So the whole of academia is just ‘dogma’ instantly when it digresses from your traditionalist-narrative? Read aforementioned replies. Where treaty of Ḥasan is mentioned? He did treaty after betrayal from ʿUbāid Ullah bin ʿAbbās and Muʿāwiya overpowered him. Ḥasan simply sought to prevent the Kufan Shīʿa from becoming sacrificial pawns in a confrontation with Muʿāwiya.
@sdriankhmeinist Ahmad you need to read more actually.
Framing a deliberate methodology as "dereliction" ignores the historical reality. Scholarship shows the Imams' non-participation in turbulent revolts was a conscious, strategic choice rather than a mistake.
Then your statement invalidates the infallibility of Riḍā’s progeny as whole including Muḥammad al-Taqī the Jawād. Let move this the other way around, because why stop at Riḍā? Jaʿfar al-Ṣādiq and Bāqir were quietists too.
“The accepted view among scholars is that Jaʿfar al-Ṣādiq appears to have maintained the politically quietist stance of his father, Imām Muḥammad al-Bāqir”.
Amikam Elad.
All of these Anime Dawah girls rising to fame
all of them are debating kafir men .
all calling themselves salafi
3 of them had connection with the Maleek guy
none of them have their real names .
it is a MOSSAD PSY-OP