Perhaps I wasn't clear. I wasn't asking you to prove the Trinity contradicts Scripture. I was asking why you believe Sola Scriptura would require rejecting it or the other doctrines you listed.
As for resolving disagreements, Scripture provides examples of Church authority and dispute resolution. Matthew 18 describes involving others and eventually the Church, while Acts 15 shows apostles and elders deliberating over doctrinal disputes. Neither establishes universal papal jurisdiction.
And not every difference in interpretation becomes a Church-dividing dispute.
Having a centralized authority doesn't eliminate disagreements either. Consider the SSPX, sedevacantists, or Catholics who dispute Vatican II. Some remain within Catholic communion, while others have separated.
I recognize that the Church has authority to resolve disputes. What I question is your assumption that this necessarily requires an infallible authority centered in Rome. That's the claim you still need to demonstrate.
Please explain how any of those examples contradict Scripture or would fail when tested against it.
I've never claimed that anything not explicitly written in the Bible must be rejected. Sola Scriptura doesn't mean rejecting tradition, doctrine, councils, or Church authority. It means Scripture is the final infallible standard against which they are tested.
The Trinity, Christ's two natures, and His two wills are theological formulations grounded in Scripture. Christmas and Easter celebrate biblical events. None requires rejecting Scripture as the final authority.
And yes, Paul commanded Christians to preserve apostolic oral traditions (2 Thessalonians 2:15). The question is how we verify that a tradition taught centuries later genuinely came from the apostles.
You keep treating Sola Scriptura as though it means Scripture is our only authority. That's not what I've argued. Recognizing Church authority doesn't mean accepting that Rome alone possesses infallible authority.
Acts 17:11 commends the Bereans for testing even Paul's preaching against Scripture. Paul tells us to test all things (1 Thessalonians 5:21), and John tells us to test the spirits (1 John 4:1).
So what's wrong with testing Church teachings, and what standard should we use?
I've never rejected Church authority. I believe it must be tested against Scripture. Sola Scriptura may have been formally articulated during the Reformation, but testing teachings against Scripture is clearly apostolic.
The question isn't whether the Church has authority, but whether that authority is beyond correction by Scripture.
Interesting. Even Grok recognized that I repeatedly affirmed the Real Presence and that you kept arguing against a memorialist position I never held. It called that a strawman.
I'll concede Ignatius supports early Eucharistic realism, which I've never denied. But his writings don't establish transubstantiation or universal papal jurisdiction.
You still haven't demonstrated Rome's exclusive authority without assuming it first.
Ironically, Grok seems more willing to acknowledge what I've actually said than you have been. ๐
@HabitualLinest@Clintonshaw88 Of course someone who accepts Rome's authority would say that. I believe I should agree with Jesus and Scripture first. All other authorities, including churches and their leaders, should be tested against God's Word.
Another AI accusation, followed by personal insults. I used AI to highlight my previous responses because you falsely accused me of "avoiding the elephant in the room" when I'd already addressed the Real Presence multiple times. The screenshots were of our actual conversation.
Now you've moved from the Eucharist to historical continuity and my supposed lack of an epistemic foundation, complete with a Build-A-Bear insult.
I grew up Catholic, was confirmed in the Church, and know its teachings. I simply don't accept that disagreement with Rome means disagreement with Christianity.
You can appeal to Church authority all you want, but repeating that Rome is the final authority doesn't establish that claim for someone who questions it.
If you believe my arguments contradict one another, identify the actual contradiction. Otherwise, perhaps engage with what I've said rather than the Protestant caricature you've constructed. ๐
I haven't been avoiding the Eucharist. I've addressed it multiple times. I believe in the Real Presence of Christ in communion, as do many Lutherans, Anglicans, Methodists, and other Christians. I've never denied what Ignatius taught about the Eucharist.
What I dispute is your assumption that affirming the Real Presence necessarily requires accepting transubstantiation or Roman Catholic authority.
And we're discussing papal jurisdiction because you claimed history proves the Catholic Church under Rome is the one Church Christ established.
It makes me wonder whether you've actually read my responses or are arguing against the ghost of a position you've imagined I hold. ๐
The Eastern Orthodox, Oriental Orthodox, and Assyrian Church of the East also claim apostolic continuity, and none is under papal jurisdiction. They aren't simply different rites within your communion.
Ignatius's use of "Catholic Church" establishes that the term was used in the early second century. It doesn't, by itself, establish that every apostolic church must be subject to the universal jurisdiction of the bishop of Rome.
