Hallie Stebbins

Editor for neuroscience & computer science books at Princeton University Press

[Pavan Sodhan @PSodhan]

Echoing @MelMitchell1 recommendation to buy @random_walker & @sayashk fantastic new book exploring how the emerging power of artificial intelligence is being overhyped by its proponents because they will profit from pushing it’s use, which I reviewed for @BooksinFive below!

1/5

[Princeton University Press @PrincetonUPress]

From @random_walker & @sayashk, AI Snake Oil gives you an essential understanding of how AI works and why it often doesn’t—and when you should suspect that companies are using #AI hype to sell AI snake oil.

Enter to win 1 of 10 free copies @goodreads:
https://t.co/u7LeKJSHGm

[Nicole C Rust, PhD @NicoleCRust]

A bright blue light on a distracting day ... The Cover reveal for Elusive Cures!!

(I love it).

https://t.co/9y9M8e5tMm

[Princeton University Press @PrincetonUPress]

From @random_walker & @sayashk, AI Snake Oil gives you an essential understanding of how AI works and why it often doesn’t—and when you should suspect that companies are using #AI hype to sell AI snake oil.

Enter to win 1 of 10 free copies @goodreads:
https://t.co/5B0BEfBx34

[Arvind Narayanan @random_walker]

📢 AI Snake Oil is out today! I have too many feelings because this book has been five years in the making. In 2019 I gave a talk on AI Snake Oil and tweeted out the slides. I had no idea my career was about to change. Within a couple of days I had 30 or 40 invites to write a book or an article. I said no to all of them because I felt I needed to do more research to be able to write a book. So when @sayashk joined my team I knew this was the topic we were going to work on. The book is based on our research on limits to prediction, the dangers of predictive decision making, the reproducibility crisis in machine learning based science, the limits of large language models, and the risks of social media algorithms.

The book is not an anti-technology screed. If our point was that all AI is useless, we wouldn’t need a book to say it. It’s precisely because of AI’s usefulness in many areas that overhyped claims and outright snake oil have been so successful in the market. It’s hard for people to tell these apart, and we hope our book can help. And while we think the tech industry should have much more accountability, the harms we describe are usually not solely due to tech, and much more often due to AI being an amplifier of existing problems in our society. A recurring pattern we point out in the book is that "broken AI is appealing to broken institutions" (Chapter 8).

Since our book talks about what AI can’t do, AI boosters often tell us it’s going to be outdated soon. If you think so, I’d love to have a friendly bet! Read the book and tell us what you think will be wrong in two years or five years. (You can start with the intro chapter, which is available online; the link is in my pinned tweet.) The reason we’re confident of our assessments is that they are not based on limitations of the technology. Instead, they are based on inherent limits to prediction grounded in our sociological analysis. (The book owes a huge debt to Princeton sociologist @msalganik; our collaboration with him informed and inspired the book.) We also talk a lot about what we shouldn’t use AI for, even if we can.

We’ve had many moments of hope and trepidation for the book as we worked on it over the years. We’re so grateful for the early interest the book has had, especially to the 40,000 people who subscribe to the AI Snake Oil newsletter, and the many podcasts that have had us on to talk about the book. We’ve had great reviews in The New Yorker, Publishers' Weekly (featured in the Top 10 science books for Fall 2024), and many other outlets. And we’ve had such a wonderful experience working with Princeton University Press. We’re also fortunate to have received incisive peer reviews from @MelMitchell1 , @mollycrockett , @chris_bail, and three anonymous reviewers. The book is so much better as a result.

What's in the book

Chapter 1: Introduction. We begin with a summary of our main arguments in the book. We discuss the definition of AI (and more importantly, why it is hard to come up with one), how AI is an umbrella term, what we mean by AI Snake Oil, and who the book is for.

The entire introduction is available online. See the link in my pinned tweet.

Chapter 2: How predictive AI goes wrong. Predictive AI is used to make predictions about people—will a defendant fail to show up for trial? Is a patient at high risk of negative health outcomes? Will a student drop out of college? These predictions are then used to make consequential decisions. Developers claim predictive AI is groundbreaking, but in reality it suffers from a number of shortcomings that are hard to fix.

Chapter 3: Can AI predict the future? Are the shortcomings of predictive AI inherent, or can they be resolved? In this chapter, we look at why predicting the future is hard — with or without AI. While we have made consistent progress in some domains such as weather prediction, we argue that this progress cannot translate to other settings, such as individuals' life outcomes, the success of cultural products like books and movies, or pandemics.

Chapter 4: The long road to generative AI. Recent advances in generative AI can seem sudden, but they build on a series of improvements over seven decades. In this chapter, we retrace the history of computing advances that led to generative AI.

Chapter 5: Is advanced AI an existential threat? Claims about AI wiping out humanity are common. Here, we critically evaluate claims about AI's existential risk and find several shortcomings and fallacies in popular discussion of x-risk. We discuss approaches to defending against AI risks that improve societal resilience regardless of the threat of advanced AI.

Chapter 6: Why can't AI fix social media? One area where AI is heavily used is content moderation on social media platforms. We discuss the current state of AI use on social media, and highlight seven reasons why improvements in AI alone are unlikely to solve platforms' content moderation woes.

