Okay, as a (somewhat) experienced writer…
Although a stand-alone fic (such as I wrote) can wring maximum drama out of Dracaena and Harry not confessing their feelings until the very, very end, I agree with those who argue that in a full-length Malfoid rewrite of the whole HP epic, this last-second reconciliation would be very hard to pull off believably and effectively. Having them reconnect earlier in the story is probably the way to go, not least because it massively raises the emotional stakes of Harry learning he is the last Horcrux and being forced to sacrifice himself.
Option 2 (Room of Requirement) is by far the easier/simpler choice for this. The Battle of Hogwarts is already underway, only two Horcruxes remain, there is now a real hope of defeating Voldemort, everyone in Hogwarts is fighting for their lives – all of which makes it psychologically much easier for Dracaena to admit her true feelings and join Harry's side without perceiving herself as thereby betraying her parents to their deaths. This easier choice in turn reduces the character-development burden on the author.
Option 1 appeals to writers who want Harry and Dracaena to have more time to express their true feelings before the finale, but it creates a lot more of a storytelling challenge due to the much higher "friction" at that point of the narrative between Dracaena's conflicting loyalties. It's easy to see her covertly helping Harry at the Manor (concealing his identity, maybe even slipping him a wand); it is very difficult to see her willingly abandoning her family at this point. (Hence why the one Malfoid fic I've seen try this up to now has Harry basically kidnap her.)
That doesn’t make this option impossible, but it means writers who want to do this will need to build the groundwork for it much earlier in how they depict Harry and Dracaena’s relationship and Dracaena's character development. She will have to already hold serious doubts about her family loyalty. Sectumsempra or its aftermath might need to turn out differently as well.
One possible approach here would be the depiction of Voldemort giving her the Dark Mark. The usual assumption here is that she blames Voldy for everything and sees her parents as victims of the Dark Lord just like she is. But a clever writer who’s been laying the right foundations in Years 1 through 5 can make this go the other direction: Dracaena starts to blame her parents for putting her into this impossible situation, seeing them as betraying her love. (Bellatrix's insane villainy could also be leveraged to make this work.) So Dracaena could ultimately turn to Harry as her savior from both Voldemort and her family.
#malfoid
A new challenge to writers. When Malfoid should join the Golden Trio and redeem herself?
1. Escaping Malfoy Manor and witnessing Dobby's death.
2. The final battle, in the Room of Requirement.
Option 1 seems nice, but there's still the issue of how to save Malfoid's parents
I actually do a lot of the cooking in our house. Been experimenting with traditional Italian pasta lately.
Pasta with chicken and garlic butter:
2 chicken breasts.
1 box pasta (spaghetti or linguine).
Fresh garlic, five-six cloves diced or preferably put through a garlic press.
8-ounce wedge of Parmesan and/or Romano cheese, fresh-grated.
Butter, 1 stick plus cooking-butter for the chicken.
Tomato paste.
Half an onion, diced/minced fine.
Italian-herb mix for the chicken.
Salt/pepper to taste.
Preferred cooking implement: A stainless steel pan with high sides.
Saute the herb-seasoned chicken breasts, then remove, dice up, and set aside.
While boiling the pasta (use well-salted water), melt the butter in the pan (this will also deglaze the "fond" from the chicken) and cook the garlic and onions in it. Use LOW heat, you want to do this slowly and not burn the garlic or turn the butter brown. Toward the end, add the tomato paste, then start adding modest amounts of pasta water to smooth it out.
As soon as the pasta is "al dente" put it in the pan with more pasta water. Mix and toss, the pasta will absorb the butter, then start adding the grated cheese along with more pasta water, mixing/tossing to combine. Salt and pepper to taste. You will rapidly get a creamy sauce coating everything.
Add the diced chicken at the end so it can also be coated with the sauce.
Serve and eat immediately. This is enough for three or four people.
@Sheepfarmer373 Wow, that would be QUITE the divergence from the canon storyline. But a very interesting one!
And then you get an Adayasmr-type version of Year Seven, with Dracaena joining the Golden Trio for the entire arc.
Okay, as a (somewhat) experienced writer…
Although a stand-alone fic (such as I wrote) can wring maximum drama out of Dracaena and Harry not confessing their feelings until the very, very end, I agree with those who argue that in a full-length Malfoid rewrite of the whole HP epic, this last-second reconciliation would be very hard to pull off believably and effectively. Having them reconnect earlier in the story is probably the way to go, not least because it massively raises the emotional stakes of Harry learning he is the last Horcrux and being forced to sacrifice himself.
Option 2 (Room of Requirement) is by far the easier/simpler choice for this. The Battle of Hogwarts is already underway, only two Horcruxes remain, there is now a real hope of defeating Voldemort, everyone in Hogwarts is fighting for their lives – all of which makes it psychologically much easier for Dracaena to admit her true feelings and join Harry's side without perceiving herself as thereby betraying her parents to their deaths. This easier choice in turn reduces the character-development burden on the author.
Option 1 appeals to writers who want Harry and Dracaena to have more time to express their true feelings before the finale, but it creates a lot more of a storytelling challenge due to the much higher "friction" at that point of the narrative between Dracaena's conflicting loyalties. It's easy to see her covertly helping Harry at the Manor (concealing his identity, maybe even slipping him a wand); it is very difficult to see her willingly abandoning her family at this point. (Hence why the one Malfoid fic I've seen try this up to now has Harry basically kidnap her.)
That doesn’t make this option impossible, but it means writers who want to do this will need to build the groundwork for it much earlier in how they depict Harry and Dracaena’s relationship and Dracaena's character development. She will have to already hold serious doubts about her family loyalty. Sectumsempra or its aftermath might need to turn out differently as well.
One possible approach here would be the depiction of Voldemort giving her the Dark Mark. The usual assumption here is that she blames Voldy for everything and sees her parents as victims of the Dark Lord just like she is. But a clever writer who’s been laying the right foundations in Years 1 through 5 can make this go the other direction: Dracaena starts to blame her parents for putting her into this impossible situation, seeing them as betraying her love. (Bellatrix's insane villainy could also be leveraged to make this work.) So Dracaena could ultimately turn to Harry as her savior from both Voldemort and her family.
#malfoid
A new challenge to writers. When Malfoid should join the Golden Trio and redeem herself?
1. Escaping Malfoy Manor and witnessing Dobby's death.
2. The final battle, in the Room of Requirement.
Option 1 seems nice, but there's still the issue of how to save Malfoid's parents
@DeadWhisperof I keep using the word "miraculous" for the Malfoid phenomenon.
Something like this -- a character emerging a quarter-century later from the collective ideas of dozens of strangers, yet making the original work better in every way -- SHOULD NOT BE POSSIBLE.
And yet it happened.
Of those options, 2 is by far the "simpler" option for a writer. The Battle of Hogwarts is already underway, only two Horcruxes remain, there is a real hope of defeating Voldemort. This makes it psychologically easier for Dracaena to admit her true feelings and join Harry's side without perceiving herself as thereby betraying her parents to their deaths.
Option 1 creates a lot more "friction" between Dracaena's conflicting loyalties. It's easy to see her covertly helping Harry at the Manor (concealing his identity, maybe even slipping him a wand); it is very difficult to see her willingly abandoning her family at this point. Hence why the one Malfoid fic I've seen pull this off has Harry basically kidnap her.
Now, the wild card here is how their relationship has gone and how Dracaena's character has evolved prior to this point. In a story where she's already formed deep doubts about her family loyalty, maybe where sectumsempra turned out better -- like in Adayasmr's version -- it is possible to see her switching sides earlier. But the author would have to plan for this and set it up very carefully.