‼️A serious warning from 🇭🇺 Hungary: an increasing number of people, in this case legal dignities regardless of their political allegiance, are speaking out against the current government's legal abuses and politically motivated prosecutions of opposition politicians. These serious abuses in Hungary mean that neither the European Commission nor the European Parliament can continue to stand idly by.
This is an important statement!
TEN PRINCIPLES OF CRIMINAL JUSTICE UNDER THE RULE OF LAW
We, the undersigned lawyers, believe in the achievements of the transition to democracy, which established a clear distinction between the rule of law and a police state by protecting individual freedoms from the whims of those in power. We feel that these 37-year-old achievements are in danger today.
1.) In a state governed by the rule of law, fundamental human rights apply equally to everyone, including those who break the law. Due process is essential, even when society rightfully demands accountability in a given case.
2.) In a state governed by the rule of law, everyone is entitled to the presumption of innocence. This means that suspects should not be brought before the authorities in full restraints unless there is a specific security risk. Turning criminal proceedings into a humiliating and intimidating political spectacle played out in the media violates both the presumption of innocence and the right to a fair trial.
3.) In a state governed by the rule of law, arrest is not a form of advance punishment, but rather a necessary and proportionate restriction of the accused’s personal liberty to ensure the successful conduct of criminal proceedings.
4.) In a state governed by the rule of law, arrest is a legal institution subject to strict conditions: it may only be used in cases of real and well-founded risk of flight, concealment, reoffending or obstruction of justice. It is absurd to invoke these grounds in the case of individuals for whom the possibility of reoffending is ruled out, such as those who have been aware of the impending proceedings for months, have voluntarily reported to the investigating authorities and could have destroyed the evidence long ago if they had intended to do so.
5.) In a state governed by the rule of law, the purpose of arrest cannot be to break a person’s will or coerce confessions. Deprivation of liberty ordered on the basis of fabricated grounds constitutes torture and serves not the rule of law, but rather as a demonstration of power and deterrence.
6.) In a state governed by the rule of law, judicial oversight of deprivation of liberty serves a protective function. The 1989 amendment to the Code of Criminal Procedure, which transferred authority over what was then known as 'pretrial detention' to the judiciary, reflected a changed understanding of the relationship between the state and the individual, as well as a greater appreciation of personal liberty. Automatically ordered arrests render judicial protection meaningless and superfluous.
7.) According to statutory regulations, in a state governed by the rule of law, handcuffs may only be used in cases of risk of escape, risk of assault, risk of self-harm or resistance.
8.) In a state governed by the rule of law, coercive measures should not be used to create humiliating or intimidating political spectacles. Leading suspects away in handcuffs under the glare of cameras violates the principle of proportionality.
9.) In a state governed by the rule of law, there is no acceptable justification for monitoring a defence attorney.
10.) The sole purpose of criminal proceedings in a state governed by the rule of law must be to uncover the objective truth, not to validate a political agenda.
Signatories:
Péter Hack, professor emeritus, former member of the National Assembly;
Gábor Fodor, former minister, former member of the National Assembly;
András Schiffer, attorney, former member of the National Assembly;
Mihály Bihari, professor emeritus, former president of the Constitutional Court, former member of the National Assembly;
László Bodolai, attorney;
Zoltán Borbély, attorney;
Rudolf Garay, attorney;
István Gortvay, attorney;
András Grundtner, public official;
Róbert Juharos, attorney, former member of the National Assembly;
András Koltay, university professor;
Imre Kónya, attorney, founding director of the Independent Lawyers’ Forum, former Minister of the Interior;
Mária Kóródi, former member of the National Assembly and Deputy Speaker of Parliament, former minister;
Tamás Kötter, writer, attorney;
István Kukorelli, professor emeritus, former Constitutional Court justice;
Dániel Kurucz, editor-in-chief of Köztér;
Zoltán Lomnici Jr., attorney;
Botond Mándics, attorney;
István László Mészáros, attorney, former member of the National Assembly;
Angelika Mihalik, attorney;
Tibor Navracsics, associate professor, former minister and former member of the National Assembly, former member of the European Commission
Zsolt Németh, retired colonel, associate professor;
Márta Pankucsi, lawyer and sociologist, university lecturer;
Béla Pokol, professor emeritus, former Constitutional Court justice;
Róbert Répássy, attorney, former State Secretary for Justice;
Gyöngyvér Schillinger, writer;
István Stumpf, Széchenyi Prize-winning university professor, former Constitutional Court justice, and former Minister of the Chancellery;
Tamás Szép, attorney and local council member;
István Szikinger, attorney;
Katalin Szili, former Speaker of the National Assembly;
Zoltán Szotyori-Lázár, attorney and compliance lawyer;
Máté Tóth, attorney, energy lawyer, and university teacher
The prime minister of Hungary in the parliament today. He could not control himself. He fidgeted, constantly interrupted the representatives’ speeches, and spoke to them in a vulgar manner. Parliament has never seen anything like it. He is a mentally unstable man stuck in childhood with behavioral issues. It’s pathetic.