen that every youth STEM contest, from the Regeneron STS to iGEM to the 3M Young Scientist Award has extraordinary dominance by Indian-American and to a lesser extent Chinese-American children.
These prize contests are for children ages 11-17, and they are American kids, with only their parents or grandparents being immigrants.
Invariably, about 40-60% of the finalists are Indian (1.5% of the pop) and 70-90% are Indian + Chinese (3% of the pop). Even if skilled immigration ended now, American STEM by 2035 is going to be overwhelmingly Chinese- and Indian-American.
So in addition to all the immigration points where others have destroyed Palmer's arguments, his finance and economic points are terrible as well.
Second only to JD Vance, Palmer Lucky has chosen to appease the lowest-human-capital race socialists in a manner that wholly contradicts his real life. Like JD, he seems to have greatly overestimated both their numbers and their human capital per capita. Their approval is not desirable on any level, especially since they just want intra-white socialism with wealthy white people like Palmer footing the bill.
Stay tuned to @HuaweiENT Star Products & flagship solution launch to see how our #HiCampus and #HiDC redefine campuses & data centers: Details: ๐ https://t.co/xPzUSGwIRq #HuaweiMWC#MWC20 https://t.co/wuLIQkIVjM