@ClownWorld You leave poverty by generating wealth. You don't generate anything by just being handed money. Handed food for a week doesn't feed me for the month.
@IMPERATORAUS Had to quit the AT. Told a couple I was sad but God has His plans for me. Said I was only sad I never got to see a bear. Half-mile before my exit trail I got to see a bear cub. God answers even small little requests because He loves us.
Crime and Punishment isn't about a single murder, but the idea that can justify murdering millions.
Raskolnikov famously kills a predatory pawnbroker, reasoning that she won't be missed, and he can use her money for the greater good.
Strangely, however, he never uses her money. He instead buries it under a rock and forgets it.
What was his true motivation then?
Later on, you discover he's motivated by a much darker ideology, which he shares in an article titled "On Crime."
He argues there are only 2 types of people:
1. Ordinary people: who live by the status quo and obey the law
2. Extraordinary people: who have the strength to break the law
He concludes that extraordinary people SHOULD break the law to serve the greater good of humanity…
The problem of this ideology is it doesn't justify just one murder, but two, or three, or three thousand, etc. Raskolnikov proves this himself: after murdering the pawnbroker, he then murders her innocent sister, solely for self-preservation.
Ultimately, Dostoevsky warns that when man rejects objective morality, not only is murder justified, but moral relativism — taken at scale — can justify mass murder itself.
What is brilliant about Crime and Punishment is that the greatest damage to Raskolnikov is not the legal or social consequences that eventually catch up to him.
Instead, Raskolnikov's actions destroy him bit-by-bit from the inside. Where Raskolnikov thought that his own superiority would allow him to commit crimes with impunity, he finds that it is the personal cost that actually damages him.
Thus Dostoevsky makes a poignant argument that morality is objective. And if we live according to our own will, and to our own ambition, disaster is lurking...
---
Athenaeum Podcast Ep. 15:
Dostoevsky's Warning to the Modern World
w/ @pensandpoison
Reminds me of Jordan Peterson describing the animus of left wing revolutionary thought as "revenge against God for the crime of Being"
The spirit of the age truly is "If I have a creator, then he has to justify Himself to ME, not the other way around"