Joie

💙karina

[ChinaKarinaBar @ChinaKarinaBar]

1️⃣宁艺卓回复的帖子有两张图，p1是宁艺卓唯粉对柳智敏全家的攻击开盒以及谣言传播，p2是这位博主因为对p1宁艺卓唯粉的回击，截图了宁艺卓和母亲早年公开综艺的问答对话。
2️⃣@NingNing_Bar 在推上发布的内容完全移花接木，p1是宁艺卓回复的博主，博主头像没有红色字体只是综艺截图，p2是一个只有20几条微博的用户，两条发在一起引导大家认为宁艺卓回复的用户是带有红色字体的头像。
3️⃣早在去年柳智敏分享家庭生活的时候，宁艺卓粉丝就对她的家人进行了非常严重恶意的攻击，以及在前几天再次造谣了柳智敏父亲的身份和家庭背景等等。
（第三条不做配图，所用言语可恶可恨至极，柳吧不忍这种图再次传播对柳智敏产生再次伤害。）

微博事微博毕，这个事情发生之后我们也只是在x上更新我们的新应援，根本没想搭理你们。不是你们在这里想误导大众我们根本不会用这个账号发这些东西。打信息差打上瘾了？

不让你小心思得逞就着急了是不🥹

[WxySwaggyK @WxySwaggyK]

230623
#aespa #에스파
#Karina #카리나 #劉知珉 #カリナ #柳智敏

[ꨄ︎ @itgirIshit]

her bar forgot that this is not weibo. there's no china studio team to navigate, delete, suspend and control narratives to manipulate everyone and their mama. fabricating stuff won't work on here. they brought this issue here, giving kbar no choice but to respond with a bomb 😭

[Karina♡ @ujiminphoria]

MYGOD KARINA IS SO FINE

[KARINA Charts @karinachartss]

It is also important to recognize that Chinese fan culture and international fan culture are very different. Regardless of whether people agree or disagree with what happened, we strongly oppose bringing this issue into the international community and allowing it to escalate even further. We do not want to see this situation continue to grow beyond where it already has.

At the same time, please do not assume that Karina is only being defended by her Chinese fans. Many international fans are also aware of what has been happening on Weibo and share the same concerns.

What is said on Weibo should not be brought onto other platforms to target Karina or to continue fanwars. Doing so only creates a more negative environment, not only for both fandoms but ultimately for Ningning and Karina themselves. We hope everyone will refrain from escalating this situation any further and allow it to end here.

[KARINA Charts @karinachartss]

Lastly, we would like to clarify why Karina's fans are upset. (The primary reaction has come from Chinese fans, although many international fans have also expressed disappointment. Until this issue was brought onto the international side.) However, it had not escalated to this extent.

1. Ningning has every right to defend herself and her mother. No one is criticizing her for doing so. The concern stems from the wording of her post, specifically the phrase "...been subjecting my FANS and family to verbal abuse." Many fans interpreted this as defending or speaking on behalf of her fanbase as a whole. Given that some of those fans have, for years, spread body-shaming, sexualized insults, malicious rumors, and attacks targeting Karina and her family, this wording has understandably disappointed people.

2. One of the Weibo posts Ningning replied to included screenshots of posts in which Karina was body-shamed, sexualized, and her family's personal information was targeted. The original poster had reproduced those posts to illustrate the abuse Karina had been subjected to. As a result, some fans found Ningning's decision to reply to that post disappointing because of the context surrounding it, not simply because she chose to defend herself.

To be clear, this is not about denying Ningning the right to speak up for herself or her family. Rather, it is about why some fans reacted negatively to the specific wording of her statement and the context of the posts she responded to. Understanding that context is essential to understanding why this situation has become so controversial.

Rather than putting Karina's Chinese and international fans in a negative light or escalate this situation even further, we urge everyone to remember that SM Entertainment has already taken legal action against malicious posts and harassment. Fanwars often escalate to the point where people on both sides engage in unacceptable behavior. While no harassment should ever be excused, it is neither fair nor constructive to place the entire responsibility on only one side while overlooking the actions of the other. There is no benefit in prolonging fanwars or creating more conflict.

