The latest disclosure of an HMRC briefing note provided to the then FST in July 2019 makes for some more chilling reading. https://t.co/dsMCiyvr3E
It appears that HMRC did not like the previous draft of the standard letter being sent to all MPs.
1/17
Our survey of people facing the #LoanCharge clearly shows:
1. Most people simply cannot pay.
2. Many people have lost income due to the IR35 off-payroll rules & the pandemic.
3. The vast majority of people were mis-sold schemes.
#LoanChargeScandal
https://t.co/tlfYPFuaUP
Despite knowing the #LoanCharge had no legal basis, Jim Harra's only concern was to "peel away the support [Loan Charge victims] have gained from MPs and peers". So much for government's pledge to create a "Trusted, modern tax administration". @keir_starmer: time to act on this.
The disclosures in short:
1. LC is a "debacle" per top HMRC official.
2. It's designed for HMRC's convenience.
3. Despite "principled objections" to LC, government refused to change policy.
4. HMRC try to help government maintain the chosen narrative.
Did it w/ 20 chars to spare.
@Jesse_Norman@hmtreasury@HMRCgovuk The @loanchargeAPPG report completely invalidates any claim whatsoever that @HMRCgovuk communicated their concerns over schemes effectively
More importantly, that the law was NOT clear from 2010 as claimed in the flawed Morse #LoanCharge report
Yes transparency is needed Jesse
What’s everyone’s thoughts on the wording on setttlement offer letter from HMRC. It’s like they know this is unproven and in event it will be proved to not be due in future then I can’t claim back what I pay 🤔 #LoanChargeScandal@loanchargeAPPG@keithmgordon@LCAG_2019
Great work Julia. It's a story I've heard dozens of times over the last two years. Honest, hard-working law-abiding people. Duped into taking out arrangements by individuals who believe they are above the law. Victims face ruin. Those responsible live the high life. #loancharge
When will HMRC be held accountable for misleading #LoanCharge evidence? LCAG writes to @LordsEconCom re Mary Aiston's claims on selection of experts for 'independent' #LoanCharge.
That undermines any argument that the loan charge has been effective to end these schemes, because this number suggests these schemes are even more widespread than ever.
If not, is this another case of HMRC citing irrelevant data to improve the impression of their performance?
@wealthagent@RobbieT014 The #LoanCharge campaign can only be described as a sad failure, when factoring in the poor settlements take-up (including HMRC actively blocking such), continued take-up of new loan arrangements (including zero action on loan promoters), family destruction and suicides. Madness
@NO2019LoanCharg@HCsick@keithmgordon @GarethParris @LordsEconCom Same here. I asked for 10years TTP, they’ve given me 3 years and have to get legal charge on home for the difference which is exactly the total equity on my home that I had to put in the paperwork to them!
Next week the Finance Bill Sub-Committee takes evidence on changes to the Loan Charge following the Morse review. Witnesses include @CIOTnews, @teamIPSE and @LCAG_2019. Read more here ⬇️https://t.co/DJvwssSaye
@HMRCgovuk If you are told a tax QC has said that what you are doing is within the rules who should be punished?
a) the tax QC
b) the promoter who hired the QC and sold the arrangement on their advice
c) the end user who believed (a) and (b) were telling the truth
#LoanChargeScandal