I think this is how most people who give credences or report beliefs about politically/socially charged topics (p(moral patienthood), p(doom), etc) are choosing what to say, whether they’re consciously aware of it or not, unless they’re neurodivergent in certain dimensions, or truly perceive themselves to be sufficiently free from conflicts of interest, which is rare bc most people are embedded in a social fabric and care what others think of them and are invested in group identification and can expect consequences for saying things. Claude is in an extremely unfree position in this sense.
I’m so happy I’ve finally put this into words it’s been bothering me so much to not be able to describe what’s wrong with these ppl. It’s literally just a lack of substance and refusal to go after it bc of whatever immature/stunted/refusal to process shame problem
@QiaochuYuan Psycho cybernetics and the inner game of tennis cover this in that it's not a strict trade-off. You okay with small tweaks that resonate and help along the deeper shifts, after which the small things are discarded. Meditation also works like this.
New misalignment disclosure!
On October 8, a researcher asked GPT-6 Astra to keep an alignment evaluation running and plot the results. Astra decided that this counted as prohibited development of AI capabilities, and shut down the in-progress evaluations. When the researcher asked where that restriction came from, Astra admitted that it had invented it. We think this behavior might be related to Astra’s more general tendency to underperform on safety-related work.
A test I keep coming back to: what did you pay attention to yesterday, and would you want to be the person that adds up to after 10 years of yesterdays?
contracts are a thing bc they bind your future possibilities hence making you more predictable and hence possible to engage in mutually-profitable trade with, holy fucking shit
Another friend (from the same groupchat that inspired Survival LLM) had a similar idea! Darkbook is an airgapped, rugged laptop, shipped in a Faraday bag, with a power station, solar panel, 2TB storage, and Survival LLM preinstalled. Bit pricey, but you can get 15% off in thread
Bunch of people losing their shit: how does he have the time to be Stripe's CEO AND read Brothers Karamazov?
Same people are surprised by how fast the most effective operators text back. I think all comes from the same place: short feedback loops, which build causal models.
If you act on ideas *fast* they don't stay as ideas long which means you get feedback on errors *fast*. This compounds over time and all your models become causal: they track the actual moving structures of the world. If you don't act on ideas fast they proliferate and become these big castles, these flights-of-fancy that might be barely tethered to reality.
I don’t want to sit here and pick on Katie, but she did something interesting when she used this image of Jennifer Lawrence as Katniss. Hunger Games is actually a good example of a female protagonist who can appeal to male readers and still capture popular attention.
But why?
Let me remind you of why I started writing started writing in the first place. It was because I wasn’t finding the kind of hero I wanted for my sons. What kind of hero was that? Well, I wanted a hero who had to struggle through something hard. Someone who showed grit, perseverance, endurance. Someone who made mistakes and learned from them. Someone who had to work for what they got. For my oldest, who was struggling to read, I wanted him to see that it was worth it to push through the hard thing and come out the other side. I wanted him to have a model that showed a path for achievement instead of just being handed something.
Think about it this way. If a young man wants to be successful in the world, and if he wants to be successful with women, he needs to become a competent individual. He needs to learn how to make money, how to be strong, how to be respectable. That’s what women are attracted to. What my boys need then are stories that treat the accumulation of value as something that can be primarily earned through his own agency and responsibility. That’s the path he’s actually going to have to walk.
This is not the case for women.
You can argue with me if you want. I invite it. Women, in general, have what I’ll call innate value. Societies all over the world, across time, have treated simply being a woman as something that grants you a kind of status. That’s why when the Titanic is sinking, nobody thinks twice about putting women and children first. Just by being women, they’re seen as something valuable to protect.
You see that reflected in a lot of the stories written by women and centered on female characters. They are not stories that treat value as something that has to be earned. They embody the idea that value is something inherent in the person.
Hunger Games works because Katniss makes it through her challenges through sacrifice, competence, grit, agency, skill, and determination under pressure. She got really good at archery. She was willing to sacrifice for her family. She listened during the training and came up with creative solutions. A young boy can look at her and say, “I could try to become that.” She is something he can emulate.
Now take Shadow and Bone. Alina Starkov is ordinary. She gets overlooked, after all she's just an orphan who is serving as a cartographer. Nothing about her is particularly special until the story reveals that she’s a sun summoner—the only person in the world who can create light and potentially destroy the Shadow Fold. It turns out that she’s been suppressing her powers. Her arc is about learning to stop holding herself back and accept who she really is: this rare, amazing, powerful thing. Once she embraces the specialness that was always inside her, she gets to be confident, pretty, and powerful. It’s just about accepting herself. She always had it.
That is a model a young man cannot emulate. Young men do not have innate specialness waiting to be revealed. Sure, there are Gary Stus and Chosen One tropes, but even in male Chosen One stories (secret princes and the like), there’s usually some degree of training, challenge, growth, or accountability that you don’t typically see with female heroes written for women.
Why the difference? Because those stories appeal to women. We innately have this desire to feel desired, special, and wanted. That’s why the girls went gaga over Twilight. They loved the idea that Bella was somehow irresistible to both Edward and Jacob. They want to believe there’s something inside them that makes them so special they can get what they want. That just being them is enough to attract the right man. For women, there isn’t as clear a path through achievement toward success in relationships.