Please stop bringing unnecessary hostility to both Twitter and Weibo. Spreading misinformation and provoking other fandoms only harms everyone involved. It's time to let this end instead of making the situation worse. @NingNing_Bar.

[Joie @ediwtbh]

@Anya_0304_ Her bar even replied“So what if the original picture used by the person Ningning responded to is different”. Just admitted that her bar was spreading false rumors.🥲

[Joie @ediwtbh]

@NingNing_Bar “So what if the original picture used by the person Ningning responded to is different”. You’ve also admitted that you were spreading false rumors🙄

[Karina♡ @ujiminphoria]

OMFG KARINA’S MAKE UP?? SHE’S SO PRETTY

[순간의 카리나 @karinaofmoment]

예쁘다💙

[sytmr ꨄ︎ @sammybluu411]

Okay, let's do this, shall we. I will do it nice and clean so hopefully yall will have enough IQ to process the whole thing. Doing this because yall dumbfck are trying to twist the narrative and the main topic of why the whole incident is backfired ningning girly badly not just inlt side but also CN side. And somehow a lot of yall assumed we are "mad" because nn wants to protect her family, which WE DON'T.
- First of all, let's talk about your narrative "The lies came out of your own fave mouth". Before we get to the point, let's me show everyone the glimpse how C-nms (with NN's CN team helps) has been doing for couple months lately, include of spreading groundless rumors/defamations about Karina's family relationship and trying to link her and her family to anti-CN political stance (pic 1+2). Everyone and their mamas already knew Karina's father is a former marine which she mentioned multi times before the show that you use for your post honey. FYI, 99% of Kr men have to go through military service once in their lifetime because South Korea has a Mandatory Military Service System. Whether a kr family has a military background or not, its unnecessary to debate. This is THE TRUE, what c-nms and nn's cn team has been spreading about Karina's father and her family political stance is THE LIES.
- As some of you already known or may not know, the wb post that nn replied and used for her "call out" contained Karina's family doxxed WHICH HAD BEEN DONE BY NN's CN FANS. Karina had NEVER EVER mentioned her family members private info, even her older sister dog's name, because she considers it as a part of her family that she always wants to protect. So which one of these came from my fav mouth??
Oh, btw, nn's mother pic was no need to be doxxed as nms was crying about. nn herself joined a lot of kid talent shows back in cn since she was a kid, her family including her mother already being public on tv show interviews, its just a matter of time for them to dig it up, easily.
NOW FOR THE MOST IMPORTANT PART, I'm gonna explain why Karina's fans furious about this incident. The timeline of what had happened (pic 3).
If you use wb or if you not, yes, fanwars happen everyday in nasty way. Karina and nn's cn fans have been fought for months now. So, the hidden rule on CN side is, as a celeb/idol, you shouldn't and not allowed to involve yourself in fanwar.
The thing happened ytd was NN tried to protect her family by replying under an anti's post and tagged them publicly on her official wb acc. The post has a pic that included screenshots of Karina being sexualized, having her family doxxed. The OP had simply copy-pasted the exact insults originally directed at Karina and replaced her name with ningning. Instead of being smart and beloved maknae by choosing better way to avoid the damage could be done to her groupmate, she chose to throw Karina under the bus, open up a gate for her fans and Karina's antis to jump in and drag her sister😔.
The funny part is she was active on wb since forever, lurking on that app years after years yet, she knew and aware of what her CN fans (supporting by her CN's team) has been doing for months to her so called SISTER yet in the statement that she put up on her wb, she still defending her CN's fans by saying them has been verbal attacks (she even mentioned her fans before her family, the priority is there ig). This is actually the first time i've seen an idol sided and defended their CN akgaes who were harassing and trying to make her teammate get canceled in her homeland for years (pic 4 +5).
Things got people attention fast and her cn's team start buying hotsearchs on wb left and right. They really think they can get pity from public and cnetz but sadly nn's action which throw Karina under the bus and damage her teammate image by insert herself in fanwar is the thing cnetz hate the most so its backfired her and her cn team. Did you know kpop cn fans in general are start questioning aespa's relationship, their bond and support the disbandment because of this lmao.
On the other hand, Karina Bar's post that tagged SM and aespa's account asking them take responsibility and protect Karina and her family due to the huge amount of defamations for months starting blowing up, reached 100k likes on wb in just couple hours. They made SM's official wb acc have to come out with an announcement used vague words, seemingly intended to de-escalate the situation caused by Karina's CN fans after everything not going in the direction that they want (pic 6)
There are way more teas left but i wanna keep it for myself first, maybe i will share more if these stupid nms piss me off later. BYEEEEE

