This started as a discussion about stats, but is quickly devolving into shifting arguments and personal attacks, so I'm going to bail.
For what it's worth, you do have a point and we share common ground. But I think you've lost the plot a bit after I challenged your interpretation of the stats.
Unfortunately, I think the incentives are increasingly pushing in this direction.
Virtually every developer I know is using AI.
The cost of "missing out" keeps increasing, so devs are going to integrate AI more as time goes on.
But the cost of "admitting" to AI can also be high. And if the perceived consequences of getting caught are no worse than admitting it in the first place, there's a pretty strong incentive to keep your mouth shut.
AFAIK, Steam hasn't defined penalties for failing to disclose, so it relies heavily on honesty. But honesty can invite hostility and potentially serious commercial consequences.
Add to that an environment of increasing competition, layoffs, and economic uncertainty, and yeah, people are going to lie.
Sure, which is why I was up front about that. That's not the gotcha you think it is, since I volunteered the info. And yes, it's a select group, mostly people who have several decades of experience at this point.
But originally, you claimed most AI users wouldn't even be devs without AI, now you're shifting that group to being aging senior devs.
If you don't like AI use, that's OK. I'm not happy about the rise of AI, and what it's doing to the profession. But you're trying really hard to paint users of AI as "not real devs", when the scarier part is that they are devs. And AI use is rising.
Uhh... the Industrial Revolution destroyed many people's livelihoods, drove entire trades into poverty, some of whom never recovered. You know that right?
The qol for the average person was better for it eventually, but that doesn't mean that it wasn't rough going for a lot of people caught in the transition.
Also, Luddites were skilled workers protesting falling wages, unemployment, etc. Nobody wants to see their earning-potential evaporate, especially if you have a life/family/obligations that depend on that income. Surely you can understand that?
Look, I'm neither defending nor attacking AI use here, but those stats, as stated, are misleading.
You're claiming "less than 40%" of gamedevs use generative AI, and then speculating that most of those people wouldn't even be gamedevs without it.
The latest GDC survey found 40% generative AI adoption across game industry professionals, up from 36%. It also found that 54% of respondents aged 45+ use generative AI. Maybe they're all middle-aged newcomers, but I somehow doubt it. I'd bet it's the more experienced devs.
If we're going to use stats, let's be honest about what they actually say.
The more interesting statistic, to me, is that 55% believe generative AI is negatively affecting the industry.
That's pretty much in line with my original post. Adoption is growing, but people remain concerned about the consequences.
You can find a technology useful, or feel pressure to adopt it, while simultaneously believing it may damage the industry you work in.
Those positions aren't mutually exclusive.
@humaniproject I think that's 100% a great way to approach it. I'm not advocating for, or against, AI, but pointing out that a perverse incentive exists for users of AI to lie about it.
For some people, yeah, that's certainly part of their opposition to AI.
Among the artists and programmers I know who are facing layoffs, unemployment, and the hardships that follow from that, anger directed at AI is more about the work displacement and economic uncertainty that comes with it.
Agreed, benefits/value is real.
I'd guess a lot of the hostility and desire to dismiss is rooted in fear. People are watching skills they've spent decades developing become increasingly automated. Careers they've built their lives around suddenly look uncertain. Kids are graduating with debt into a job market that may be changing underneath them.
At some point, hopefully everyone is enjoying an increased qol from AI, but that doesn't mean the people caught in the chaotic transition time can't be a little pissy about drawing the short end of the stick.
Yeah, there seems to be a lot of frustration towards studios, and maybe some of it is justified.
I'd caution against conflating the decisions made by executives with the people whose careers and livelihoods may be disrupted by what's coming. They weren't the ones making those decisions, but they may be the ones paying the price.
"The gaming industry" isn't some monolithic entity. It's people.
PETAFAB just released on Steam at $9.99:
https://t.co/YL3qEmZ9WW
PC, Mac and Steam Deck/Machine. 90Hz on Steam Deck OLED. Up to 540Hz + 8000Hz late-latch mouse on high end PC for ultra-low latency.
Let's see if you can beat my high scores :D
An old videotape should feel safe. Whatever happened on it is already over.
Until you hear footsteps behind you.
The moment you turn around, you stop being a spectator.
Some mysteries were never meant to be solved.
Built in @threejs. Play in browser 👇
The new Three.js Water Pro v4 update is nearly feature complete! Enjoy a quick tour of the new island archipelago 🏝️
Getting the shorelines to look nice and not kill performance has been the hardest part.
The typical solution requires a computationally intensive shallow water solver. I found a way to bake most of the calculations to get around this and only use a very fast solver for the leading edge of the swash.
As an end user, all you need to do is register the terrain with a single function call and that's it. No drawing shorelines or anything.
Last remaining "hard part" is generating spray where the water hits the rocks.
In need of some nice, stylised, human-made 3D assets? I've got pretty much everything you need to make your own dungeon crawler and then some :D Most of them are completely FREE too :)
https://t.co/2GJm3FqJex
#gamedev
Created some spooky trees for halloween 🎃
A new species available in Just a simple tree: a near dead, tortuous tree that only grows at night.
https://t.co/Mp5ts7DurA
#threejs#webgpu#gamedev
@SebAaltonen@ThreatInteract Will be happy to throw it onto a few devices for testing purposes.
Play through is probably a no-go, I can't play shooters anymore without headaches, getting old 🙃
@SebAaltonen@ThreatInteract No worries, there's no real deadline. If you find yourself with some time and have something interesting you'd like to share, I'd be happy to work with you on it and show off the game in the process.