Ignatius is an important witness to the early Church, but his use of "Catholic Church" refers to the universal Church, not necessarily the later claims of Roman papal supremacy.
And Rome isn't the only ancient Church claiming apostolic continuity. The Eastern Orthodox, Oriental Orthodox, and Church of the East also trace their origins to the apostles and claim to preserve the authentic apostolic faith.
What's interesting historically is how disputes over authority, doctrine, and attempts to enforce unity repeatedly contributed to divisions within Christianity. The EastโWest Schism is a particularly important example involving Rome's expanding jurisdictional claims.
So citing Ignatius and saying "history proves Rome is the one true Church" skips over nearly 2,000 years of contested history. Apostolic origins don't automatically establish universal papal jurisdiction.
The exact phrase โpersonal relationship with Godโ isn't in Scripture, but the concept certainly is. Jesus says His sheep hear His voice and He knows them (John 10:27). He calls His disciples friends (John 15:15), and Paul speaks of God as our Father (Romans 8:15).
Interestingly, CCC 2558 describes prayer as a โvital and personal relationship with the living and true God.โ
So apparently this โfruity languageโ is Catholic language too. Are we rejecting biblical concepts simply because the exact modern phrasing isn't in Scripture?
You're explaining Christianity through the theological lens of the Catholic Church. That's an important distinction. Other Christians affirm Christ's sacrifice, His Real Presence in communion, and our participation in Him without accepting every aspect of Catholic Eucharistic theology. Disagreement with Rome's explanation isn't disagreement with Christianity or Christ's sacrifice.
Did I say "symbolizes" or "represents," or did I say I believe in the Real Presence?
You're arguing against a position I haven't taken. Catholics aren't the only Christians who affirm Christ's Real Presence in communion. Lutherans, Anglicans, Methodists, and others affirm it, though they understand it differently. Even the Eastern Orthodox affirm Christ's true body and blood without requiring the Roman Catholic explanation of transubstantiation.
Repeating the word "is" doesn't establish transubstantiation. It establishes what Jesus said. The disagreement isn't whether Christ is truly present, but whether His words require accepting a particular theological explanation of how He is present.
Then I think we're largely in agreement. Recognizing Hanukkah's historical and religious significance can enrich our understanding of Christ without requiring Christians to observe it as an obligation.
And while Catholics preserve that history in their canon, Protestants can recognize the same history without considering Maccabees inspired Scripture. After all, John 10:22โ23 explicitly records the Feast of Dedication during Jesus' ministry.
I appreciate you recognizing that distinction. It's refreshing to find some common ground in this discussion.
"This is my body" establishes Christ's words, not necessarily the medieval philosophical explanation of transubstantiation.
Christians affirmed the Real Presence centuries before transubstantiation was formally adopted at Lateran IV in 1215 and reaffirmed at Trent in 1551. Protestants still affirm the Real Presence without accepting transubstantiation.
And here's a question: If Jesus said "Drink ye all of it" (Matthew 26:27), and Paul describes eating the bread AND drinking the cup (1 Corinthians 11:26), why did the Catholic Church restrict the chalice to clergy for centuries?
I understand the Catholic doctrine of concomitance, but where does Scripture authorize withholding the cup from the laity?
You're actually the first person in this discussion to acknowledge that Catholics still celebrate something connected to Hanukkah, even if through its fulfillment in Christ. Others have simply dismissed it as belonging to the Old Covenant.
I appreciate that distinction. It also raises an interesting question: if Christians can recognize and celebrate the fulfillment of an Old Covenant festival in Christ, why would recognizing the historical and religious significance of Hanukkah itself be objectionable?
You're explaining Catholic Eucharistic theology, but you're assuming that anyone who disagrees with it cannot participate in Christ's sacrifice.
I don't deny Christ's presence in communion. Neither do many Lutherans, Anglicans, or Methodists. Paul speaks of participation in Christ's body and blood in 1 Corinthians 10:16. Believing that doesn't require accepting transubstantiation.
Yes, the Israelites ate the Passover lamb, but Exodus 12 also identifies the blood as the sign protecting them from judgment. And Hebrews 10:10โ14 emphasizes that Christ's sacrifice was offered once for all.
As for apostolic succession, you're assuming that valid communion requires the particular form of episcopal succession recognized by Rome. Where does Scripture establish that requirement?
You keep arguing against a Protestant belief that communion is nothing more than crackers and grape juice. That's not what I believe, and it isn't what millions of other Protestants believe either.