If his family cared about his wellbeing more than how it affected them, then they would never have asked for such a sacrifice. Demanding someone live on in suffering in order to spare you from grief isn't an act of love, it's the ultimate act of exploitation. The message that sends is that the person whom you claim to love is only valuable as a means to your end, their own welfare isn't valuable in and of itself. The patient himself could have chosen to stay alive to participate in experimental treatments, but that should have been one choice available to him, rather than an obligation. I think that if his family accepted his choice (I don't think there's enough information to go on with regards to how his family responded), then there's no greater act of love and care than that.
People survive jumps from high places all the time and surviving such an attempt is virtually guaranteed to result in lifelong, serious disability. Bridges in the UK have nanny state barriers on them to prevent jumpers and gun ownership is illegal. I understand your position as a psychiatrist that you are legally obligated to stop suicide, and I appreciate the fact that you support the right to commit suicide. But it is not at all easy to have a successfully completed suicide attempt, and there are a great many people who are still alive not because they're ambivalent about whether they want to live or die, but because the stakes of failing are too high that their current circumstances don't warrant the risk of being irrevocably made many times worse.
Demanding other people live as slaves to your emotional wellbeing is the most selfish thing that you can expect, unless they've forced you to be dependent on their continued existence. Because those who don't want to die are in the majority, it's basically a case of might makes right.
Based on the current state of affairs, there is no medical treatment available that could have been tried. So for the immediate future, there isn't any grounds for hope of improvement, and that would have been the basis on which assisted dying would have been approved. It's cruel to force someone to suffer unbearably for the indefinite future on the basis of the off chance that a future treatment could be developed. That isn't respecting the patient, nor valuing their welfare. That's about enforcing an ideology and treating the patient and their welfare as collateral damage.
You're conflating not giving false hope with declaring that there is no hope. If the doctor says that there is no treatment that he can prescribe right now, then that's not declaring the situation to be permanently hopeless. The doctor can even add the "but let's keep trying" part as you suggested, without necessarily having to take away the patient's option of assisted dying. It would be unethical for the doctor to declare that the patient must continue suffering on the basis that it isn't possible to rule out future treatments being developed which might help. If the doctor had declared that the patient's condition will never improve and there will never be any effective treatments, so they might as well choose assisted dying, then I can see how your point would stand. But giving the patient the autonomy to make a choice based on what is currently known is not an act of taking away hope.
There's a world of difference between declaring someone's situation hopeless and refraining from giving them false hope. It would be wrong to declare someone's situation hopeless unless it's medically certain that their condition will never be effectively treated. However, it's also unethical to give people false hope, and people should be allowed to make choices based on what is known at the present time, rather than some hypothetical future change of circumstances that may never materialise. Is there any evidence that the man's doctors explicitly declared his condition to be hopeless?
The survival instinct doesn't have a teleological function. Humans are capable of higher order thought processes. We don't have to be slaves to our animal instincts. He made a decision based on the best information that was available at the time, which was that there was no foreseeable prospect of improvement, and that death would stop the suffering.
@BabaMc777@PaulMinotMD People who have the same rational self interests that I have as feeling, harmable beings, but without as evolved a philosophical outlook on life as mine.
I understand the fact that I was born into a world in which everyone is intertwined with each other, but I had no choice in that matter and have never forced anyone to be dependent on my existence. There's no contract that I signed and therefore no ethical basis for binding me to the terms of some obligation that I had no chance to refuse.
It may never have improved, and he was the one who had to suffer, so it should have been only his choice to decide whether the continued suffering was worth the prospect of future improvement. The man himself is no longer experiencing any sense of tragedy, or anything else. There's nothing to stop others from finding it tragic, but they weren't the ones who were having to suffer through his life, so their feelings aren't the point.
If they told you that they wished that they had died, then that wouldn't be a good strategy for getting out of the psychiatric ward as quickly as possible, which is probably what most of them wanted. But all of those people also would have just had a very close brush with their primal survival instinct and would be experiencing an intense sense of relief, because their psychology is evolved to resist death at all costs and you can't just think your way out of that reaction.
The Subway near where I live, where I've been going for 5 years since I moved, has always employed a rota of exclusively south Asian (probably Indian) employees. There is high turnover, but the new employees that come into replace the ones that have left are always South Asian. I don't live in an area that has a particularly high concentration of South Asians.
The opt out clause seems like a reasonable safeguard that could be introduced. That should be introduced and people who do consent to MAiD should not have to contend with being told that they need to be protected from themselves or that can't be allowed autonomy over their own body because it would reflect badly on the inequality and injustice in society.
How can you be indifferent to suffering? We have limited information to go on regarding what he tried. But people with all sorts of different medical conditions can have varying different degrees of severity, and what works for some may not work for all. Ultimately he should have been entitled to decide for himself based on the best information available.
I'm not against allowing criminals to have the right to die, but they shouldn't have it before non criminals. And I'd still argue that convicted criminals should have to serve a minimum portion of their sentence before being eligible for suicide, in order to maintain the deterrence effect. In that context, a partial but not absolute obligation to suffer would make some sense. But I don't think that the option should be permanently taken away from anyone, just that there are arguments to justify why it should be temporarily suspended in some cases if people have brought obligations on themselves, or if society has a legitimate interest in deterring certain behaviours.
Very much in support of people not being compelled to suffer, which should be at least observed as a negative liberty right not to be forced to live. I don't have anything in principle against the "right to try", but the issue with that is that governments probably can't afford to just give out any unproven experimental treatment for free, due to the fact that there is a finite amount of funds available. I don't think that a person's negative liberty to decide not to continue struggling should have to be coupled with the positive duty for the government to summon infinite amounts of resources to pay for every unproven treatment that is being trialled.
Not arguing against the need for more support and research. But that isn't an overnight solution for people suffering right now. There's no amount of financial support which would have made that man's life anything other than hellish until a cure is found. And people claim to be taking the suffering seriously, which means that if it had been up to them, they'd have condemned him to continue suffering unbearable for the foreseeable future, just for the sake of making some kind of moral or philosophical statement that suicide is never the right answer. That's appalling.
It's not compassion to force people to live who are suffering, and there's nothing morally enlightened about the insistence that someone else continue to suffer. If the government was allowing people to freely access whatever they needed to endure as painless and reliable a death as possible, then that would be one thing. But if you distrust the government's motives in facilitating assisted dying, it makes no sense to place unlimited trust in their motives regarding suicide prevention. Not unless that argument is a smokescreen for an entirely different motivation, such as religious beliefs.