Chapter 7: Why do myths about AI persist? Companies, researchers, and journalists all contribute to AI hype. We discuss how myths about AI are created and how they persist. In the process, we hope to give you the tools to read AI news with the appropriate skepticism and identify attempts to sell you snake oil.

Chapter 8: Where do we go from here? While the previous chapter focuses on the supply of snake oil, in the last chapter, we look at where the demand for AI snake oil comes from. We also look at the impact of AI on the future of work, the role and limitations of regulation, and conclude with vignettes of the many possible futures ahead of us. We have the agency to determine which path we end up on, and each of us can play a role.

-------

We hope you find the book useful and look forward to hearing what you think.

[Princeton University Press @PrincetonUPress]

🚨 Applications are now open for PUP’s Science Book Proposal Grants! 🚨

[Arvind Narayanan @random_walker]

Kirkus Reviews, which provides early book reviews to the publishing industry, has given AI Snake Oil a very positive "starred" review, which we're told is rare and kind of a big deal. Honored and grateful! https://t.co/ydFehQrTlI
Preorder: https://t.co/6CtMHrJXCx
w/ @sayashk

[Sayash Kapoor @sayashk]

I'm ecstatic to share that preorders are now open for the AI Snake Oil book! The book will be released on September 24, 2024.

@random_walker and I have been working on this for the past two years, and we can't wait to share it with the world.

Preorder: https://t.co/DUaiCFBx9L

[Princeton University Press @PrincetonUPress]

50% off books sitewide!! Sale starts now and runs through May 26th on print, audiobooks, and ebooks (some exclusions apply). Don't miss out on this chance to stock up and save for summer reading! https://t.co/LHHgU1eRnv #Sale #BookSale #AcademicTwitter

[Stephen Bush @stephenkb]

I think @PrincetonUPress are consistently the most interesting university press at the moment: my column this week is partly inspired by an excellent new set of essays, You Are Not Expected To Understand This: https://t.co/B1jq7BROCA

[Hallie Stebbins @halliestebbins]

Happy pub day to @thekibosch and “You Are Not Expected to Understand This”! It was an absolute joy to work with Torie and our group of outstanding authors. 26 inspired essays on 26 lines of code that changed the world – out now from @PrincetonUPress
https://t.co/qbiA4GhEiB

[Princeton University Press @PrincetonUPress]

Happy Pub Week to Patterns, Predictions, and Actions by Moritz Hardt & Benjamin Recht! An authoritative, up-to-date graduate textbook on #MachineLearning that highlights its historical context & societal impacts, it is out in hardcover & ebook. https://t.co/b2qZR7WAf0 @beenwrekt

[Princeton University Press @PrincetonUPress]

Our 50% off #PUPSummerSale has begun! Stock up for summer reading, holiday gifts, and more with code PUP22 at checkout. Worldwide sale with free shipping (some exclusions apply) now through June 28th (11:59 PM EST). https://t.co/G9JBksyWMI #SummerSale

[Hallie Stebbins @halliestebbins]

📖❤️

[Princeton University Press @PrincetonUPress]

Happy #ValentinesDay book lovers! Instead of flowers, we got you a sale! Get 75% off select books (US and Canada only) in our #PUPBookLoverSale now through Feb. 28. Fill those carts with great deals on great books and use code LOVE75 at checkout. https://t.co/ovhzx5NQul

[Hallie Stebbins @halliestebbins]

👇hugely exciting project underway!

[Hallie Stebbins @halliestebbins]

On shelves this week, Daniel Jackson’s The Essence of Software -- big ideas reimagining how we think about software design, for anyone who interacts with software. Much appreciation for everyone who has recommended this ambitious book. @mkapor @xeeliz @benbendc @haroldthimbleby

[Princeton University Press @PrincetonUPress]

Out today in North America (25 January in UK/Europe), The Essence of Software: Why Concepts Matter for Great Design by Daniel Jackson is a revolutionary concept-based approach to thinking about, designing, and interacting with software. https://t.co/Paoqxxio22 #ComputerScience

[Princeton University Press @PrincetonUPress]

We're hiring! PUP seeks a motivated, detail-oriented, and highly organized individual to support two editors to fill the role of Editorial Assistant: Science. Remote/hybrid work option. For more details: https://t.co/3tqpbSvXgs

[Hallie Stebbins @halliestebbins]

Happy pub day to @gershbrain! Revealing the computational logic underlying the failures -- and successes -- of human cognition, What Makes Us Smart is now out from @PrincetonUPress. https://t.co/k5ozwYpAQV

[Hallie Stebbins @halliestebbins]

👇half off our books through the 21st!!

[Princeton University Press @PrincetonUPress]

The Summer Sale has begun! Worldwide and sitewide (some exclusions apply) our hardcover and paperback books are 50% off with code PUP21. Shop now through July 21st and stock up! https://t.co/vw20zlgdBH #PUPSummerSale #PrincetonUPress

[Princeton University Press @PrincetonUPress]

News alert! We’re incredibly excited to announce the launch PUP Speaks, an in house speaker’s agency at Princeton University Press. Read more: https://t.co/ufrlVdMIgW #PrincetonUPress #PUPSpeaks @aupresses