Top Tweets for #DefineGender

If we exclude confounding factors, how many "True Trans Children" remain? After removing children with autism, same-sex attraction, those in care, with trauma histories, or mental health comorbidities, how many children with innate, persistent gender dysphoria unrelated to these factors are left? Evidence from major reviews (Cass 2024, HHS 2025) and clinic data suggests extremely few - likely 5-10% at most, and possibly close to zero. The current surge in "trans children" is overwhelmingly explained by these overlapping vulnerabilities, not a standalone innate condition. Evidence: - Comorbidity Overlap: 70-90% of referrals have significant mental health issues (anxiety, depression, self-harm); autism rates 35-68%; trauma/abuse and family dysfunction is common. Children in care and those who later identify as gay/lesbian are heavily overrepresented (up to 80% in older cohorts). - After Exclusion: Removing these factors leaves a tiny fraction. European reviews (Finland 2020, Sweden 2022) describe "pure" cases as rare and usually resolving without medical intervention. - Historical Context: Until 2011–12, the UK's Tavistock clinic (the world's largest) treated fewer than 200 children per year - mostly young boys with no recorded comorbidities of this scale. The post-2014 explosion in numbers particularly girls correlates with social influences, not innate increase. From a child developmental science perspective, Piaget, Kohlberg, Bem, and others show no innate "trans" identity in children. Distress is typically a learned, flexible gender schema amplified by vulnerabilities and external cues. "True" cases without confounders are vanishingly rare, suggesting the phenomenon is largely socially constructed.