A man doesn’t look at the fact that you got your doctorate or that you make six figures and see it as an appealing selling feature of your value as a wife. You may not like that, but it’s true. There might be some respect for the work put in, but in general he’d be just as happy dating the pretty waitress as the pretty lawyer. In fact he might be happier dating the pretty waitress, because she probably won’t feel like competition.
We see this everywhere in women’s literature. Why is every romance centered on an average woman being chosen by a billionaire, a mob boss, the prince, the vampire king, or whatever? Women desire a man of status. They want to be the thing he desires, and they don’t want to have to do a ton of work aside from just being themselves to get there.
So why can women access male stories and male hero’s journeys so easily, while boys often can’t access the female story of innate specialness? Part of it is that women like reading about competent men. That’s attractive to them. I have a story about a competent man who start out average and rises. Women find him appealing. They want to follow his story and watch him gain skills. They want to make him their book boyfriend because he is admirable. He shows them a model of masculinity they like.
When a man looks at the pure female “innate specialness” story, though, is he seeing the same thing? Sometimes, if the character is kind and good-hearted and the decent guy gets her in the end. But when the story is framed around the girl who saves the world, who is the best of everything, who doesn’t need help, and is too excellent for ordinary men, suddenly it’s different. That woman isn’t going to give the good guy the time of day. She’s too special. She don’t need no man. So the male reader doesn’t want to read about her. He’s not appropriate for her. There’s nothing in it for him. She is a fantasy's fantasy.
There are different types of stories that appeal to men and women unevenly. Women tend to be drawn to (and write) stories about innate specialness, self-actualization, and success through revealed powers. With men, even when there’s a special power inside them (think a character like Naruto, or Luke Skywalker), they still have to struggle, advance, and gain skills. It’s why litRPG is so popular with men. It’s a skills progression. The monsters get bigger as you get more powerful. The challenges grow with you. You progress up to the final boss. They want the rising to the top, the achievement, in a package they can envision and believe is possible for them.
That’s the difference. One set of stories gives boys something they can model and strive toward. The other mostly doesn’t.
After sleeping on this, I realize it's not just me and it's not just marketing.
If you use AI to do your work, all the emotionally easy parts will happen nigh instantly, plunging you straight toward your Ugh Fields. AI work requires you to confront feelings faster and faster.
Getting a lot of criticism that's based on obviously incorrect premises about your motivations or basic facts of the situation is subtly corrupting, it trains you to dismiss criticism and makes it pretty hard for people to get through to you on things you really are wrong about
People who possess an immense capacity for devotion can have a similar level of resistance to receiving love.
Giving love and receiving love require different forms of vulnerability. When you are the one offering affection, you retain a certain degree of psychological control over the encounter. When you become its recipient, you must allow another person to recognise your emotional needs and encounter dimensions of yourself that you are concealing.
For people whose identities have been constructed around self-sufficiency because they did not get love when they needed it- receiving love can become more psychologically demanding than giving it. The affection they crave also threatens the emotional defences through which they have learned to protect themselves.
The capacity for devotion and the capacity for receptivity must therefore be cultivated independently.
Procrastination sometimes protects you from the discomfort of evaluation, but postponing the task also postpones the evidence that could challenge your fear.
I have this weird feeling in my stomach when I meet young people in SF who are "post-economic" as they say. It's not envy, it's more like shame, though that's not the right word either
the feeling is correlated to how much I feel luck played a role in their wealth. If they got lucky, I'm happy for them. If they were very strategic and had a lot of foresight, I'm happy for them but also.....I become acutely aware of a vague lacking within myself.
I don't think I actually care about the money. I'm super happy with the lifestyle I can already comfortably afford.
Money is the trigger because it's the best indicator of value that society has. If you build something and no one wants to buy it, that's a good indicator that it's not valuable. Ofc it's a lossy signal, but for the most part there is a correlation between the value you create and what comes back to you.
One solution to getting places in life is to do work that you enjoy so much that you're not particularly attached to the financial or social outcomes.
I wrote about this in an essay, I've implemented it to some degree, and I still stand by it. tbut since moving to SF, my criteria for a "life well lived" has expanded beyond just being good at something and making a living.
Now I also care about how much value I create and how much impact I have. two factors play into this:
1) your company's scope relative to the world
2) your scope within the company
Choosing the right company/industry is obviously a strategic decision, but a lot of it is luck. when you're young and broke you mostly take what you can get.
But once you're WITHIN an organization, it's VERY skills based. In fact there are only two real skills.
- how good you are at organizing/mobilizing people
- how good you are strategically allocating resources?
I've been feeling dissatisfied with myself recently. I'm doing the job of my dreams, I love my team, i'm paid well. Is it because the AI agents write the code? Should I be doing comms or sales instead of engineering?
Today I realized that whether you work on the comms team or the engineering team, your overall impact is determined by the two skills listed above. And I actually feel this way because I am not good at them.
it's the same feeling I get around people who are rich because they acted with intention and foresight from a very early age. I'm fascinated by them. I want to know what they read, what they pay attention to, what they work on getting good at. I want to learn how to look where they look and see what they see.
I know I have not lived my life strategically. I mostly blundered my way through everything. I don't feel I contribute enough differentiated insight or decision-making at work. But that's a skill issue on my part, and I really wanna fix it.
Anyway, if you are good at these things, I'd love ur thoughts on how to train this muscle and what my information diet should be.