I have been reflecting on everything that has happened, and I believe most of you are in the wrong.
It was also my wishful thinking that Heeseung was forced out and that we could fight to bring him back, but I’m too grown to let my wishful thinking deceive me from seeing reality.
And the reality is that:
1. We never truly know any idols or who they really are as a person behind the camera, no matter how long or how much we have followed and supported them.
2. A contract is legally binding for both parties, which means neither can simply end the contract early unless it’s a mutual agreement or the other party breaches the contract.
There is no proof to support the latter. If Heeseung had breached the contract, we would know about it either through a scandal or a court case proving that he did. None of that is the case, which leaves only one option:
He chose to leave. I know that's a hard pill to swallow.
But even if Belift gave him an ultimatum, which deserves its own criticism. It doesn’t change the fact that, legally, he had a choice and didn’t have to leave ENHYPEN.
And that changes everything and leads to my decision to boycott Heeseung’s solo career.
Not because he wants to release solo music. An artist should never be punished for wanting to release music. That’s the most normal desire for an artist.
I will boycott Heeseung because he was willing to agree to a decision that has, by far, the most harmful consequences for the other six members since ENHYPEN exists.
Not only did he betray his members, but his decision also forced them to relearn the formations of the choreographies and the line distributions of EVERY song, which is an insane amount of work.
But the worst thing of all is that he left a few months before contract renewal, and by doing so, he risked and potentially ruined the chance for ALL of the other members to negotiate better opportunities, better salaries, and overall better conditions for their new contracts.
The right decision would have been to stay with ENHYPEN until the contract renewal phase. That way, they ALL would have had the upper hand in negotiations and could have easily demanded better terms, considering how successful ENHYPEN is.
But by leaving, he devalued ENHYPEN’s brand and put the members in a much worse position—all because he couldn’t wait a few more months before releasing his solo work? That’s unreasonable and unethical. How do you expect me to support something like that as a fan of ENHYPEN?
What we, as a fandom, have to do right now is:
1. Show unwavering support to ENHYPEN—not just because they were betrayed and need support right now, but also to ensure that their brand value does not decline, so they can have the upper hand in negotiations and decide for themselves what they want.
2. Boycott Heeseung’s solo career—not just because the decision is unethical, but also to show BELIFT that our support for ENHYPEN remains with ENHYPEN, and that they cannot just tear apart six years of hard work from ENHYPEN and ENGENE for the sake of more profit. If you support Heeseung’s solo career, all you will do is prove to BELIFT that it was the right call to break apart a perfect group because ENGENE will support them anyway. That would make ENHYPENS future even more unstable.
If we get new information, I might change my views. As of now, this is my stance on the matter.