Top Tweets for #ReviewMill2
#ReviewMill #FakeReview #CoerciveCitation @MDPIOpenAccess @Polymers_MDPI
Round 1
Reviewer 1 #MiniReviewMill 7
Reviewer 3 Moustafa Mahmoud Yousry Zaghloul #ReviewMill2
Details in @PubPeer
https://t.co/pD2iqpsgU5
Should an #ExpressionOfConcern be released❓
#ExpressionOfConcern @MDPIOpenAccess @Coatings_MDPI
Round 1
Reviewer 1➡️Sachin Sirohi #ReviewMill3
Reviewer 2➡️Moustafa Mahmoud Yousry Zaghloul #ReviewMill2
Details in @PubPeer
https://t.co/S9JZv3yYWT
Should an #ExpressionOfConcern be released?
#ReviewMill2 #Epilogue #CoerciveCitation #FakeReview
Ending with >50 verysimilar review reports in @MDPIOpenAccess journals
https://t.co/2wJEAQuoUE
Reviewer’s (Moustafa Mahmoud Yousry Zaghloul) required articles citation analysis from @webofscience
⬇️
#ReviewMill2 #Episode6 #CoerciveCitation #FakeReview
Following with >50 very similar review reports in @MDPIOpenAccess journals
https://t.co/x6z8otegD4
I present now cases 51 to 55 and a bonus
@PubPeer for more detailed information
🧵
#ReviewMill2 #Episode6 #CoerciveCitation #FakeReview
Following with >50 very similar review reports in @MDPIOpenAccess journals
https://t.co/x6z8otegD4
I present now cases 51 to 55 and a bonus
@PubPeer for more detailed information
🧵
#ReviewMill2 #Episode5 #CoerciveCitation #FakeReview
Following with >50 very similar review reports in @MDPIOpenAccess journals
https://t.co/NdzjiJL2Ta
I present now cases 41 to 50
@PubPeer for more detailed information
50.
#ReviewMill2 #CoerciveCitation #FakeReview @Polymers_MDPI @MDPIOpenAccess
Reviewer 2 Moustafa Mahmoud➡️4 articles to be added in the introduction
Reviewer=coauthor of4⃣required articles
“The references to be included are”
https://t.co/wdpYytYzvm
48.
#ReviewMill2 #CoerciveCitation #FakeReview @Polymers_MDPI @MDPIOpenAccess
Reviewer 3 Moustafa Mahmoud Yousry Zaghloul➡️8 articles to be added
Reviewer=coauthor of8⃣required articles
Round 2➡️Reviewer insists
“The references to be included are”
https://t.co/vxlPUCDLAd
46.
#ReviewMill2 #CoerciveCitation #FakeReview @Polymers_MDPI @MDPIOpenAccess
Reviewer 2 Moustafa Mahmoud Yousry Zaghloul➡️5 articles to be added
Reviewer=coauthor of5⃣
Authors refused to add
Round 2➡️Reviewer insists➕Authors refused again
https://t.co/ftN1Or5ohi
43.
#ReviewMill2 #CoerciveCitation #FakeReview @Polymers_MDPI @MDPIOpenAccess
Reviewer 1 Moustafa Mahmoud➡️2 articles to be added in the introduction
Reviewer=coauthor of2⃣required articles
“The references to be included are”
https://t.co/gnOYAYRhoE
42.
#ReviewMill2 #CoerciveCitation #FakeReview @Materials_mdpi @MDPIOpenAccess
Reviewer 2 Moustafa Mahmoud➡️3 articles to be added in the introduction
Reviewer=coauthor of3⃣required articles
“The references to be included are”
https://t.co/svaeNPGLvm
41.
#ReviewMill2 #CoerciveCitation #FakeReview @Coatings_MDPI @MDPIOpenAccess
Reviewer 2 Moustafa Mahmoud Yousry Zaghloul➡️6 articles to be added in the introduction
Reviewer=coauthor of6⃣required articles
“The references to be included are”
https://t.co/eeCpA9DKlP
#ReviewMill2 #Episode5 #CoerciveCitation #FakeReview
Following with >50 very similar review reports in @MDPIOpenAccess journals
https://t.co/NdzjiJL2Ta
I present now cases 41 to 50
@PubPeer for more detailed information
#ReviewMill2 #Episode4 #CoerciveCitation #FakeReview
Following with >50 very similar review reports in @MDPIOpenAccess journals
https://t.co/bInoZjZRyz
I present now cases 31 to 40
@PubPeer for more detailed information.
#ReviewMill2 #Episode4 #CoerciveCitation #FakeReview
Following with >50 very similar review reports in @MDPIOpenAccess journals
https://t.co/bInoZjZRyz
I present now cases 31 to 40
@PubPeer for more detailed information.
