The recent proposal from the Trump Admin to sell federal public lands highlights a potential risk of BAAJA. It might facilitate sale of federal public lands. 1/x
The APA failure to inform plus the FLPMA requirement for information for the decision gives you a legal violation besides NEPA and the land sale easily meets irreparable harm. 10/x
@BenSchifman That may well be true in many cases. But there may well be situations where no other substantive law is on point or available. Having this as a back up would be helpful.
There’s a lot of controversy over the remedies section of the permitting reform bill. Some Dem senators are calling for exempting tribes from the restrictions on vacatur for NHPA claims. And the remedy restrictions are one of the most controversial parts of the bill. 1/9
Any of these approaches might help facilitate passage of the bill overall, without unduly compromising the policy goals of the drafters. More details at this blog post.
https://t.co/akH0DSbXiF
9/9
A narrower approach is to only allow vacatur after a remand order if there is irreparable harm as well as a continued NEPA violation. Or only if there is bad faith agency noncompliance. 8/9