How much more of a revolutionary cosplayer do you have to be to forcefully occupy a building, create an artificial "blockade" against yourself, and then demand "humanitarian aid" to be allowed in after a mere 12 hours because you're concerned about starving and dehydrating "to death". The attempt to recreate a Gaza-lite environment on a college campus is demonstrative of the strange revolutionary fetishization of Gaza's horrendous suffering and the Palestinian issue by some of the protesting students. The unfolding debacle is the result of the SJPs deliberate disregard for effective messaging and saying they don't want to make their rhetoric palatable. Turning people against the just and urgent Palestinian aspirations for freedom and statehood is precisely what many pro-Palestine activists are currently doing, instead of seizing on a historical, once in a lifetime opportunity to reach mass audiences with favorable messaging and build broad alliances to achieve justice and lasting peace. Truly shameful squandering of public empathy for the Palestinian people.
@toothblush I don't think I've ever advocated for violence of any level. You're right though, it's wrong to have done even a fraction of the atrocities they've committed. However, the normalization of anti-Semitic behavior is also disgusting. Not all Jews hold the same views as their leaders
This fear of persecution that Palestinian Arabs have felt for so long is now felt by the Jews, as their entire race is being collectively punished for the wrongdoings of a single regime. This anti-Semitism must stop, for both the sake of the movement and for the safety (11/12)
It is undeniable that Palestinians are justified in their anger, as they have been repressed and persecuted for far too long. However, their anger should be directed toward Netanyahu and his abhorrent, racist policies rather than fighting to abolish Israel as a state. (10/12)
things that Palestinians are so desperately fighting against - a safe place to live. Pro-Palestinian advocates should not be rallying together to fight Israel but to shame Netanyahu and his disgusting and horrifying policies that have led Israel down the path it is on today. 9/12
it should never be at the expense of another. "From the river to the sea" is a phrase that has been used since the start of this tragedy, and I cannot believe that it has garnered such mainstream usage. To advocate for the wiping out of Israel is to advocate for the same (8/12)
just be anti-Semitic, and are hiding behind the guise of a freedom-fighter, while others may just be misinformed. This leads me to what I think is the biggest issue that so many protestors get wrong. The difference between Netanyahu's policies and the state of Israel. (6/12)
I believe that the crux of the issue is that Netanyahu's policies and Israel's identity have been intertwined and used interchangeably when they are so different in so many ways. I want to believe that these protestors understand that while they deserve a state of their own, 7/12
Some argue that Hamas is simply retaliating in the same way that they have been treated by Israel. However, the people that Hamas are hurting are not the same people that have repressed and attacked them. How is collective punishment justified in any way? Some may (5/12)
I don't know if this is a hot take, and I doubt that many people are going to see this, but I feel like I want to get this off my chest. I genuinely feel like a lot of the pro-Palestine protests around the country have gotten out of hand. (1/12)
This, combined with some advocates' open embrace of Hamas and their atrocities is extremely concerning. Seeing Hamas as a freedom-fighter is so extraordinarily dense that I can't wrap my head around it. When is it ever justified to kill innocent women and children? (4/12)
Protests like this are not the way to generate positive media attention towards your cause. Just over the past few days, I've seen Palestinians raise their voice against some of the phrases that have been chanted at these rallies, and they truly, truly are horrific. (3/12)
I absolutely do not deny the fact that Palestinians have been treated too horribly for far too long and that they absolutely should not be denied their own state, but I also believe that these protestors are genuinely at the point where they are hurting their own cause. (2/12)