@bartlebytaco I’d swap the white album with Rubber Soul, mostly out of personal preference and that bloat you mentioned with the former. No real disagreement otherwise.
@pourfairelevide So phenomenal. We read Rubin “Hurricane” Carter’s autobiography last semester in a class on literature of incarceration. Dylan’s song featured prominently in our discussion too.
@AmericanGwyn I know that your problem is more with this idea of the partisan within literature. If we work with Jameson’s definition though, I think it’s more fair to cast doubt on the idea of an apolitical text. Great writers help us access the material forces that drive our world, right?
@AmericanGwyn I don’t want to simply restate what I said in another thread, but if you work with Jameson’s definition of the political perspective from The Political Unconscious, I think this becomes less of a problem. Jameson, I think, means something closer to “material struggle.”
@bernardtjoy Absolutely understood. Many of my mentors thus far have been invested in Marxist dialectics (or historicism otherwise) and/or ecocriticism, so that’s much of what I know. Definitely will keep this in mind as I move forward. Thank you for the time and replies!
@bernardtjoy Haha I’ll defer to you and others on that for now as I’m not quite experienced enough to properly answer. Of course my snap answer is no, there is much more to access. Is your experience that political criticism receives too much airtime compared to other perspectives?
@bernardtjoy That’s fair and I do think many great writers were apolitical in that (as Aaron said) they seemed to have little use for partisan politics or participation. My only point is that we can (and maybe should) access the politics of their work within academia regardless of that fact.
@bernardtjoy Right, fair enough. More than anything, I’m just not convinced that reading for politics reduces a text in any meaningful way. Maybe that’s not exactly what you mean, though. At the least, I do agree that reading for political agreement or cohesion is a bad move.
@bernardtjoy Doing so allows us to historicize texts and see them along the political (not partisan) lines that drive and define our world. For Jameson, everything is politics, but not quite in the way you try to frame it here.
@bernardtjoy Respectfully, my perspective here is very much in line with Fredric Jameson’s in The Political Unconscious. The political perspective is the horizon of all meaning (to use Jameson’s words) and informed readers can access it irrespective of an author’s own political leanings.