#ReviewMill2 #Episode3 #CoerciveCitation #FakeReview
Following with >50 very similar review reports in @MDPIOpenAccess journals
https://t.co/xkJZiSh8wq
I present now cases 21 to 30
@PubPeer for more detailed information
🧵
30.
#ReviewMill2 #CoerciveCitation #FakeReview @Coatings_MDPI @MDPIOpenAccess
Reviewer 4 Moustafa Mahmoud➡️7 articles to be added in the introduction
Reviewer=coauthor of7⃣required articles
“The references to be included are”
https://t.co/9WTCfHzhgR
#ReviewMill2 #Episode3 #CoerciveCitation #FakeReview
Following with >50 very similar review reports in @MDPIOpenAccess journals
https://t.co/xkJZiSh8wq
I present now cases 21 to 30
@PubPeer for more detailed information
🧵
#ReviewMill2 #Episode2 #CoerciveCitation #FakeReview
Following with >50 very similar review reports in @MDPIOpenAccess journals
I present now cases 11 to 20
@PubPeer for more detailed information
https://t.co/xpJuH1e6jK
20.
#ReviewMill2 #CoerciveCitation #FakeReview @Coatings_MDPI @MDPIOpenAccess
Reviewer 3 Moustafa Mahmoud Yousry Zaghloul➡️2 articles to be added in the introduction
Reviewer=coauthor of2⃣required articles
“The references to be included are”
https://t.co/4rh3wpSjVJ
#ReviewMill2 #Episode2 #CoerciveCitation #FakeReview
Following with >50 very similar review reports in @MDPIOpenAccess journals
I present now cases 11 to 20
@PubPeer for more detailed information
https://t.co/xpJuH1e6jK
#ReviewMill2 #Episode1 #CoerciveCitation #FakeReview
Related with >50 very similar review reports in @MDPIOpenAccesss journals
https://t.co/VvUXCPH7Wr
I present now cases 1 to 10
@PubPeer for more detailed information.
Note: cases as they were found chronologically
🧵
10.
#ReviewMill2 #CoerciveCitation #FakeReview @jcsmdpicom @MDPIOpenAccesss
Reviewer 1: Moustafa Mahmoud Yousry Zaghloul➡️6articles to be added (introduction)
Reviewer=coauthor of6⃣required articles
Round2➡️Reviewer insits/Authors resist
Standard review
https://t.co/yrBxoMwYNM
#ReviewMill2 #Episode1 #CoerciveCitation #FakeReview
Related with >50 very similar review reports in @MDPIOpenAccesss journals
https://t.co/VvUXCPH7Wr
I present now cases 1 to 10
@PubPeer for more detailed information.
Note: cases as they were found chronologically
🧵
🚨🚨
#ReviewMillSeries #FakeReview #CoerciveCitation
SEASON 2
‼️Coming soon
🔹I chosed #ReviewMill2 as hashtag
🔹Details will also be posted at @PubPeer
Features ⬇️
#ReviewMill2 #FakeReview #CoerciveCitation
🔹Reviews performed from 02/05/22 to 13/02/23
🔹Reviewer’s citations @webofscience (29/01/2024)
2021➡️28
2022➡️515
2023➡️253
Thanks to @wool_yeah
https://t.co/zK6ZhE43JS
A texbook case of coercive citation manipulation means, by a certain scholar from the University of Queensland. There are much more stuff like this in @MDPIOpenAccess journals, literally dozens in 2H 2022.
Similar papers from 2023 exist, but the reviews are closed.
#ReviewMill2 #FakeReview #CoerciveCitation
🔹Reviewer = Moustafa Mahmoud Yousry Zaghloul
🔹55 review reports
🔹6 journals
Note: A previous alert about this reviewer at https://t.co/2FPrkpQggb by Alexander Magazinov
and...
Last Seen Hashtags on Sotwe
Trends for you
Most Popular Users
Elon Musk 
@elonmusk
241.2M followers
Barack Obama
@barackobama
119.1M followers
Cristiano Ronaldo
@cristiano
112.8M followers
Donald J. Trump
@realdonaldtrump
111.8M followers
Narendra Modi
@narendramodi
107.1M followers
Rihanna
@rihanna
98.3M followers
NASA
@nasa
92.3M followers
Justin Bieber
@justinbieber
91.4M followers
KATY PERRY
@katyperry
89M followers
Taylor Swift
@taylorswift13
82.9M followers
Lady Gaga
@ladygaga
74.4M followers
Virat Kohli
@imvkohli
71.9M followers
Kim Kardashian
@kimkardashian
70.4M followers
YouTube
@youtube
68.8M followers
Neymar Jr
@neymarjr
64.8M followers
Bill Gates
@billgates
64.6M followers
The Ellen Show
@theellenshow
62.4M followers
Selena Gomez
@selenagomez
62M followers
CNN
@cnn
61.8M followers
X
@x
60.8M followers