As reported by @rustybrick and @SERPalerts a couple days ago, Google is testing a login wall on search.
On Nov 18, for about ten hours, our SERP collection fell by as much as 98%, across several providers simultaneously.
Google is testing eliminating incognito searches
My dog when dinner is an hour and ten minutes away and “all” he’s had today is…
Breakfast
Lunch
Some turkey from my lunch (given, not stolen)
Three treats
Basically starving.
1️⃣ Stop chasing keywords
💡 Every conversation is rooted in keywords
2️⃣ Stop the “Top 10” listicle
💡Stop citing listicles.
3️⃣ Stop trusting proxy scores
💡Good idea! Now tag AIO and AI Mode clicks with UTMs and we will.
We will, apparently, do anything to avoid being part of a real company that offers a thing that people love.
Instead, we will create bullshit offers like 2010 era blog networks repositioned as GEO. Reddit spam called GEO. SEO packages from eight years ago relabeled as GEO with a one hundred percent markup.
🤷
If you want to build an AEO program that gets vaporized by model and harness updates, focus on the exact patterns that drive mentions and citations right now (eg lists, comparisons, alternatives, etc).
If you want to be good at AEO in a durable long-term way, focus on driving SOV expansion on the channels (search, youtube, some social) that are inputs to AI visibility.
Build world-class programs in search, youtube, social and pr. And then surgically address point in time AEO gaps.
Some people struggle to balance these ideas but a simple thing I have done is split the backlog 50:50.
50% is things I believe will put points on the board right now to build momentum and confidence.
50% is the most important long-term things that might not land this month or this quarter, but that will drive step change performance improvements in the future.
Working across multiple time horizons is foundational for building things that compound.
You really feel it the first time you make a quarter because something you did nine months ago.
And then your brain re-wires and you realize your job as a growth leader is to have a growth plan for the next year+ but that plan is not about growth 12 months from now, it’s about growth from now on.
“You can revoke a user's access. You can change what the model is willing to do. When a model is released in an uncontrolled manner, there's no ability to do that. It's entirely out of your hands.”
And the mask slips. It's all about control, all about being able to grant or refuse permission.
Amodei, you may think you're doing this for "safety", but what the fuck do you think Is going to happen when the psychopaths who infect governments get such power?
An AI-enabled boot grinding a human face, forever.
General 'ramble at claude via voice chat and then tell it to clean it up as a tweet'. Let 'er rip if ya feel like it.
I think you've been pretty clear. This is a moment where execs want this work. There's expanded scope and budget to go get. Call it whatever you want, but go get that work.
That's fine. Smart. Good marketing. Probably more sensible than me from a pure business standpoint.
I'm, probably too stubbornly, much more team... No. I'm not going to call it a new thing that implies we all just got here. If you've been reco'ing these things for years - own it. Say so. Point out that SEOs were already here. There's no need to shy away from the fact that what they want now is mostly very solid SEO recommendations already. My take is basically "Welcome to the party - glad you finally caught on and want the work SEOs have been pushing for, let's go."
If some CMO needs their ego protected because they ignored SEO for years and now need to act like buying a bunch of SEO work is this new and different thing, I'm good without their cash. 🤷
I think I finally figured out why the SEO vs GEO thing sticks in my craw so much.
The things that would have laid the groundwork for good AI search performance today are the things SEOs have been talking about for 10 years.
Next year is the 10-year anniversary of Traffic Think Tank. I know for a fact hundreds of people have been talking about the stuff that’s now making the rounds as “new approaches” for surfacing in ChatGPT, AI Overviews and Claude. (Not Perplexity. Nobody seems to care about Perplexity anymore.)
This should be the victory lap. This is when you look at the CMO who ignored your requests and your advice for a decade and say “I fucking told you so.”
Instead, loud voices in the SEO community are saying we should repackage it. Call it GEO. Pretend to the CMOs (who didn’t want to listen to their SEO teams) that this is all new. That they haven’t heard it for the last 10 years. That they haven’t been sitting in C-level seats knowing nothing about how the channel actually operates.
So instead of telling them we knew better this entire time, the advice is to kowtow. Use the language they want to use. Make believe it’s all new and different, and they’re so smart for finally wanting to do it. “Oh gosh, who could have seen this coming? We better get on this right away.”
Say whatever they want to hear, because they control the money.
Maybe it’s because I’m lucky enough that I don’t need to close X deals in the next three months to pay my mortgage. I’m good. So maybe that’s my privilege showing. I don’t have to make believe, and other people do, because they decided to run an agency and have full-time salaries to pay. If you have to say the shibboleth to make your bills next month, okay. Fine.
But that doesn’t define what’s true. It defines what’s commercially useful.
And I’m entirely uninterested in saying things I don’t think are true just because they’re commercially useful.
If that’s where you are, I feel bad for you, frankly. Every single time I hear the “new” GEO work explained, I can think of five blog posts from seven years ago that describe exactly the same thing.
You’re playing a bullshit game to impress dumb CMOs so they’ll pay you. I get it. Money’s important. But don’t shit a shitter. Don’t pretend when you’re talking to me that this is new or different or revolutionary. It’s the same bullshit you were doing eight years ago. You’re just calling it something else and charging more.
And if you can get more money for the same old shit with a new coat of paint, good for you. I’m as staunchly pro-capitalist as anyone. I respect and applaud your right to get money from dumb people.
Just don’t expect me to pretend publicly that they’re not dumb.
It's still "just" SEO.
And if you’ve been saying this stuff for a decade, take your well-earned victory lap.
Good morning, Crawlers!
Welcome to the eleventh floor of the Organic Search dungeon.
This season of the crawl is proudly sponsored by the Alphabet Corporation, who also own the dungeon.
Now, some quick patch notes.
It has come to our attention that some crawlers were using sponsored listicles to take advantage of the System AI. Very clever. We love to see that kind of initiative.
It has been patched in our latest update. Crawlers who relied on this exploit will find their rankings have been adjusted accordingly.
A reminder about loot: reaching position one no longer guarantees a click. The System AI now answers the query for the user, using your content. You’re welcome.
The rules for this floor have not changed. Make helpful content for users. The definition of “helpful” has not been published.
That is all. Now get out there and rank, rank, rank!