[Meow @0411_meowfist]

230623 🐈‍⬛

#카리나 #KARINA
#에스파 #aespa

[KARINA Charts @karinachartss]

Hi @NingNing_Bar. We would like to clarify several points, as important context has been omitted and inaccurate information has been circulated.

First, the post Ningning replied to did not contain the statement, "She has failed in teaching her daughter..." The image currently being shared with that caption is not from the original Weibo post. It is an edited version that appeared later. Therefore, presenting it as if it were part of the original post is factually incorrect and misrepresents what Ningning actually replied to.

Second, the original Weibo post contained screenshots documenting the abuse Karina had been subjected to, including body-shaming, sexualization, and rumors involving her family. So please do not crop that part out, it is important to accurately represent the content of the original post instead of replacing it with edited material.

We also want to clarify that the family photos used in the original screenshots were not photoshopped or fabricated. They were screenshots taken from a Chinese television program. The only alteration made on our side was censoring the individuals' faces out of respect for their privacy. Their faces were blurred solely to avoid exposing family members any further, not to manipulate the evidence.

We do not support harassment, doxxing, or attacks against any artist or their family. That principle applies equally to everyone. However, discussions should be based on complete and authentic evidence. Cropping out key context or substituting original screenshots with edited ones only creates confusion and makes it harder for people to understand what actually happened.

If the objective is to inform the public rather than shape a narrative, then the full, original screenshots should be presented. Context matters, and so does the accuracy of the evidence being shared.

[78o @91wu8rvd]

이거ㅈㅉ레전드야

[KARINA GLOBAL UNION @KRNGlobalUnion]

Hi @NingNing_Bar , it has come to our attention that the image has been edited to include the text stating, “she has failed in teaching…”. This text was not present in the original post.

While we do not support any actions that could cause harm or target anyone’s family, we also kindly ask that edited images not be circulated in ways that alter the original content or context. Doing so may mislead others, contribute to the spread of misinformation, and unintentionally cause harm to innocent parties.

We appreciate your understanding and cooperation. Thank you.

[ChinaKarinaBar @ChinaKarinaBar]

𝑊𝑎𝑡𝑒𝑟 𝐵𝑜𝑚𝑏 𝑤𝑖𝑡ℎ 𝐾𝑎𝑟𝑖𝑛𝑎

𝙋𝙖𝙧𝙩 3-4 【여성 아티스트 서포트 최초 진행】

KINTEX역 역사 내 기둥형 5연속 스크린 월간 전체 게재
기간: 7.23 ~ 8.22

KINTEX역 3·4번 통로 양측 롱스크린 월간 전체 게재
기간: 7.23 ~ 8.22

#Karina #카리나 #유지민 #カリナ #aespa

[ChinaKarinaBar @ChinaKarinaBar]

@NingNing_Bar自己给自己爱豆母亲照片p上的文案可还行？

[ChinaKarinaBar @ChinaKarinaBar]

@NingNing_Bar 怎么不敢发这条回复微博的完整截图 是不是害怕别人看到她回复的这条微博第一张图就是对柳智敏的羞辱和对她家人的造谣？这样连带家人的造谣和辱骂你们持续了三年多了 还要人怎么忍？

[Joie @ediwtbh]

@NingNing_Bar As the Chinese bar for Ningning, you’re actually using images photoshopped by her own fans to spread rumours about Karina ,you’re absolutely disgusting.

[Joie @ediwtbh]

Why doesn’t Ningning take these fans to court🤣

[Joie @ediwtbh]

The pictures posted by Ningning’s bar even include images photoshopped by her own Chinese fans 🤡