Let's name exactly how Tata is being destroyed. And exactly who benefits. ๐ป
The documented facts:
๐ RBI orders Tata Sons - an Upper Layer NBFC - to go public
๐ Tata Sons board agrees to list - opposed by Tata Trusts who own 66% of Tata Sons
๐ Noel Tata calls Chandrasekaran's reappointment "illegal"
๐ Tata Sons consolidated net profit slipped 35% under current management
๐ Six Parsi/Zoroastrian organisations write to PM Modi to protect Tata's legacy
๐ New York Times calls it "government intervention" in India's most revered institution
๐ The Print: "Government push to force Tata Sons onto the stock market - turning a governance dispute into a national crisis"
Now the conflict of interest nobody is saying out loud:
๐ด A forced Tata Sons listing = dilution of Tata Trusts' 66% control
๐ด Tata Trusts fund hospitals, universities, research institutions; not shareholders
๐ด Forced listing = philanthropic structure dismantled. Permanently.
๐ด Chandrasekaran - the chairman at the centre of this - sits on boards of Modi government's strategic committees
๐ด The RBI Governor enforcing the listing order was appointed by the Modi government
๐ด The same government that weaponised ED, CBI and RBI against every business that didn't comply, is now using regulatory mandate to break the one conglomerate it doesn't yet control
Tata Trusts own 66%. If that 66% is diluted through a forced listing; who buys those shares? At what price? And who decides the timing?
J.R.D. Tata built this for India. Ratan Tata protected it for India. And it is being dismantled, through regulatory capture, for a handful.
Business leaders are silent. Because silence is now the price of survival in Modi's India.
But the Supreme Court is watching. The Parsi community is on record. The New York Times is watching. The BBC is watching.
India is watching. ๐ฎ๐ณ
๐จ The question isn't whether Tata will survive this. The question is: who is waiting to pick up the pieces?
Name them. Under oath. Before a JPC. Now.
They are pushing for the public listing of Tata Sons, the holding company, so that two capitalist cronies can drag down its share price and launch a hostile takeover through their shell companies.
And ultimately destroy the TATA brand, which has been an integral part of Indiaโs development.
NEWS: NYC is suing Activision, saying Bobby Kotick was unfit to negotiate the Microsoft deal--and that the deal was rushed to get him and the board out of danger of lawsuits over how they handled misconduct at the company
Details, complaint at the link
https://t.co/m7LVLaeaPd
I'm getting a strong sense that Biden narrowly wins the Presidency but Republicans hold the Senate.
This is the WORST POSSIBLE SCENARIO for stocks & (in the near-term) gold.