@BitcoinNewsCom@Trezor Never holding the address is the only data protection that doesn't depend on someone else's security team. Much of what's called compliance is really building a list, and every list eventually has more than one owner. Which fields could any service stop collecting tomorrow?
@PiusSprenger It didn't go anywhere, it got quiet. Someone settling a fare or a week's groceries in sats across a table doesn't post a chart. The timeline rewards the asset story because it can be screenshotted; the cash story only shows up when you're the one holding the cash.
Twelve women, a living room in Kasarani, Sunday after church. 1,000 shillings each on the table. One walks home with 12,000. Next month, the next name on the list.
No contract, no interest. The enforcement is that everyone knows where you live.
That's the part a sats version has to replace. Building Chama we shipped the boring half first: the circle fills by the deadline or every share goes back, and nobody collects yet. Rotation is next, and the hard question isn't who gets paid. It's what happens when someone collects in round two and stops showing up.
Would you join one with people you've never sat in a room with?
Fedi has been working to make running Fedimint federations even more decentralised, private, and easy.
As a result, many federations are moving to this new setup in the coming weeks and months. This will require their users to migrate to new federations.
Please read this message to find out if this affects you and how to migrate.
@SwissHodler Worth adding that all three lines also describe a bitcoin balance on an exchange. The property that matters isn't bitcoin vs francs, it's whether you hold a key or a claim. A lot of people switched currencies and kept the IOU.
The step people skip is 1, and not because they disagree with it. Most coins sit on an exchange because that's also where people buy and sell, and leaving means finding another way to trade. Self custody tends to stick once the on- and off-ramp doesn't require handing the coins back to a platform first.
Before our first on-chain trade touched mainnet, we tried to cheat our own escrow. It worked.
A seller could post a lock pointing at an address built from keys they picked, and the code accepted it, because nothing bound the lock to the keys agreed when the seat was taken.
The fix was boring: freeze the terms when the seat is taken (address, three keys, who funds, refund height), reject any lock that differs, and have the other side watch the chain instead of trusting the message.
The dangerous bugs are rarely in the signatures. They're in what the signatures are allowed to be about.
@SimplyBitcoin The stack only moves one way for most of us: fiat in, cold storage, never out. The interesting day is when the raise itself arrives in sats, or the grocer takes them. Then it stops being a quiet habit and starts being a local economy. That's the step I'd like to see more of.
So the question I'd put to anyone building here: what did you change to make the first message easier to send?
And if you've ever bought sats from a person rather than a platform, what got you to send yours?
The hardest part of buying bitcoin from a person isn't the escrow, the price, or the cash. It's the first message.
Most people would rather pay a platform's spread than open a chat with a stranger about money.
Platforms don't sell liquidity. They sell not having to talk to anyone.
Building Chama we kept bumping into this. A counterparty shown as a hex key is a stranger. The same person shown by name, with everyone in the trade room visible, is someone you can picture.
None of that is cryptography. All of it decides whether the first message gets sent.
@satsman Credit for the store closing the loop, most education skips that step. The map is what I'd like to understand: 27k pins is a lot, but the gap I keep hitting is between "a place exists somewhere" and "a place within walking distance". Real clusters, or thin outside a few cities?
When did someone last pay you in sats for real work or goods? Not a zap, not a tip, not a test payment between friends.
Asking because "circular economy" gets said a lot, and I want to know how much of it exists outside a few beach towns and meetups. "Never" is a useful answer too.
@V4BTC Rule 1 is the hard one in practice. Saving is a solo act; earning and spending need another person who will take sats, so it's a local problem more than a protocol one. The places where it works seem to have a few stubborn merchants and a regular meetup before they have any app.
@TheCryptoBlade The fee is the smaller problem. A balance you can't withdraw isn't bitcoin, it's an IOU that tracks the price, and it carries every risk a bank balance does. One question sorts any custody product: can I move it to a wallet I control today, without asking anyone?
Your reputation on a platform belongs to the platform.
Ten years of good reviews, gone the morning they close your account.
On Nostr the key is yours, and a rating is a note signed by the person who actually traded with you, not a row in someone's database.
Change apps, keep your name.
Trust should travel with the person, not the brand.
@satsman Agreed that understanding comes first. The part I keep seeing is the second step stalling: people understand sats well enough to hold them and still have nowhere nearby to earn or spend them. Does your education work include a place to actually use them afterwards?
@SimplyBitcoin The inflation lecture never landed for me either. What did was asking what happens if the bank decides next week that he can't withdraw it. That 3% is the rent he's paid for permission, and most people have never priced permission before.